Gustav 
          MAHLER 
          (1860-1911) Symphony 
          No.4 in G Major (1899-1900)  Camilla Tilling (Soprano) Philharmonia Orchestra/Benjamin Zander Walthamstow 
          Assembly Hall, London. June 6-8, 2000 Includes a free 70 minute discussion 
          disc
 
          Camilla Tilling (Soprano) Philharmonia Orchestra/Benjamin Zander Walthamstow 
          Assembly Hall, London. June 6-8, 2000 Includes a free 70 minute discussion 
          disc  TELARC 2CD-80555 
          [77.21]
 TELARC 2CD-80555 
          [77.21] 
         
        
A 
          patrician and thought-provoking guide to Mahler’s most approachable 
          symphony casting the last movement in its correct perspective. 
        
Felix 
          MENDELSSOHN (1809-1847) 
           
          String Quartet in E flat major, Opus 12 String 
          Quartet in A minor, Opus 7  Leipzig String Quartet Rec 
          22-25 May 2000, Rathaus, Markleeburg
 
          Leipzig String Quartet Rec 
          22-25 May 2000, Rathaus, Markleeburg  MDG 307 1055-2 [54.10] [TB]
 
          MDG 307 1055-2 [54.10] [TB]
         
        
The 
          Leipzig Quartet score when it comes to points of detail, with the virtuosity 
          of individual players allocated a higher priority in the recorded balance. 
          Swings and roundabouts, then in a head-to-head with the ASV-Vellinger 
          disc.  
        
Felix 
          MENDELSSOHN (1809-1847) 
          String 
          Quartet in E flat major, Opus 12 String Quartet in A minor, Opus 7 
          Fugue in E flat major, Opus 81 No. 4  Vellinger String Quartet Rec 2-3 March 1999, St George's Brandon Hill, 
          Bristol
 
          Vellinger String Quartet Rec 2-3 March 1999, St George's Brandon Hill, 
          Bristol  ASV CD QS 6236 
          [60.48] [TB]
ASV CD QS 6236 
          [60.48] [TB] 
        
In 
          both performances the Vellingers play immaculately, but also with great 
          expressive freedom. The attention to detail in matters of dynamic nuance 
          brings much reward too: this is quartet playing of the highest order.
        
André 
          MESSAGER 
          (1853-1929) Véronique 
          - operetta (complete with dialogue)  Mady Mesplé (Hélène), Andrea Guiot, Denise Benoit, 
          Michel Dens (Florestan), Jean-Christophe Benoit, Michel Dunand, Jacques 
          Pruvost
 
          Mady Mesplé (Hélène), Andrea Guiot, Denise Benoit, 
          Michel Dens (Florestan), Jean-Christophe Benoit, Michel Dunand, Jacques 
          Pruvost 
          René Duclos Choir Orchestre de l’Association des Concerts Lamoureux/Jean-Claude 
          Hartemann Rec. Paris, 1969  EMI 
          72435 7407328 [CD1 48.46 CD2 47.33] [RW]
EMI 
          72435 7407328 [CD1 48.46 CD2 47.33] [RW]
        
Messager's 
          gift lies in warm melodies and harmonies that are easy on the ear. His 
          orchestration has a classical suppleness and charm. The soloists both 
          sing and act well with the required element of fun and delight.  
        
Nikolai 
          MIASKOVSKY (1881-1950) 
          Symphony 
          No. 6 (1923)  Slovak 
          National Opera Choir Czecho-Slovak Radio SO/Robert Stankovsky rec The 
          Concert Hall, Slovak Radio, Bratislava, 25-30 Mar 1991
 Slovak 
          National Opera Choir Czecho-Slovak Radio SO/Robert Stankovsky rec The 
          Concert Hall, Slovak Radio, Bratislava, 25-30 Mar 1991  MARCO POLO 8.223301 [63.28] [RB]
 
          MARCO POLO 8.223301 [63.28] [RB] 
        
Do 
          not let this convincing and idiosyncratic symphony elude you. A successor 
          in the line of Tchaikovsky's Pathétique.  
        
 
          Italo MONTEMEZZI 
          (1875-1952) L’amore 
          Dei Tre Re (The Love of Three Kings) A tragic poem in three 
          acts Libretto by Sem Benelli after his play  soloists, Orchestra Lirica e Coro di Milano della RAI Arturo Basile 
          (conductor) Recorded (mono) Milan, 3 September 1950
 
          soloists, Orchestra Lirica e Coro di Milano della RAI Arturo Basile 
          (conductor) Recorded (mono) Milan, 3 September 1950  WARNER FONIT (2 CDs) 8573 874787 - 2 [85.49] [CF]
 
          WARNER FONIT (2 CDs) 8573 874787 - 2 [85.49] [CF]  
        
A 
          mono recording by Italian Radio. Despite shortcomings in the sound the 
          drama completely takes you over. Very creditable singing from Petrella 
          and Berdini. Bruscantini’s performance alone would justify this purchase. 
          
        
Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART 
          (1756 
          - 1791) Mozart Edition Volume 1 Concertos 
          for Wind Instruments,Violin Concertos  BRILLIANT 
          CLASSICS 99713 7CDs [approx 454 minutes]
BRILLIANT 
          CLASSICS 99713 7CDs [approx 454 minutes]  
        
This 
          first volume of Brilliant Classic’s complete Mozart set certainly bodes 
          well for the other 23 volumes. The performances range from good to excellent, 
          the sound is almost always fine. ... see Full 
          Review 
        
Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART 
          (1756 
          - 1791)  Mozart Edition vol. 4 Piano Concertos [approx. 11 hours 25 min.]
 
          Mozart Edition vol. 4 Piano Concertos [approx. 11 hours 25 min.]  BRILLIANT 
          CLASSICS 99720 [approx. 11 hours 25 min.] [KM]
 
           BRILLIANT 
          CLASSICS 99720 [approx. 11 hours 25 min.] [KM] 
        
Once 
          again, Brilliant Classics comes up with a very good set of Mozart’s 
          works. While not perfect, these performances and recordings are fine. 
          The budget price is an additional incentive for those interested in 
          discovering all of Mozart’s works for piano and orchestra. ...see Full 
          Review 
        
 Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART (1756 
          – 1791)  
          Symphony No. 41 in C Major (The Jupiter) – (1791) - Clarinet Concerto 
          in A Major K.622 – (1791) Bassoon Concerto in B Flat Major K.191 – (1774) 
          - Jack Brymer (clarinet), Gwydion Brooke (Bassoon)  Royal Philharmonic Orchestra – Sir Thomas Beecham. recorded in Studio 
          No.1, Abbey Road, London (Symphony - 26,28/3/57 and Bassoon Concerto 
          – 18/12/58) and Salle Wagram, Paris (Clarinet Concerto – 14,15/5/58), 
          ADD STEREO.
 
          Royal Philharmonic Orchestra – Sir Thomas Beecham. recorded in Studio 
          No.1, Abbey Road, London (Symphony - 26,28/3/57 and Bassoon Concerto 
          – 18/12/58) and Salle Wagram, Paris (Clarinet Concerto – 14,15/5/58), 
          ADD STEREO.  EMI CDM5 
          67596-2 [79.49] [JP]
 EMI CDM5 
          67596-2 [79.49] [JP] 
        
Go 
          ahead and purchase with confidence – not only do you get a superb trio 
          of works and performances, you also get deluxe packaging and all at 
          mid-price.  
        
Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART (1756-1791) 
          Violin 
          Concerto no. 4 in D, K. 218 (1) Ludwig 
          van BEETHOVEN (1770-1827) Violin Concerto in D, op. 
          61 (2)  Joseph SZIGETI (violin), 
          London Philharmonic Orch/Sir Thomas Beecham (1), British Symphony Orch/Bruno 
          Walter (2) Recorded 8.10.1934, Abbey Road Studio no. 1 (1), 14.4.1932, 
          Central Hall, Westminster (2)
 Joseph SZIGETI (violin), 
          London Philharmonic Orch/Sir Thomas Beecham (1), British Symphony Orch/Bruno 
          Walter (2) Recorded 8.10.1934, Abbey Road Studio no. 1 (1), 14.4.1932, 
          Central Hall, Westminster (2)  NAXOS Historical 8.110946 [66.56] [CH]
 
          NAXOS Historical 8.110946 [66.56] [CH] 
        
It 
          is above all for the very humane, vocal manner of Szigeti’s playing 
          that these performances are valuable.  
        
          Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART (1756-1791) 
          Oboe 
          Quartet in F K370, Clarinet Quintet in A K581, Clarinet Concerto in 
          A K622  Gordon Hunt 
          oboe Chilingirian Quartet Andrew Marriner clarinet Chilingirian Quartet 
          London Mozart Players Jane Glover conductor Recorded Rosslyn Hill Chapel, 
          Hampstead November 1984 (Clarinet Concerto) and Wigmore Hall December 
          1981 (Quintet and Quartet)
 Gordon Hunt 
          oboe Chilingirian Quartet Andrew Marriner clarinet Chilingirian Quartet 
          London Mozart Players Jane Glover conductor Recorded Rosslyn Hill Chapel, 
          Hampstead November 1984 (Clarinet Concerto) and Wigmore Hall December 
          1981 (Quintet and Quartet)  EMI Classics for Pleasure 724357488327 [78,39] Budget Price [JW]
 
          EMI Classics for Pleasure 724357488327 [78,39] Budget Price [JW] 
           
        
One 
          magnificent recording and two very fine ones at super-budget price. 
          A fine disc. ... see Full Review 
        
 
        
Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART (1756-1791) Divertimento 
          in E flat, K. 563, Duo in B flat, K. 424*.  Leopold String Trio (Marrianne Thorsen, violin*, Scott Dickinson, 
          viola*, Kate Gould, violoncello) Recorded Champs Hill (GB), 23-25.11.2000
 
          Leopold String Trio (Marrianne Thorsen, violin*, Scott Dickinson, 
          viola*, Kate Gould, violoncello) Recorded Champs Hill (GB), 23-25.11.2000 
           HYPERION CDA67246 [67.27] 
          [CH]
 HYPERION CDA67246 [67.27] 
          [CH] 
         
        
The 
          Leopold String Trio are very, very good, no mistake about it, but mightn’t 
          they have been a little more outgoing?  
        
 
          Wolfgang Amadeus MOZART 
          (1756-1791) Complete 
          String Quintets, Volume 2 Quintet 
          in C minor, K406; Quintet in C major, K515  Ensemble Villa Musica Rec 3-5 Nov 2000, Fürstliche Reitbahn Bad 
          Arolsen
 
          Ensemble Villa Musica Rec 3-5 Nov 2000, Fürstliche Reitbahn Bad 
          Arolsen  MDG 304 1032-2 
          [59.03] [TB]
 MDG 304 1032-2 
          [59.03] [TB] 
        
The 
          Ensemble Villa Musica does the music proud, aided by a recording which 
          is atmospheric and full of presence. It really is of 'demonstration 
          quality'. The quality of the sound has a musical advantage, moreover, 
          since the details in the texture and the rich sonorities are heard to 
          full advantage. 
        
Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART 
          (1756-91) Così fan tutte.  Elisabeth Schwarzkopf (soprano) Fiordiligi; Nan Merriman (mezzo) Dorabella; 
          Lisa Otto (soprano) Despina; Léopold Simoneau (tenor) Ferrando; 
          Rolando Panerai (baritone) Guglielmo; Sesto Bruscantini (baritone) Don 
          Alfonso; Philharmonia Chorus and Orchestra/Herbert von Karajan. Notes, 
          text and translation included Recorded on July 7th 1954 in Kingsway 
          Hall, London and July 14th-16th and 19th-21st, 1954 in No. 1 and No. 
          3 Studios, Abbey Road. [ADD] Mono
 
          Elisabeth Schwarzkopf (soprano) Fiordiligi; Nan Merriman (mezzo) Dorabella; 
          Lisa Otto (soprano) Despina; Léopold Simoneau (tenor) Ferrando; 
          Rolando Panerai (baritone) Guglielmo; Sesto Bruscantini (baritone) Don 
          Alfonso; Philharmonia Chorus and Orchestra/Herbert von Karajan. Notes, 
          text and translation included Recorded on July 7th 1954 in Kingsway 
          Hall, London and July 14th-16th and 19th-21st, 1954 in No. 1 and No. 
          3 Studios, Abbey Road. [ADD] Mono  EMI GREAT RECORDINGS OF THE CENTURY CMS5 67064-2 [161.00]
 
          EMI GREAT RECORDINGS OF THE CENTURY CMS5 67064-2 [161.00] 
           
        
 
        
Here 
          is a recording that really deserves the label ‘Great’. This set surely 
          represents the bright, busy epitome of comic opera. It is pure joy from 
          beginning to end and will be making many return visits to my player. 
        
Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART 
          (1756-1791) Don 
          Giovanni, opera (1787)  Bo Skovhus (Don Giovanni), Renata Girolami (Leporello), Boaz Daniel 
          (Masetto), Janusz Monarcha (Commendatore), Torsten Kerl (Don Ottavio), 
          Adrianne Pieczonka (Donna Anna), Regina Schörg (Elvira), Ildiko 
          Raimondi (Zerlina)
 
          Bo Skovhus (Don Giovanni), Renata Girolami (Leporello), Boaz Daniel 
          (Masetto), Janusz Monarcha (Commendatore), Torsten Kerl (Don Ottavio), 
          Adrianne Pieczonka (Donna Anna), Regina Schörg (Elvira), Ildiko 
          Raimondi (Zerlina) 
          Hungarian Radio Chorus, Nicolaus Estherházy Sinfonia/Michael 
          Halász 
          Rec. Phoenix Studio, Budapest, Nov. 2000  NAXOS 8.660080-82 [CD1 58.31, CD2 58.38, CD3 56.30] [RF]
 
          NAXOS 8.660080-82 [CD1 58.31, CD2 58.38, CD3 56.30] [RF] 
        
This 
          performance and recording stands ahead of many in the catalogue, even 
          if not supplanting Giulini’s 1959 recording for EMI, which may never 
          be bettered, but that is at full price.	... 
          see Full Review 
        
Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART (1756 
          – 1791) Die 
          Zauberflöte – Opera in two acts - (1791)  Anton Dermota (Tamino), Irmgard Seefreid (Pamino), Erich Kunz (Papageno), 
          Wilma Lipp (Queen of the Night), Ludwig Weber (Sarasto), George London 
          (Speaker), Sena Jurinac, Freidl Riegler & Else Schurhoff (The three 
          ladies), Emmy Loose (Papagena), Peter Klein (Monostatos). Singverein 
          der Gesellschaft der Musikfreunde in Wien Wiener Philharmoniker/Herbert 
          von Karajan.
 
          Anton Dermota (Tamino), Irmgard Seefreid (Pamino), Erich Kunz (Papageno), 
          Wilma Lipp (Queen of the Night), Ludwig Weber (Sarasto), George London 
          (Speaker), Sena Jurinac, Freidl Riegler & Else Schurhoff (The three 
          ladies), Emmy Loose (Papagena), Peter Klein (Monostatos). Singverein 
          der Gesellschaft der Musikfreunde in Wien Wiener Philharmoniker/Herbert 
          von Karajan.
          recorded in the Brahmsaal,Vienna,2,3,6-9, 7-16, 20-21/12/50 ADD MONO.
           EMI CMS5 67071-2 [129.07] 
          [JP]
 EMI CMS5 67071-2 [129.07] 
          [JP] 
        
I 
          cannot recommend this issue highly enough. Truly a Great Recording of 
          the Century!  
        
Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART 
          (1756 – 1791) Famous 
          Opera Arias  Various
 
          Various  WARNER CLASSICS 
          APEX 0927 413762 [76.54] Bargain Price [RMK]
 WARNER CLASSICS 
          APEX 0927 413762 [76.54] Bargain Price [RMK]  
        
Some 
          famous arias sung by some famous soloists and for the most part with 
          great success. ... see Full Review 
          
        
Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART 
          (1756-1791) Overture: 
          Der Schauspieldirektor, Concerto for Two Pianos in E flat major, K365, 
          Aria: L'amero, saro costante, K208 (Il re pastore), Concert Aria: Ma, 
          che vi fege, o stelle, K368, Symphony in F major, K112   Clara Haskil, Géza Anda (pianos)
 
          Clara Haskil, Géza Anda (pianos) 
          Erika Köth (soprano) Camerata Academica Salzburg Bernhard Paumgartner 
          Rec 4 August 1957, Mozarteum Salzburg  ORFEO C 572 011 B [60.57] [TB]
 
          ORFEO C 572 011 B [60.57] [TB]  
        
Some 
          of the finest Mozart performers of their generation but their abundant 
          freshness and vitality is rather undermined by the sound 
        
Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART (1756-1791) 
          Complete Piano Variations  Ronald Brautigam (fortepiano) Recorded at Länna Church, Sweden, 
          August 1997
 
          Ronald Brautigam (fortepiano) Recorded at Länna Church, Sweden, 
          August 1997  BIS CD-1266/1267 
          [4 CDs: 60.37, 63.07, 61.37, 61.21] [CH]
 BIS CD-1266/1267 
          [4 CDs: 60.37, 63.07, 61.37, 61.21] [CH] 
        
Brautigam’s 
          brilliance and enthusiasm, as well as the instrument itself, are just 
          what is needed most of the time.  
        
Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART (1756 
          – 1791) Overtures: 
          The Nozze di Figaro K.492. Bastien und Bastienne, K.50. Der Schauspieldirektor, 
          K.486. Lucio Silla K.75. Cosi fan Tutte, K.588. La Finta Giardiniera, 
          K.196. Die Entführung aus dem Serail, K.384. Il Re Pastorale, K.208. 
          Idomeneo, K.366. La Clemenzo di Tito, K.621. Don Giovanni, K.527. Die 
          Zauberflöte, K.620.   Staatskapelle Dresden – Sir Colin Davis. recorded 1996 Lukas Kirche, 
          Dresden, DDD, STEREO.
 
          Staatskapelle Dresden – Sir Colin Davis. recorded 1996 Lukas Kirche, 
          Dresden, DDD, STEREO.  RCA 74321 68004-2 [61.22] superbudget [JP]
 
          RCA 74321 68004-2 [61.22] superbudget [JP] 
        
It 
          is a disc which you are unlikely to listen to entirely without a break, 
          but if you do, as I did, you will be entranced by the quality of playing 
          and recording. This recording was a bargain at full price and now at 
          super-bargain ….  
        
 
          MOZART?! Volume 7 Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART 
          (1756-91) Adagio in B flat, K484a. Serenade in B flat, K371a, ‘Gran 
          Partita’ (arr. Gleissner).  Collegium Classicum Recorded in the Stadthalle, Wuppertal on June 1st 
          (Adagio), March 26th-30th, 2001 (Serenade) [DDD]
 
          Collegium Classicum Recorded in the Stadthalle, Wuppertal on June 1st 
          (Adagio), March 26th-30th, 2001 (Serenade) [DDD]  Dabringhaus und Grimm Gold MDG301 1077-2 [60.01] [CC]
 
          Dabringhaus und Grimm Gold MDG301 1077-2 [60.01] [CC] 
        
One 
          of the most civilised, harmless discs I have ever come across. Play 
          it while you cook the dinner.  
        
Modest 
          Petrovich MUSSORGSKY (1839-81) 
          Piano Music, Vol. 2 Pictures 
          at an Exhibition, Hopak de jeunes ukrainiens, Scène de foire, 
          Sonata (piano duet), C major  Nina Kavtaradze, piano Michail Voskresensky (sonata duet)
 
          Nina Kavtaradze, piano Michail Voskresensky (sonata duet)  DANACORD DACOCD 552 [56:47] [JL]
 
          DANACORD DACOCD 552 [56:47] [JL]  
        
A 
          disc that provides an authoritative performance of Pictures at an Exhibition 
          plus some enjoyable and interesting lesser known Mussorgsky piano works. 
          ...see Full Review 
        
Carl 
          NIELSEN (1865-1931) 
          Symphony 
          No.1 in G minor Op.7, Violin Concerto 
          Op.33 Henrik 
          Hannisdal (violin) Norwegian 
          Radio Orchestra Ari 
          Rasilainen, conductor (Symphony)  Terje Mikkelsen, conductor (Violin Concerto) Recorded 
          at NRK Broadcasting Hall, Oslo in June and October 1996
 
          Terje Mikkelsen, conductor (Violin Concerto) Recorded 
          at NRK Broadcasting Hall, Oslo in June and October 1996  TELDEC APEX 0927 40622 2 [71.14] [CF]
 
          TELDEC APEX 0927 40622 2 [71.14] [CF] 
        
Ari 
          Rasilainen and the Norwegian Radio Orchestra give the symphony not only 
          a good sense of pace but also draw out the kaleidoscopic moods of the 
          first movement. Henrik Hannisdal’s playing in the concerto is sweet-toned 
          especially in the higher positions on the E string, bringing a Bruch 
          like quality to the music, and in the more virtuosic passages rather 
          surprisingly evokes Mediterranean tone colours.  
        
Carl 
          NIELSEN 
          (1865 – 1931) Symphony 
          No. 1, Op. 7 (1891-92) 
          Symphony No. 2, "The Four Temperaments", Op. 16 (1901-02) 
           Finnish Radio Symphony 
          Orchestra – Jukka-Pekka Saraste recorded in the Sibelius Hall, Lahti, 
          Finland, 26-27 March 2001 (No.1) and 2-3 March 2001 No. 2 - DDD.
 Finnish Radio Symphony 
          Orchestra – Jukka-Pekka Saraste recorded in the Sibelius Hall, Lahti, 
          Finland, 26-27 March 2001 (No.1) and 2-3 March 2001 No. 2 - DDD.  FINLANDIA 8573-85574-2 [63.31] [JP]
 
          FINLANDIA 8573-85574-2 [63.31] [JP]
        
The 
          overall characteristic is that of vitality and both of these performances 
          display this characteristic to the full. The Finlandia recording is 
          superb, and the orchestra is set in a fully believable acoustic.  
        
Carl 
          NIELSEN 
          (1865-1931) Symphony 
          No. 2 Four Temperaments (1902) Symphony No. 4 Inextinguishable 
          (1902)  Danish State 
          Radio SO/Thomas Jensen Danish State Radio SO Launy Grøndahl Mono 
          ADD Rec Concert Hall, Danish State Radio, 3 Oct 1947 (Sym 2); 17-19 
          Aug 1951 (Sym 4)
 Danish State 
          Radio SO/Thomas Jensen Danish State Radio SO Launy Grøndahl Mono 
          ADD Rec Concert Hall, Danish State Radio, 3 Oct 1947 (Sym 2); 17-19 
          Aug 1951 (Sym 4)  DUTTON 
          LABORATORIES CDCLP4001 [68.00] [RB]
 DUTTON 
          LABORATORIES CDCLP4001 [68.00] [RB]  
        
Recordings 
          of performances that are not merely vivacious but of eruptive ferocity. 
          Historic rather than merely historical! Superbly transferred by Dutton 
          in good sound. ...see Full Review 
           
        
Carl 
          NIELSEN 
          (1865-1931) Symphony 
          No. 1 (1893) Symphony No. 5 (1922) Helios Overture (1904)  Danish State Radio SO/Thomas Jensen Danish State Radio SO/Erik Tuxen. 
          Mono ADD Rec Concert Hall, Danish State Radio, 14-15 June 1952 (Sym 
          1); 7 Apr 1954 (Sym 5); 8 June 1952 (Helios)
 
          Danish State Radio SO/Thomas Jensen Danish State Radio SO/Erik Tuxen. 
          Mono ADD Rec Concert Hall, Danish State Radio, 14-15 June 1952 (Sym 
          1); 7 Apr 1954 (Sym 5); 8 June 1952 (Helios)  DUTTON 
          LABORATORIES CDLXT2502 [78.36] [RB]
DUTTON 
          LABORATORIES CDLXT2502 [78.36] [RB]  
        
Robert 
          Layton's notes and Dutton's discriminating decision to use reproductions 
          of the original LP sleeves complete a catalogue-significant issue. ... 
          see Full Review  
        
Jacques 
          OFFENBACH (1819-1880) 
          La 
          Belle Hélène 
           Felicity Lott			Hélène, 
          Choeur des Musiciens du Louvre, Les Musiciens du Louvre-Grenoble Marc 
          Minkowski Rec October 2000, Théâtre du Châtelet, 
          Paris
 Felicity Lott			Hélène, 
          Choeur des Musiciens du Louvre, Les Musiciens du Louvre-Grenoble Marc 
          Minkowski Rec October 2000, Théâtre du Châtelet, 
          Paris  VIRGIN CLASSICS 
          5 45477-2 0 [2CDs: total time 118.11] [TB]
 VIRGIN CLASSICS 
          5 45477-2 0 [2CDs: total time 118.11] [TB] 
        
Many 
          regard La belle Hélène as Offenbach most enjoyable operetta. 
          This recording does much to encourage that view. 
        
 Jacques OFFENBACH 
          (1819-1880) La Périchole (1868)
 
          Jacques OFFENBACH 
          (1819-1880) La Périchole (1868)  Opéra comique (mono recording complete, with dialogue in French) 
          Susanne Lafaye (sop) (La Périchole), Raymond Amade (ten) (Piquillo), 
          Louis Noguera (bass) (Don Andrès), Jean-Christophe Benoit (bar) 
          (Le Comte), Pierre Germain (ten) (Don Pedro), Janette Vivalda (sop) 
          (Guadalena), Monique Linval (mezz) (Berginella), Denise Monteil (sop) 
          (Mastrilla), Agnès Disney (mezz) (Frasquinella), Jacques Pruvost 
          (ten) & Christian Asse (ten) (Notaries) René Duclos Choir 
          Orchestre de l’Association des Concerts Lamoureux/Igor Markevitch Rec. 
          Salle de la Mutualité, Paris, June 1958
 
          Opéra comique (mono recording complete, with dialogue in French) 
          Susanne Lafaye (sop) (La Périchole), Raymond Amade (ten) (Piquillo), 
          Louis Noguera (bass) (Don Andrès), Jean-Christophe Benoit (bar) 
          (Le Comte), Pierre Germain (ten) (Don Pedro), Janette Vivalda (sop) 
          (Guadalena), Monique Linval (mezz) (Berginella), Denise Monteil (sop) 
          (Mastrilla), Agnès Disney (mezz) (Frasquinella), Jacques Pruvost 
          (ten) & Christian Asse (ten) (Notaries) René Duclos Choir 
          Orchestre de l’Association des Concerts Lamoureux/Igor Markevitch Rec. 
          Salle de la Mutualité, Paris, June 1958  EMI 574 0882 [CD1 48.20 CD2 45.16] Mono ADD Midprice [RW]
 
          EMI 574 0882 [CD1 48.20 CD2 45.16] Mono ADD Midprice [RW] 
        
This 
          well-priced mono reissue should not dissuade the listener for the balance 
          and clarity is good and does not distract from the confident performance 
          and charming music. ... see Full Review 
        
Max 
          d'OLLONE 
          (1875-1959)  
          Piano Quartet (1949) String Quartet (1898) Piano Trio (1920) Patrice d'Ollone (piano) Quatuor Athenaeum Enesco
 
          Patrice d'Ollone (piano) Quatuor Athenaeum Enesco 
          rec Jan 1999, Salle des fêtes de l'Académie de Paris  PIERRE VERANY PV799061 [69.03] [RB]
 
          PIERRE VERANY PV799061 [69.03] [RB]  
        
Chamber 
          music fans need to hear this as much as Arion's recent Bonnal disc. 
          ...see Full Review  
        
Carl 
          ORFF 
          (1895-1982) Carmina 
          Burana  Bo Skovhus 
          (baritone), Jochen Kowalski (alto), Sumi Jo (soprano) Southend Boys' 
          Choir London Philharmonic Chorus and Orchestra Zubin Mehta (conductor) 
          Rec 1993, The Maltings, Snape
 Bo Skovhus 
          (baritone), Jochen Kowalski (alto), Sumi Jo (soprano) Southend Boys' 
          Choir London Philharmonic Chorus and Orchestra Zubin Mehta (conductor) 
          Rec 1993, The Maltings, Snape  APEX 09274 13772 (60.27) [TB]
 
          APEX 09274 13772 (60.27) [TB] 
        
The 
          extensive percussion is spectacularly well captured. The tam-tam and 
          timpani can rarely have sounded so thrilling in a recorded performance. 
          Mehta conducts with consummate control of his massed forces though he 
          is occasionally a little indulgent with slow tempi. 
          ... see Full Review  
        
Andrei 
          PETROV (born 
          1930) Suite from the Ballet The Shore of Hope 
          (1959) St 
          Petersburg Philharmonic Symphony Orchestra/Eduard Serov Symphonic 
          Cycle The Songs of our Days (1964) St Petersburg Philharmonic 
          Symphony Orchestra/Arvid Jansons Suite no 3 from the Ballet Creation 
          of the World (1975)  Leningrad Orchestra of Early and Modern Music/Eduard Serov
 
          Leningrad Orchestra of Early and Modern Music/Eduard Serov 
          All recorded in the St Petersburg Recording Studio: the dating is unclear. 
           BOHEME MUSIC CDBMR 012198 
          [AAS]
 BOHEME MUSIC CDBMR 012198 
          [AAS] 
        
Not 
          recommended to those who worship at the shrine of the avant-garde, but 
          for middle-of-the-road music-lovers this disc will be a delight.  
        
Robert 
          PLANQUETTE 
          (1848-1903) Les 
          Cloches de Corneville (The Chimes of Normandy) operetta (1877) 
          (complete, with dialogue in French)  Mady Mesplé (Germaine), Christiane Stutzmann (Serpolette), Charles 
          Burles (Grenicheux), Bernard Sinclair (Henri de Corneville), Jean Giraudeau 
          (Le Bailli), Jean-Christophe Beniot (Gaspard) Choir of the Théâtre 
          National de l’Opéra de Paris Orchestre du Théâtre 
          National de l’Opéra de Paris/Jean Doussard Rec. Salle Wagram, 
          Paris, June 1973
 
          Mady Mesplé (Germaine), Christiane Stutzmann (Serpolette), Charles 
          Burles (Grenicheux), Bernard Sinclair (Henri de Corneville), Jean Giraudeau 
          (Le Bailli), Jean-Christophe Beniot (Gaspard) Choir of the Théâtre 
          National de l’Opéra de Paris Orchestre du Théâtre 
          National de l’Opéra de Paris/Jean Doussard Rec. Salle Wagram, 
          Paris, June 1973  EMI 
          574 0912 [CD1 63.30 CD2 57.06] Midprice [RW]
 EMI 
          574 0912 [CD1 63.30 CD2 57.06] Midprice [RW]  
        
This 
          is a strong cast headed by Mady Mesplé who with her characteristically 
          light soprano voice and rapid vibrato seems right for Germaine. ...see 
          Full Review 
        
        
UGIS PRAULINS  
          ODI ET AMO - music composed and arranged 
          for Boys and Men's choir  Riga Dome Boys' Choir/Martins Klisans
 
          Riga Dome Boys' Choir/Martins Klisans  UPE RECORDING COMPANY UPE CD 010 [51.48] [RB]
 
          UPE RECORDING COMPANY UPE CD 010 [51.48] [RB] 
        
A 
          choir of world calibre. If you get a chance to hear them do not miss 
          the opportunity such is their precision, golden tone and attack. I would 
          very much like to hear them in some more classically orientated repertoire. 
           
        
Yves 
          PRIN 
          (b. 1933) Dioscures 
          (1977/revised 1984) a Concerto grosso for flute, clarinet and chamber 
          orchestra; Ephèmeres (1973/revised 1992) a Capriccio for 
          Violin and chamber orchestra; Le Souffle d’Iris (1986/revised 
          1992) a Concerto for flute and orchestra  Orchestra Philharmonique de Radio France conducted by Bruno Ferrandis 
          Flute; Pierre Yves Artaud, Violin; Philippe Graffin, Clarinet; Pascal 
          Post Recorded in the Studios of Radio France, June 1997
 
          Orchestra Philharmonique de Radio France conducted by Bruno Ferrandis 
          Flute; Pierre Yves Artaud, Violin; Philippe Graffin, Clarinet; Pascal 
          Post Recorded in the Studios of Radio France, June 1997  NAXOS 8.555347 [41.03] [GH]
 
          NAXOS 8.555347 [41.03] [GH] 
        
Three 
          fascinating but challenging works. Prin shares with Dutilleux the ability 
          to think in long, lyrical lines as at the end of ‘Dioscures’.  
        
Giacomo 
          PUCCINI (1858-1924) 
          Madam 
          Butterfly (in English)  Cheryl Barker (Cio-Cio-San), Jean Rigby (Suzuki), Paul Charles Clarke 
          (Pinkerton), Gregory Yurisch (Sharpless), Stuart Kale (Goro), Geoffrey 
          Mitchell Choir, Philharmonia Orchestra/Yves Abel Recorded Blackheath 
          Halls, London, 13-17.12.2000
 
          Cheryl Barker (Cio-Cio-San), Jean Rigby (Suzuki), Paul Charles Clarke 
          (Pinkerton), Gregory Yurisch (Sharpless), Stuart Kale (Goro), Geoffrey 
          Mitchell Choir, Philharmonia Orchestra/Yves Abel Recorded Blackheath 
          Halls, London, 13-17.12.2000  CHANDOS CHAN 3070 (2) [2 CDs, 64’37", 72’33"] [CH]
 
          CHANDOS CHAN 3070 (2) [2 CDs, 64’37", 72’33"] [CH]  
        
 
        
This 
          is opera in English at its best. Only the very elite of the "authentic" 
          Butterflies can actually boast a finer overall performance. …see full 
          review 
        
Sergei 
          RACHMANINOV 
          (1873-1943) Symphony No. 1 in D minor, 
          Opus 7 Etudes-Tableaux (orchestrated Respighi)   Russian State Symphony Orchestra/Valeri Polyansky Rec April 1999, Grand 
          Hall of the Moscow Conservatory
 
          Russian State Symphony Orchestra/Valeri Polyansky Rec April 1999, Grand 
          Hall of the Moscow Conservatory  CHANDOS CHAN 9822 [72.00]
 
          CHANDOS CHAN 9822 [72.00]  
        
Russian 
          State SO and Valeri Polyansky enter a competitive field with heads held 
          high. The recording is ambient and allows the rich textures of Rachmaninov's 
          scoring to be heard to excellent effect. There is still a special colour 
          and intensity about a Russian performance of this music.  
        
 
          Sergei RACHMANINOV 
          (1873-1943)Piano Concerto No. 2 in C minor, 
          Op. 18. Prelude in G sharp minor, Op. 32 No. 12. Etudes-tableaux, Op. 
          33 – No. 1 in F minor; No. 2 in C; No. 9 in C sharp minor. Variations 
          on a Theme of Corelli, Op. 42.  Hélène Grimaud (piano); Philharmonia Orchestra/Vladimir 
          Ashkenazy Recorded in Watford Coliseum on September 15th-16th, 2000 
          (Concerto); Teldec Studios, Berlin on June 3rd-5th, 2000 (Preludes and 
          Etudes-tableaux) and January 28th-30th, 2001 (Corelli Variations). [DDD]
 
          Hélène Grimaud (piano); Philharmonia Orchestra/Vladimir 
          Ashkenazy Recorded in Watford Coliseum on September 15th-16th, 2000 
          (Concerto); Teldec Studios, Berlin on June 3rd-5th, 2000 (Preludes and 
          Etudes-tableaux) and January 28th-30th, 2001 (Corelli Variations). [DDD] TELDEC 8573-84376-2 [59.47] [CC]
 
          TELDEC 8573-84376-2 [59.47] [CC] 
        
 
        
Here 
          is a clear case of marketing gone, if not barking mad, certainly disturbingly 
          cuckoo. Grimaud can and should stand perfectly well on her own ten fingers 
          without props such as this, especially as this is such a well-planned 
          Rachmaninov disc. 
        
 
          Sergei RACHMANINOV (1873-1943) 
          Prelude 
          in C sharp minor, Opus 3 No. 2, Ten Preludes, Opus 23, Six Moments musicaux, 
          Opus 16   Nikolai Lugansky 
          (piano) Rec 18-22 September 2000, Teldec Studio, Berlin
 Nikolai Lugansky 
          (piano) Rec 18-22 September 2000, Teldec Studio, Berlin  Erato 85738 57702 [65.28] Fullprice
 
          Erato 85738 57702 [65.28] Fullprice  
        
Frankly 
          thrilling: no other word will do. Rhythmic drive and phrasing heard 
          in an excellently delivered balance. Lugansky has the measure of the 
          rhythmic tautness so central to Rachmaninov's style. 
        
Sergei 
          RACHMANINOV Cello 
          Sonata in G minor, op 19 Dmitri SHOSTAKOVICH 
          Cello 
          Sonata, Op 40  Gwyneth 
          George (cello) Alberto Portugheis (piano) Rec Swansea, 1970/71 (ADD)
 Gwyneth 
          George (cello) Alberto Portugheis (piano) Rec Swansea, 1970/71 (ADD) 
           GUILD GMCD 7219 [54.56] 
          [DW]
 GUILD GMCD 7219 [54.56] 
          [DW] 
        
        
        I 
          have never heard the scherzo of the Rachmaninov played better. It is, 
          a complete revelation and I have known and loved this sonata for almost 
          40 years.[DW]
          The 
          present performances, recorded as far back as the early 1970s, are very 
          fine and quite satisfying, though the recorded sound may at times show 
          its age. They have much to offer.[HC]
         
          Joachim RAFF (1822-1882) 
           
          Piano trios. Op 112 in G; Op 155 in A minor.  Trio Opus 8 Rec: Germany, 2000? (DDD)
 
          Trio Opus 8 Rec: Germany, 2000? (DDD)  CPO 999 800-2 [64.42]
 
          CPO 999 800-2 [64.42]
        The 
          sound is good and the performances are fine although there is a slight 
          over-emphasis on emotional content, I feel.  
        
Alan 
          RAWSTHORNE 
          (1905-1971)  Sonata for violin and piano 
          (1959) Theme and Variations for two violins (1938) John 
          McCABE (b.1939) Maze Dances for violin (1973) Star 
          Preludes for violin and piano (1978)  Peter Sheppard Skærved and Christine Sohn (violins) Tamami Honma 
          (piano) Recorded in the church of St. Mary’s, Dinton, Wiltshire 2nd 
          June 1999 (tracks 6-15) and 28th June 1999 (track I) and 
          in Challow Park, Wantage, Oxon on 12th September 1999 (tracks 
          2-5 and 16) DDD
 
          Peter Sheppard Skærved and Christine Sohn (violins) Tamami Honma 
          (piano) Recorded in the church of St. Mary’s, Dinton, Wiltshire 2nd 
          June 1999 (tracks 6-15) and 28th June 1999 (track I) and 
          in Challow Park, Wantage, Oxon on 12th September 1999 (tracks 
          2-5 and 16) DDD  METIER 
          MSV CD92029 [61:56] [CT]
 METIER 
          MSV CD92029 [61:56] [CT] 
        
This 
          is a worthwhile disc, which it is to be hoped encourages the same advocacy 
          of McCabe’s little recorded chamber output as Rawsthorne’s has received 
          in recent times. 
        
Ottorino 
          RESPIGHI 
          (1879-1936) The 
          Fountains of Rome, The Pines of Rome, Roman Festivals,  Oregon Symphony Orchestra/James DePreist Rec 9-10 January 2001 (Fountains, 
          Pines), 28-29 May 1987 (Festivals), Arlene Schnitzer Auditorium, Portland, 
          Oregon
 
          Oregon Symphony Orchestra/James DePreist Rec 9-10 January 2001 (Fountains, 
          Pines), 28-29 May 1987 (Festivals), Arlene Schnitzer Auditorium, Portland, 
          Oregon  DELOS DE 3287 
          [65.50] [TB]
 DELOS DE 3287 
          [65.50] [TB] 
        
What 
          immediately impresses is the quality of the sound, both of the recording 
          itself and of the playing. And since these are the prerequisites for 
          a recording of this music, the standard set initially is encouraging 
          and satisfying. 
        
 Nikolai RIMSKY-KORSAKOV (1844-1908) 
          Sheherazade 
          - Symphonic Suite, Russian Easter Festival Overture, Capriccio Espagnol
 
          Nikolai RIMSKY-KORSAKOV (1844-1908) 
          Sheherazade 
          - Symphonic Suite, Russian Easter Festival Overture, Capriccio Espagnol 
            Philadelphia Orchestra/Eugene 
          Ormandy Rec: Town Hall Philadelphia 11 Feb 1962 (Sheherazade); 17 Feb 
          1965 (Capriccio); Broadwood Hotel Philadelphia 1 Apr 1959 (Overture)
 Philadelphia Orchestra/Eugene 
          Ormandy Rec: Town Hall Philadelphia 11 Feb 1962 (Sheherazade); 17 Feb 
          1965 (Capriccio); Broadwood Hotel Philadelphia 1 Apr 1959 (Overture) 
           SONY ESSENTIAL CLASSICS 
          SBK46537 [74.57] Budget Price [RB]
 SONY ESSENTIAL CLASSICS 
          SBK46537 [74.57] Budget Price [RB] 
        
 
        
Ormandy 
          imbues the interpretations and playing with guts, ferocity and passion. 
          The sound is unsubtle but the effect is edge-of-seat. ... see Full 
          Review
        
Nikolay 
          Andreyevich RIMSKY-KORSAKOV (1844-1908) 
          The 
          1001 Nights - Sheherazade, Op. 35  Sinbad the Sailor,  
           The Story of a Dervish, The Prince and Princess, The 
          Story of the Second Dervish  Narrated by Bernard Cribbins David Nolan, violin Philharmonia Orchestra, 
          London/ Enrique Bátiz
 
          Narrated by Bernard Cribbins David Nolan, violin Philharmonia Orchestra, 
          London/ Enrique Bátiz  NAXOS 8.555889 [79:07] [JL]
 
          NAXOS 8.555889 [79:07] [JL] 
        
A 
          first class Philharmonia performance of Sheherazade 
          packaged with tales from the Arabian Nights ably narrated by Bernard 
          Cribbins.  
        
Josephe 
          GUY-ROPARTZ 
          (1864-1955) Ouverture, 
          Variations et Final (1914) Musiques au Jardin (1920) Nocturne No. 3 
          (1922)  Francoise 
          Thinat (piano) rec 1983
 Francoise 
          Thinat (piano) rec 1983  ARION ARN 68184 [53.42] [RB]
 
          ARION ARN 68184 [53.42] [RB]  
        
 
        
Ropartz 
          in bardic and in impressionistic garb. Well advocated by Thinat and 
          Arion. ... see Full Review 
        
A 
          SECOND TRIO OF QUARTETS 
          Arnold ROSNER (b1945) String Quartet 
          No. 4 (1972) Lester 
          TRIMBLE (1923-86) String Quartet No. 1 (1950) Irwin 
          SWACK (b1919) String Quartet No. 4 (1986-90)  Alorian (Rosner); Ondine (Trimble); Sierra (Swack). rec not announced
 
          Alorian (Rosner); Ondine (Trimble); Sierra (Swack). rec not announced 
          
           OPUS ONE 150CD [69.33] 
          [RB]
 OPUS ONE 150CD [69.33] 
          [RB]
        
De 
          rigueur listening for twentieth century quartet specialists. Impressive 
          for the gritty Rosner and the promising Swack. 
        
  
        
 [Part 1 
          New]  [Part 2 A-B] [Part 
          3 C-L]
          [Part 4 M-R]  [Part 
          5 S-Y] [Part 6 Misc]