Have you signed up for our weekly mailing
of all the discs reviewed in the week?
RECORD OF THE YEAR Arnold
BAX (1883-1953)
The
Seven Symphonies (1921-1939) Interview
with Vernon Handley by Andrew McGregor
BBC
Philharmonic/Vernon Handley Recorded
in: Studio 7, New Broadcasting House, Manchester,
4 January 2002 (Third Symphony), 5 January
2002 (Tintagel), 19 December 2002 (Fourth
Symphony), 14 January 2003 (Second Symphony),
6-8 August 2003 (Fifth and Seventh Symphonies,
Rogue's Comedy Overture), 5 September
2003 (First Symphony) CHANDOS
CHAN 10122 [5CDs: 74:03+77:24+73:41+69:37+60:43]
[IL]
This
set fully deserves the MusicWeb’s ‘Recording
of the Year’ appellation, it is without doubt,
my overall recording of 2003. This is the
Bax symphonies cycle to which I shall turn
again and again.
... see Full Review
Pierre BOULEZ
(b.1925) Piano
Sonata No.1 (1946) Le Marteau sans Maître
(1953-55) Marc Ponthus (piano) Linda Hirst
(mezzo)
Lontano/Odaline de la Martinez Recorded at
St. Silas Church, London (sonata), and Rosslyn
Hill Chapel, London (no dates given, c.1995)
DDD
LORELT LNT108 [46’55] [TH]
As
good an account of this groundbreaking work
as you are likely to encounter, even from
the great man himself. … see Full
Review
The Beethoven
Mysteries Ludwig
van BEETHOVEN (1770-1827)
Violin
Concerto in D major, Opus 61 (transcribed
for piano and orchestra by the composer) (1806)
Rondo
in B flat major for piano and orchestra, WoO6
(1790?) Felicja Blumental (piano) Brno
Philharmonic Orchestra/Jiri Waldhans Allegro
in D major for piano and orchestra (1788?)
Felicja Blumental (piano) Prague Symphony
Orchestra/Alberto Zedda Rec. 1967, Brno (Violin
Concerto), Milan (Rondo), Prague (Allegro)
BRANA BR 0004 [68.34]
It
makes for interesting listening, though anyone
hoping to find an embryonic Emperor Concerto
is likely to be disappointed. … see Full
Review
Gaetano DONIZETTI
(1797 – 1848) Don
Pasquale - dramma buffo in three acts
Norina…Eva Mei (soprano) Don Pasquale…Alessandro
Corbelli (bass) Ernesto…Antonino Siragusa
(tenor) Dottor Malatesta…Roberto de Candia
(baritone) Un Notaro…Giorgio Gatti (bass)
Chorus of the Teatro Lirico–Cagliari/Paolo
Vero Orchestra of the Teatro Lirico–Cagliari/Gérard
Korsten Recorded at the Teatro Lirico, Cagliari,
February 2002.
TDK CDM-OPDP [75.43+42.12] [RM]
A
good recording. The DVD format may well overcome
the weaker points of this CD version. … see
Full Review
Alexander GOEHR
(b.1934)
Orchestral Works CD
1 [41.18] Metamorphosis/Dance; Romanza
for cello and orchestra Moray Welsh (cello)
Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra/David
Atherton Rec. Philharmonic Hall, Liverpool,
June 1981 CD2 [72.13] … a musical offering
( J.S.B.1985); ‘Behold the Sun’
Op. 44a (1981) for coloratura soprano and
orchestra; Lyric Pieces Op. 35 (1974);
Sinfonia Op. 42 (1980)
Jeanine Thomas (soprano) London Sinfonietta/Oliver
Knussen Rec. All Saints Church, Petersham,
February/March 1990
NMC D095[2CDs: 41.18+72.13] [GH]
If
you have an inquiring mind and a willingness
to open it out to an underrated composer of
our times then you should look out for this
set. … see Full Review
George
Frideric HANDEL
(1685 - 1759) Messiah:
Oratorio for soloists, chorus and orchestra
HWV 56 Susan Roberts, soprano Liliana
Bizineche-Eisinger, mezzo-soprano Algirdas
Janutas, tenor Benno Schollum, bass-baritone
Sigitas Petrulis, trumpet
Kaunas State Choir Lithuanian Chamber
Orchestra/Yehudi Menuhin Recorded live at
Kloster Eberbach in 1996 by courtesy of the
Rheingau Music Festival on the occasion of
the 80th birthday of Lord Menuhin
WARNER APEX 2564 60819-2 [2CDs 70.33 +
61.29] [BK]
It
is worth having for the orchestral playing,
for the singing by the choir and women soloists,
and for the splendid playing by trumpeter
Sigitas Petrulis … see Full
Review
Antonio LOTTI
(1667
- 1740) Mass
in g minor ‘Missa Sapientiae’ [29:31] Johann
Sebastian BACH (1685 - 1750) Magnificat
in E flat (BWV 243a) [32:06]
Balthasar-Neuman-Chor Balthasar-Neumann-Ensemble/Thomas
Hengelbrock Recorded in November 2000 (Bach)
and October 2002 (Lotti) in the Evangelische
Kirche, Gönningen, Germany DDD
DEUTSCHE HARMONIA MUNDI 05472 77534 2
[61:40] [JV]
Very
expressive performances of two masterpieces
... see Full Review
Astor PIAZZOLLA
(1921-1992)
Giora
Feidman plays Piazzolla: Moderato Tangabile
[3:45]; Chant et Fugue [7:08]; Preparense
[5:05]; Tristango [8:15]; Lo Que Vendra [4:01];
Milonga del Angel [5:45]; Fracanapa [3:58];
Hommage [6:43]; Marron y Azul [4:39]; Kicho
[6:30]; Tanti anni prima [5:51]
Giora Feidman: clarinet and bass clarinet
(Track 10) Raul Jaurena: bandoneon (soloist
on Tracks 3,7,9) South West German Chamber
Orchestra of Pforzheim/Vladislav Czarnecki
WARNER CLASSICS 0927-19505-2 [61:44] [SA]
A
perfect example of all the influences Piazzolla
brought to bear on tango; every track is a
delight … verve and commitment … see Full
Review
Wladimir VOGEL (1896
– 1984) Vier
Etüden für Orchester (1930/2) Tripartita
(1934) Preludio – Interludio lirico – Postludio
(1954)
Sinfonieorchester Basel/Israel Yinon Recorded:
Casino Basel Musiksaal, October 2001
REALSOUND RS 051-0037 [79:52] [HC]
Committed
playing, hard-to-resist conviction, excellent
recording … musically satisfying … see Full
Review
Enrico CARUSO (tenor)
(1873-1921) The
Complete Recordings Volume 10 (1916-1917)
Gabriel FAURÉ
(1875-1947) ‘Sancta Maria’ CARUSO
‘Tiempo antico’ Folk
Song, ‘Santa Lucia’ Piotr
Ilyich TCHAIKOVSKY (1840-1893) Eugene
Onegin, ‘Pour moi ce jour est tout
mystère’ (Lensky’s Aria). ‘Pourquoi’Umberto
GIORDANO (1867-1948) Andrea
Chenier, ‘ Come un bel di maggio’Camille
SAINT-SAENS (1835-1921)Samson
et Dalila, ‘Vois ma misère
, hélas' Georges
BIZET (1838-1870) Les Pecheurs
de perles, ‘Je crois entendre encore’
Giuseppe VERDI
(1813-1901)Rigoletto, ‘Bella
figlia del’amore’ (quartet) Gaetano
DONIZETTI (1797-1868) Lucia
di Lamermoor, ‘Chi mi frena in tal
momento’ (sextet) Friedrich
von FLOTOW (1812-1883) Martha,
‘M’appari’ GASTALDON
‘Musica probita’ DE
CRESCENZO ‘Uocchie celeste’ Francesco
Poalo TOSTI (1846-1916)‘L’alba
separa dalla luce l’ombra’ Anton
RUBINSTEIN (1830-1894) Néron,
‘Ah! Lumiére du jour’ Caruso
accompanied by the ‘Victor Orchestra’. cond.
Walter B Rogers and Josef Pasternack Recorded
in New York and Camden, New Jersey, in March
1916, January 1917 and April 1917. Bargain
Price Great Singers Series NAXOS
HISTORICAL 8.110751 [76.59]
Eminently
listenable … the sound is most impressive.
… further enhances Ward Marston’s reputation
for fine restorations. Highly recommended.
… see Full Review
Susan Graham at
Carnegie Hall Johannes
BRAHMS (1833-1897) Zigeunerlieder,
op. 103 Claude DEBUSSY
(1862-1918) Proses lyriques Alban
BERG (1885-1935) Siebe frühe
Lieder Francis POULENC
(1899-1963) Quatre poèmes de Guillaume
Apollinaire André
MESSAGER (1853-1929) Les p’tites
Michu: Vois-tu, je m’en veux, L’amour
masqué: J’ai deux amants Moïses
SIMONS (1888-1945) Toi c’est moi:
C’est ça la vie, c’est ça
l’amour Encores:
Reynaldo HAHN (1874-1947) A Chloris
DEBUSSY Fantoches
Gustav MAHLER
(1860-1911) Liebst du um Schönheit
Ben MOORE
(b.1960) Sexy Lady
Susan Graham (mezzo-soprano), Malcolm Martineau
(piano) Recorded live at the Carnegie Hall,
14th April 2003
ERATO 2564 60293-2 [74:50] [CH]
Although
we are assured that the song recital is in
its death agonies, Susan Graham seems to pack
the hall without much difficulty and here
she is before a cheering Carnegie Hall audience
to prove it. … see Full
Review
Gudny Gudmundsdottir
(violin) Polarinn
JONSSON
(1900 - 1974) Prelude
and Double fugue on the Name B-A-C-H (1927)
Johann Sebastian
BACH (1685 - 1750) Sonata No. 1
in G Minor BWV 1001 for solo violin (1720)
Hallgrimur HELGASON
(1914 - 1994) Sonata for solo violin
(1972) Haflioi HALGRIMSSON
(b.1941) Offerto – In memory of
Karl Kvaran (1991)
Gudny Gudmundsdottir (violin)recorded
in Seltjarnarneskirkja, Iceland, 20 – 24 September
1999. DDD
POLARFONIA CLASSICS PFCD 02.04.007 [67’22"]
[JP]
This
has been an extremely interesting disc to
review, and I recommend it heartily. … see
Full Review
O Magnum Mysterium.
Music for Christmas Samuel
SCHEIDT: Cazon super intradam aechiopicam
Hieronymus PRAETORIUS:
Magnificat Samuel
SCHEIDT: In Dulci jubilo Giovanni
GABRIELI: Angelus ad Pastores;
O Magnum Mysterium; Salvator Noster Biagio
MARINI: Canzon Otta à 6
Angus Davidson (counter-tenor) His Majesty’s
Sagbutts & Cornetts Corydon Singers/Matthew
Best Filmed in Stationer’s Hall, London Francis
POULENC: Quatre Petites Prières
de St. François d’Assise; Quatre Motets
pour le temps de Noël; Litanies à
La Vierge Noire*; Salve Regina; Exultate Deo
Simon Over (organ)* Corydon Singers/Matthew
Best Filmed at St. Giles, Cripplegate, London,
1996? PAL DVD 16:9. All formats
BRILLIANT
CLASSICS 6468 [72’15"] [JQ]
A
strong DVD from the Corydons and Matthew Best
… see Full Review
FRIDAY
Jesús
ARÁMBARRI
(1902-60) Preludio
Gabon-zar sorgiñak (Witches on New
Year's Eve) Cuatro impromptus para orquestra
(Four impromptus…) Ocho canciones vascas para
soprano y orquestra (Eight Basque songs…)
* In Memoriam - Elegía para orquestra
Offrenda Viento Sur (Intermedio) Fantasía
española para orquestra (Spanish fantasy)
Itxaro Mentxaka, soprano *
Bilbao Symphony Orchestra/Juan José
Mena Recorded at the Euskalduna Concert Hall,
Bilbao, 17th-21st October
2000.
NAXOS 8.557275 [57.40] [NH]
Another
winner from the Naxos Spanish Classics series.
The Basque classical sound at its best! …
see Full Review
Johann Sebastian
BACH (1685-1750)
Goldberg
Variations, BWV 988
Gwendolyn Toth, Lautenwerk Recorded at
St. James Chapel, Cathedral of St. John the
Divine, New York City, June 2000 Lautenwerk
by Willard Martin, 1988
ZEFIRO RECORDINGS 103 [2CDs: 83:06] [DS]
Sheer
enjoyment … not in the ‘must have’ category,
but not very far behind. … see Full
Review
Johann
Sesbastian BACH
(1685 - 1750) Moon
Water - Cloud Gate Dance Theatre of Taiwan
Suites
for ’cello (1720) (excerpts): #1, Sarabande;
#2, Sarabande; #3, Sarabande; #4, Prelude;
#5, Prelude, Sarabande, Allemande; #6 Allemande.
[65.00] Mischa Maisky, ’cello, [from Deutsche
Grammophon DG 445373-2] Choreography by Lin
Hwai-Min. Setting by Austin Wang. RM Associates/LGM/BR/DRS/
MEZZO, La Chaîne Musique, Opéra,
Danse/ORF/YLE co-production. Behind the scenes
documentary [20.00] in English. German, French,
Spanish subtitles. Menu languages: English,
German, French, Spanish, Chinese. PCM Stereo,
Dolby Digital 5.0, DTS 5.0. PAL 16:9 DVD 5
Region 1-5, 7-8 RM Associates
ARTHAUS/Musik
100 374 DVD [85.00] [PSh]
Graceful
bodies moving swaying and dipping to beautiful
music played very slowly. Only for a few moments
do things heat up … see Full
Review
RECORDING OF THE MONTH Georg
Frideric HANDEL
(1685 -1759) Handel Oxford
Water Music Oxford
Water Music Suite in F, (HWV 348, arr. T.
Theo) (1719) [7.11] Oxford Water Music Suite
in g, (HWV 350, arr. T. Theo) (1719) [3.58]
Oxford Water Music Suite in D, (HWV 349, arr.
T. Theo) (1719) [3.22] Trio Sonata Op. 5,
#4 in G, HWV 399 (1739) [13.16] Trio Sonata
Op. 2, #3 in Bb, HWV 388 (1730) [10.48]
Jean-Marie LECLAIRE
"L’Aîné" (1697
- 1764) Première Recréation
de Musique Op. 6 in D (1737) [23.46] Arcangelo
CORELLI (1653 - 1713) Trio Sonata
Op. 2 #12, Ciaconna (1685) [3.36] Trio
Sonata Op. 1 #7 in C (1681) [4.50] Francesco
Xaviero GEMINIANI (1687 - 1762) Sonata
V in a (1714) [6.15]
The Brook Street Band: [Pitch: a’ = 415 Hz
] Marianna Szücs, Katalin Kertész,
vv; Hanna McLaughlin, oboe, recorder; Tatty
Theo, vc; Carolyn Gibley, harpsichord and
chamber organ. Recorded at the church in Raveningham,
Norfolk, England, 4 April 2002, and at St.
Mary-at-Hill, London, England, 24 November
2002
Notes in English, Français, and Deutsch.
Photo of the artists. www.Avierecords.com
AVIE AV0028 [77.39] [PSh]
One
of the finest baroque concert disks in decades.
No matter how many recordings of this music
you may already have, if you buy one Baroque
music disk this year, let it be this one ...
see Full Review
BARGAIN OF THE MONTH W.A.
MOZART -
Les Plus Belles Symphonies: Symphony
No.25 in G minor K183. Symphony No.26 in Eb
major K184. Symphony No.28 in C major K200.Symphony
No.35 in D major K385 'Haffner'. Symphony
No.36 in C major K425 'Linz'.Symphony No.38
in D major K504 'Prague'. Symphony No.39 in
Eb major K543. Symphony No.40 in G minor K550.Symphony
No.41 in C major K551 'Jupiter'.
Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra/Nikolaus
Harnoncourt
WARNER CLASSICS 4CDs 5046682882
Superbudget price [CMT]
Intelligence,
wit and enormous character which serves the
music ever so well. Invigorating, refreshing,
but thought-provoking, too - enriching on
many levels. … see Full
Review
Wolfgang
Amadeus MOZART (1756-1791)
Concertos
for clarinet, oboe and bassoon 1) Clarinet
Concerto in A major K.622 Jacques Lancelot
(clarinet) Orchestre de chambre Jean-Francois
Paillard/Jean-Francois Paillard 2) Oboe Concerto
in C major K.314 Pierre Pierlot (oboe) English
Chamber Orchestra/Jean-Pierre Rampal 3) Bassoon
Concerto in B flat major K.191
Paul Hongne (bassoon) Orchestre Symphonique
de Bamberg/Theodor Guschlbauer No information
on the recording venues or dates provided.
ADD
WARNER CLASSICS APEX 2564 60820-2 [67:06]
[MC]
Although
not my first choices in these works I cannot
imagine any listener being disappointed. Fine
performances and agreeable sound quality.
Well worth the modest investment. … see Full
Review
Franz SCHUBERT
(1792
- 1828) Goethe Lieder, Vol 2.
Ruth Ziesak (soprano) Christian Elsner
(tenor) Ulrich Eisenlohr (piano) Recorded
at Radiosudio, Zurich, 15th, 16th
July 2002, 31st October, 1st
November 2002 Deutsche Schubert-Lied-Edition
13 - Goethe Lieder, Vol 2.
NAXOS 8.554666 [69.16] [RH]
An
attractively programmed recital, but Ruth
Ziesak is perhaps a little disappointing …
see Full Review
Ralph VAUGHAN WILLIAMS
(1872-1958) Fantasia
on a Theme by Thomas Tallis (1910)* Norfolk
Rhapsody no.1 (1906)** The Lark Ascending
(1914)† In the Fen Country (1909,
rev.1935)†† On Wenlock Edge (1909,
orch. version f.p. 1924)‡
Sarah Chang (violin), Ian Bostridge (tenor)
London Philharmonic/Bernard Haitink Recorded
in No.1 Studio, Abbey Rd., London, *8-9th
October 1986, **†17-18th December
1994, and ††‡The Colosseum, Watford, 13-14
December 1997.
EMI CLASSICS 7243 5 85151 2 1
[77:10] [GPJ]
Fine
though much of the rest of the disc is, On
Wenlock Edge, delivered by one of the world’s
finest lyric tenors, are undoubtedly worth
the price all on their own. … see Full
Review
Giuseppe
VERDI
(1813-1901) Aida
(1871).
Renata Tebaldi (soprano) Aida; Mario del Monaco
(tenor) Radamès; Ebe Stignani (mezzo)
Amneris; Aldo Protti (baritone) Amonasro;
Fernando Corena (bass) King; Dario Caselli
(bass) Ramfis; Piero de Palma (tenor) Messenger;
Chorus and Orchestra of the Accademia di Santa
Cecilia, Rome/Alberto Erede. Rec. Rome in
August 1952. ADD
NAXOS HISTORICAL 8.110129/30 [144’33:
67’52 + 76’41] [CC]
An
important reissue. Now that it has been made
available at super-budget price, there really
is no excuse for not buying it. … see
Full Review
Golden Slumbers:
Folk and Traditional Melodies from the British
Isles Fiddler
Man; The Girl I left behind; O
waly, waly; The British Grenadiers;
Golden Slumbers; Dashing away with
the Smoothing Iron; It was a lover
and his lass composed or arranged by John
RUTTER (b.1944); Charm me asleep
by Henry LESLIE
(1822-1896); Waters of Elle by
Robert Lucas de PEARSALL
(1795-1856); Sweet Nightingale
arranged by Goff
RICHARDS; The Oak and the Ash
arranged by Gordon
LANGFORD; Loch Lomond arranged
by David OVERTON;
Londonderry Air arranged by Peter Knight;
Migildi Magildi arranged by Grayston
IVES; Irish Lullaby arranged
by Keith ABBS
Hannover Harmonists
THOROFON CTH 2485 [38.38] [GH]
The
choir excel in pronunciation, tuning, speed,
articulation, ensemble and timbre but have
not discovered the real earthy nature of English
folk music … see Full
Review
BOOK
REVIEWS
Bartok's
Mikrokosmos - genesis,
pedagogy and style by
Benjamin Suchoff The Scarecrow Press,
2002 185pp ISBN: 0810844273
Will
understandably be snapped up by musicians
and those many for whom Bartok is one of the
most original and sophisticatedly beguiling
voices in the 'last century. ... see Full
Review
Arnold BAX
A
Catalogue of the Works of Sir Arnold Bax by
Graham Parlett hardback £70 ISBN
0-19-816586-2 Clarendon Press, Oxford 1999
[RB]
A
book in which the author’s affection for Bax’s
music is balanced with academic rigour - a
guiding hand; an authoritative friend. ...
see Full Review
Information Sources
in Music editor:
Lewis Foreman ISBN
3-598-24441-X hardback publ K.G. Saur Verlag
GmbH, München 444pp. 110.00
A
most valuable book of help both to researcher,
bibliographer and librarians active in the
field of classical music and its sources.
... see Full Review
A Fiddler’s Tale:
How Hollywood and Vivaldi Discovered Me. Louis
Kaufman (1905
- 1994) Louis
Kaufman with Annette Kaufman Foreword by Jim
Svejda 384 pages; includes music CD of
recordings from 1942-52.
Probably
most music lovers, on encountering the name
Louis Kaufman, will respond "Who?"
Ironically, while probably many people have
never head of him, they have all heard him.
… see Full Review
Mozart's
Piano Concertos by John Irving Ashgate
Press, 2003 296pp 12 music exx 4pp index 18p
bibliography 07546 0707 0 Hardback £45.00
MusicWeb offer
£45.00 reduced to £42.50
post free in the UK
Recommended
for academics, and as a handbook for practising
musicians. Others with a more general interest
in the concertos may find this too tehnically
detailed though I daresay they will learn
much from it. ... see Full
Review
THE
PENGUIN GUIDE TO COMPACT DISCS & DVDs
2003/4 Edition: The Key Classical recordings
on CD, DVD & SACD 2004
Edition Edited by Ivan March
Reviews by: Ivan March; Edward Greenfield;
Robert Layton Assistant Editor: Paul Czajkowski
Paperback 1566 pp. ISBN 0141013842 £24.99
[RB]
The
most wide-ranging and satisfying classical
review print source on the market. ... see
Full
Review
Szymanowski,
Eroticism and the Voices of Mythology
by
Stephen Downes
RMA Monographs No. 11 publ. Royal Musical
Association and Ashgate, 2003 109pp. Hardback
ISBN 0 947854 10 X www.ashgate.com £35.00
reduced to £32.50 post free in the UK
An
agreeably detailed study suitable for Szymanowski
specialists and those fascinated by the margins
and overlaps between music, literature and
psychology. ... see Full
Review
UNEASY
LISTENING - A caricature guide to 20th
century composers
by John Minnion 109pp
Paperback ISBN 0-9544499 1 6 [RB]
This
is wonderfully well done as a book of illustrations.
It tells us something of the psychology of
the composer in each case and does so wittily
and not without taking a few dangerous corners.
... see Full Review