Click
for MUSICWEB RECORDINGS
OF THE YEAR
RECORDINGS
OF THE MONTH
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Johann
Sebastian BACH
(1685-1750) Six
Suites for Violoncello, BWV 1007-1012.
DVD 1: Suite No.1 in G Major; Suite No.2
in D Minor; Suite No.3 in C Major DVD 2:
Suite No 4 in E Flat Major; Suite No.5 in
C Minor; Suite No. 6 in D Major. CD1: Music
only from DVD 1; CD2: Music only from DVD
2
Wen-Sinn Yang. (cello) rec. Servatiuskirche
Auf Dem Streichen - (no date given) Sound
Supervisor: Wilhelm Meister Executive Producer:
Korbinian Meyer Director of TV and Video:
Ruth Käch. Region Code 0; NTSC ARTHAUS
MUSIK 101 419 [2 DVDs: 76:49 + 96:54]
[ZT]
Only
physical presence could transcend the musical
epiphany bestowed by this superb presentation.
... see Full
Review
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Norbert
BURGMÜLLER
(1810-1836) Piano
Sonata in F minor Op.8 (1826) [27:58] Waltz
in E Flat major (1827) [03:45] Mazurka in
E flat major [03:59] Rhapsodie in B minor
Op.13 (1834) [04:58] Polonaise in F major
Op.16 (1832) [05:56] Felix
MENDELSSOHN BARTHOLDY (1809-1847)
Marcia funebre in A minor Op.103 (1836)
[06:54] Frédéric
BURGMÜLLER (1806-1874) Rêveries
fantastiques Op.41 (1838) [05:53] L’arabesque
(25 Études Op.100, No.2) (1851) [00:44]
Innocence (25 Études Op.100, No.5)
(1851) [00:54] Ballade (25 Études
Op.100, No.15) (1851) [01:19] Valse brillante
Op.106 (1851) [06:16]
Tobias Koch (piano) rec. Schloss Kremsegg,
Kremsmünster, Austria, 16-18 November
2005
GENUIN GEN 86061 [68:44] [GPu]
An
outstanding, well-nigh revelatory disc,
fascinating music played exceptionally well,
with two early pianos very well-recorded
… see Full
Review
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Ronald CORP (b.
1951) Forever
Child and Other Choral Music Forever Child (2004) [12:20]
Verbum Patri (2002) [1:53] Give to my eyes Lord* (2005) [4:01]
May the Lord bless you* (2001) [3:16] Dover Beach (2003) [12:46]
Weep you no more sad fountains* (1997) [2:24] Two part songs
(1997) [3:18] Four Elizabethan Lyrics* (1994) [9:17] Lute-Book
Lullaby (Sweet was the song) (1980) [1:30] Fear no more the
heat o’ the sun (2004)[2:57] Missa San Marco (2002) [12:01]
Requiem (2004) [1:55] Voces
Cantabiles/*Alexander Wells (piano)/Ronald Corp rec. All Hallows
Church, Gospel Oak, London, 26, 28 November 2005. DDD DUTTON
EPOCH CDLX 7171 [68:32] [JQ]
This
CD has given me enormous pleasure from start to finish and is
one of the most enjoyable discs to have come my way for a long
time. ... see Full Review
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Hans
Werner HENZE (b.
1926) Voices
for two voices and instruments (1973):
Los poetas cubanos ya no sueñan;
Prison Song; Keiner oder alle; The distant
drum; 42 Schulkinder; Caino; Heimkehr; Grecia
1970; Legende von der Entstehung des Buches
Taoteking auf dem Weg des Laotse in die
Emigration; Gedanken eines Revuemädchens
während des Entkleidungsaktes; Das
wirkliche Messer; Patria; Screams (Interlude);
Para aconsejar a una dama; Roses and revolutions;
Schluss; Das Blumenfest
Sarah Walker (mezzo), Paul Sperry (tenor)
London Sinfonietta/Hans Werner Henze rec.
Rosslyn Hill Chapel, January 1978. ADD First
released on LP as Decca Headline HEAD19/20,
1980 EXPLORE
EXP 0007/8 [49.42 + 47.13] [AOz]
These
last few weeks, I’ve been blessed by a surfeit
of excellent recordings, but this one really
is special ... If all releases by Explore
are as good as this, we are in for exciting
times. ... see Full
Review
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Johann
Wenzel KALLIWODA
(1801-1866) Symphony
No. 5 in B minor, op. 106 (1840) [27:44]
Symphony No. 7 in G minor, WoO/01 (1841)
[28:50] Overture No. 16 in A minor, op.
238 (1863) [11:42]
Das Neue Orchester/Christoph Spering
rec. Köln, November 15-18, 2004
CPO 777 139-2 [68:29] [DJB]
This
is unquestionably my discovery of the year
and my disc of the year … see Full
Review
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Gustav
MAHLER
(1869-1911) Symphony
No. 6 in A Minor Tragic (1903-1905)
[84:31] Carl NIELSEN
(1865-1931) Symphony No. 5, Op.50
(1921-1922) [34:27]* Gioachino
ROSSINI (1792-1868) Semiramide
Overture (1822) [12:23]+
Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra, New
Philharmonia Orchestra*, BBC Symphony Orchestra+/Jascha
Horenstein rec. Winter Gardens, Bournemouth
10 January 1969; BBC Studios, London 26
February 1971*; 6 November 1957+. Also included
is a short interview with Horenstein by
Deryck Cooke recorded in 1971. ADD. (Mahler
and Rossini are mono)
BBC LEGENDS BBCL 4191-2 2 [64:19 + 74:00]
[TD]
A
major release … You will be involved, you
will be moved, you will be unnerved, you
will not be disappointed. ... see Full
Review
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Wolfgang
Amadeus MOZART (1756-1791) Un
moto di gioia - Opera and Concert Arias Schon lacht
der holde Frühling, KV580 (1789) [7:47] Ch’io mi scordi
di te? KV 505 (1786)[10:01]¹ Nehmt meinen Dank, KV383
(1782) [3:44] Lungi sa te, mio bene Aria from Mitridate,
Rè di Ponto, KV87 (1770) [9:21]² Un moto di gioia, Arietta
KV579 (1789) from Le nozze di Figaro [1:33] Come
scoglio Recitative and aria from Così fan tutte,
KV588 (1790) [5:28] Ruhe sanft mein holdes Leben from Zaide,
KV344 (1779) [5:44] Exultate, jubilate, KV165 (1770)
[13:30]³ Miah
Persson (soprano), Yevgeny Sudbin (piano obbligato)¹, Bengt
Olerås (solo horn)², Ulf Samuelsson (organ)³, Swedish Chamber
Orchestra/Sebastian Weigle rec. September 2005, Örebro Concert
Hall, Sweden BIS
SACD-1529 [63:36]
[DC]
The
singing of one of the best young lyric sopranos
of the day … a valuable addition to any
vocal collection. ... see Full
Review
HISTORICAL
RECORDING OF THE MONTH Jean-Philippe
RAMEAU
(1683-1764) Six
Concerts en Sextuor (1741) [59:10] Les Indes
Galantes, Ballet Héroïques (1735)
[48:41]
Irène Joachim (soprano) Camille Maurane
(baritone) Raymond Malvasio (tenor) La Chorale
Yvonne Gouverné L’Ensemble Orchestral
Hewitt/Maurice Hewitt Rec. in Paris in 1952
(Six Concerts) and 1942 (Les Indes Galantes)
CASCAVELLE VEL 3092 [59:10 + 48:41]
[JW]
Vigorous
and enthusiastic, long on sympathy and romantic
trajectory … Hewitt was a talented and dedicated
musician and this release does his memory
honourable service ... see Full
Review
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Dmitri
SHOSTAKOVICH (1906–1975)
Symphony
No.13 in B flat minor, "Babi Yar"
Op. 113 (1962) (Babi Yar. Adagio
[16:13]; Humour. Allegretto [8:19]; In the
Store. Adagio [12:12]; Fears. Largo [12:11];
A Career. Allegretto [12:42]) Jan-Hendrik
Rootering (bass) Netherlands Radio Choir
Netherlands Radio Philharmonic Orchestra/Mark
Wigglesworth rec. April 2005, Music Centre
for Dutch Radio and Television, Studio MCO5,
Hilversum BIS-SACD-1543
[62:22]
Dmitri
SHOSTAKOVICH (1906–1975) Symphony
No.13 in B flat minor, "Babi Yar"
Op. 113 (1962) (Babi Yar. Adagio
[16:03]; Humour. Allegretto [8:07]; In the
Store. Adagio [12:43]; Fears. Largo [11:43];
A Career. Allegretto [13:06])
Taras Shtonda (bass) Czech Philharmonic
Choir Brno Beethoven Orchester Bonn/Roman
Kofman rec. 28-30 November 2005, Heilig
Kreuz-Kirche Bad Godesberg MUSIKPRODUKTION
DABRINGHAUS UND GRIMM
MDG
937 1205-6 [61:51] [GF]
Two
extremely well-played and thrilling SACD
versions of this deeply fascinating symphony.
The BIS recording wins on points thanks
to the impressive sound quality and the
singing. ... see Full
Review
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Dmitri
SHOSTAKOVICH
(1906-1975)
Cello Sonata in D minor, Op. 40 (1934) [30:03];
Pieces for Cello and Piano (1949-1953) –
The Clockwork Doll (arr. Sapozhnikov
and Kirkor) [0:53]; Hurdy-Gurdy (arr.
Atovmian) [0:44]; Sad Song (arr.
Kalianov) [1:52]; Lullaby (arr. Kalianov)
[1:22]; Spring Waltz (arr. Atovmian)
[1:46]; Nocturne (arr. Atovmian)
[3:06]; Moderato [2:13]; Gigue
from ‘Hamlet’ (arr. Chelkauskas) [1:41]
Alfred SCHNITTKE
(1934-1998) Madrigal In Memoriam
Oleg Kagan for Solo Cello (1991) [8:22].
Klingende Buchstaben (1988) [4:17];
Cello Sonata No. 1 (1978) [21:57]
Alban Gerhardt (cello); Steven Osborne (piano).
rec. Wigmore Hall, London, 26-28 August
2005. DDD
HYPERION CDA67534 [78:50] [CC]
I
cannot recommend this disc enough. True,
it is full-price, but I bet you will play
it many more times than a multitude of super-budgets.
Superb. ... see Full
Review
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Jean
SIBELIUS
(1864-1957) A
Film in Two Parts: The Early Years [52:31];
Maturity and Silence [50:34] Elisabeth
Söderström (soprano); Boris Belkin
(violin) Swedish Radio Symphony Orchestra/Vladimir
Ashkenazy (conductor) Recorded 1984
Cameraman: David Findlay, Editor: Peter
Heelas, Writer and Director: Christopher
Nupen. NTSC All regions Includes bonus film
Allegro molto The Christopher Nupen
Films ALLEGRO
FILMS 05CN [103:05] [AO]
A
true collector’s item, a poetic and imaginative
essay on Sibelius and on the nature of artistic
creation. ... see Full
Review
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Richard
STRAUSS (1864
– 1949) Salome
(1905) Birgit Nilsson (soprano)
– Salome; Gerhard Stolze (tenor) – Herod;
Grace Hoffman (mezzo) – Herodias; Eberhard
Wächter (baritone) – Jokanaan; Waldemar
Kmentt (tenor) – Narraboth; Josephine Veasey
(mezzo) – Page to Herodias; Paul Kuen (tenor)
– First Jew); Stefan Schwer (tenor) – Second
Jew; Kurt Equiluz (tenor) – Third Jew; Aron
Gestner (tenor) – Fourth Jew; Max Proebstl
(bass) – Fifth Jew; Tom Krause (baritone)
– First Nazarene; Nigel Douglas (tenor)
– Second Nazarene; Zenon Kosnowski (bass)
– First Soldier; Heinz Holecek (bass) –
Second Soldier; Theodor Kirschbichler (bass)
– Cappadocian; Liselotte Mailk (soprano)
– Slave
Wiener Philharmoniker/Georg Solti publ.
1962. No recording dates and venue given.
John Hunt’s discography in Birgit Nilsson’s
autobiography says Vienna, October 1961
DECCA 475 7528 [53:52 + 45:34] [GF]
For
the raw animal thrill of Solti’s conducting,
the overblown recording and, most of all,
Nilsson’s unsurpassed singing of the title
role this is a recording that should be
in every respectable CD collection. ...
see Full
Review
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Charles-Marie
WIDOR
(1844-1937) Organ
Symphony No.5, Op.42, No.1 (1879) [40:50]
Organ Symphony No.6, Op.42, No.2 (1879)
[37:54]
Colin Walsh (organ) rec. Lincoln Cathedral,
19-21 September, 2005.
GUILD GMCD 7305 [79:16] [JF]
I
am so impressed by this CD that I would
have to recommend it to anyone who wishes
to explore this unbelievably exciting and
equally beautiful music. ... see Full
Review
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Hugo
WOLF
(1860-1903) Eichendorff-Lieder:
Der Musikant, Verschweigene Liebe, Das Standchen,
Nachtzauber, Seemans Abschied Mörike-Lieder:
Der Genesene an die Hoffnung, Der Knabe
und das Immlein, Begegnung, Verboirgenheit,
Nimmersatte Liebe, Im Frühling, Auf
ein Wanderung, Um Mitternacht, Auf ein altes
Bild, Gebet, An den Schlaf, An die Geliebte,
Lied eines Verliebten, Peregrina 1 and 2,
Der Jager, Abschied. Goethe-Lieder: Gutmann
und Gutweib, Ganymede
Ian Bostridge (tenor), Anthony Pappano (piano)
rec. 26-29 April 2005, LSO St Luke’s, London
EMI CLASSICS 3 42256 2 [71:37] [AOz]
An
excellent and highly individual approach
to Wolf by an interpreter who really understands
Wolf’s special sensibility and breathes
life into the music. ... see Full
Review
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Alexander
ZEMLINSKY (1871-1942)
Lyrische
Symphonie Op. 18 (1922)
Matthias Goerne (baritone); Christine Schäfer
(soprano) Orchestre National de Paris/Christoph
Eschenbach rec. Paris, June 2005. SACD
CAPRICCIO
71 081 [51:47] [AO]
The
performances and insights are so profound
that this recording will stand the test
of time. It will be the touchstone for decades
to come, like a "lamp held on high,
in order to light (our) way" as the
text suggests. ... see Full
Review
RECORDING
OF THE MONTH Juan
Diego Flórez: Sentimiento
latino Pedro
Elías GUTIÉRREZ (1870–1954) 1. Alma llanera (1914)
[3:18] José Alfredo
JIMÉNEZ (1926–1973) 2. Ella (1950s) [3:44] María
Isabel GRANDA LARCO (Chabuca GRANDA) (1920–1983) 3. La flor de
la canela [3:42] Carlos GARDEL (1890–1935)
and Alfredo
Le PERA 4. El día quem e quieras(1935) [4:38] Agustin
LARA (1900–1969) 5. Granada (1932) [4:15]Trad. (arr.
Flórez)
6. La jarra de oro [3:16] José PADILLA (1889–1960) 7. Princesita (from La
corte del amor) (1916) [3:10] María
GREVER (1884–1951) 8. Júrame (1920s) [3:37] Manuel
María PONCE (1882–1948) 9. Estrellita (1914) [3:04] María
Isabel GRANDA
LARCO (Chabuca GRANDA) and Eduardo Óscar
ROVIRA 10. Fina estampa [2:34] Noel
ESTRADA (1918–1979) 11. En mi viejo San Juan (1940s?) [4:44] Ernesto
LECUONA (1895–1963) 12. Siboney (1929) [4:00] Nilo
MENÉNDEZ and Adolfo
UTRERA 13. Aquellos ojos verdes [4:14] María Isabel GRANDA
LARCO (Chabuca GRANDA) 14. Bello durmiente [2:38] Jesús
Monge RAMIREZ (1910–1964) 15. México lindo (1940s) [4:03] Juan
Diego Flórez (tenor), Daniel
Binelli (bandoneon) (4, 7, 8), David Gálvez (guitar) (2, 3, 9, 10, 14), Shields-Collins
Bray (piano) (7, 9), Juan Diego Flórez (bongos (10), Mariachi de Oro with Swang
Lin, Eugene Cherkasov, Xiao-Hua Sheng (violin) (2), Michael Shih, Adriana Voirin
De Costa (violin) (7, 9), Laura Bruton (viola) (7, 9), Karen Basrak (cello) (7,
9), William Clay (bass) (7, 9), Fort Worth Symphony Orchestra/Miguel Harth-Bedoya
(1, 3-6, 8, 11-13, 15)
rec. 25 September–2 October 2004, Landreth Auditorium, Fort Worth, Texas DECCA
475 7576 [55:08] [GF]
Sensible,
sensitive, intelligent, technically impeccable, extremely beautiful –not
a trace of bad behaviour. Singing of this calibre can refine
even the slightest of material – and this is not all that slight.
... see Full Review
BARGAINS
OF THE MONTH
BARGAIN
OF THE MONTH Benjamin
BRITTEN (1913-1976)
War Requiem, Op. 66 (1961)
[81:24] Rehearsing War Requiem: recordings
made during session rehearsals* [49:34]
Galina Vishnevskaya (soprano); Peter Pears
(tenor); Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau (baritone)
The Bach Choir; London Symphony Chorus;
Highgate School Choir Melos Ensemble Simon
Preston (organ) London Symphony Orchestra/Benjamin
Britten rec. Kingsway Hall, London, 3-5,
7, 8, 10 January 1963 Stereo/*mono
DECCA - THE ORIGINALS 475 7511 [54:52
+ 76:50] [JQ]
This
superb recording, definitive in so many
ways, speaks to us as powerfully today as
it ever did. ... see Full
Review
BARGAIN
OF THE MONTH Antonín DVOŘÁK (1841-1904) Requiem,
Op. 89 (1890) [94:59] Biblical Songs, Op. 99 – excerpts*
(1894) [19:08] Maria
Stader (soprano); Sieglinde Wagner (contralto); Ernst Haefliger
(tenor); Kim Borg (bass) Czech Chorus, Prague Czech Philharmonic
Orchestra/Karel Ančerl *Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau (baritone);
Jörg Demus (piano) rec., Rudolfinum, Prague, January, February
1959; *Studio Lankwitz, Berlin, April 1960. ADD DEUTSCHE
GRAMMOPHON ROSETTE COLLECTION 476 5307 [72:40 + 41:34]
[JQ]
This
Ančerl version of the Requiem is something rather special
and it constitutes a clear first choice ... see Full
Review
BARGAIN
OF THE MONTH Franz
LISZT
(1811-1886)
Complete Piano Music - Volume 23
Piano
Transcriptions of Beethoven's Symphonies
7 and 8, S464/R128: Symphony No. 7 in A
major, Op. 92 [38:46] Symphony No. 8 in
F major, Op. 93 [24:58]
Konstantin Scherbakov (piano)rec. Potton
Hall, Westleton, Suffolk, 5-7 June 2002
(No.7); 5 October 2004 (No.8). DDD
NAXOS 8.557856 [63:44] [TP]
Those
who have been collecting this series will
already be rushing into the stores to snap
this issue up. Those who are as yet unfamiliar
with Liszt’s Beethoven transcriptions should
do the same.... see Full
Review
BARGAIN
OF THE MONTH Wolfgang
Amadeus MOZART (1756-1791) Piano
Concerto No. 21 in C major, K467 (1785) [27:41] Piano Concerto
No. 25 in C major, K503 (1786) [31:23] Stephen
Kovacevich (piano) London Symphony Orchestra/Sir Colin Davis
rec. London, June 1972. ADD PHILIPS
ROSETTE COLLECTION 4765316 [60:04] [DRD]
There
have been many superlatives in this review but they’re all deserved.
Enough - I’m going to listen to the music again! ... see Full
Review
BARGAIN
OF THE MONTH
Sergei PROKOFIEV (1891-1953)
Romeo and Juliet (1935-36): excerpts
from Suites No.1 (Op. 64a), No. 2 (Op. 64b)
and No. 3 (Op.101): (Montagues and Capulets
(Op.64b, No. 1) [5:31]; Juliet the Young
Girl (Op. 64b, No. 2) [3:52]; Folk Dance
(Op. 64a, No 1) [4:16]; Scene (Op. 64a,
No. 2) [1:31]; Madrigal (Op. 64a, No. 3)
[3:35]; Minuet (Op. 64a, No. 4) [3:04];
Masks (Op. 64a, No. 5) [1:55]; Romeo and
Juliet (Op. 64a, No. 6) [7:41]; Tybalt’s
Death (Op. 64a, No. 7) [4:35]; Friar Laurence
(Op. 64b, No. 3) [2:40]; Dance (Op. 64b,
No. 4) [1:57]; Romeo and Juliet before Parting
(Op. 64b, No. 5) [9:14]; Dance of the Girls
from The Antilles (The Girls with Lilies)
(Op. 64b, No. 6) [2:12]; Romeo at Juliet’s
Tomb (Op. 64b, No. 7) [7:01]; Death of Juliet
(Op. 101, No.6) [4:18])
Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra/Myung-Whun
Chung rec. Concertgebouw, Amsterdam, January,
February 1993. DDD DEUTSCHE
GRAMMOPHON ENTRÉE 00289
477 5011 [63:22] [JQ]
Superlative
playing, sympathetic conducting, fine engineering,
marvellous music and a bargain price; what
more can one ask? ... see Full
Review
BARGAIN
OF THE MONTH Ralph
VAUGHAN WILLIAMS
(1872-1958) An
Introduction to Ralph Vaughan WilliamsOverture
to The Wasps from the 'Aristophanic
Suite' (1909) * [10:16] Fantasia on 'Greensleeves'
- arranged by Ralph Greaves (d. 1966) (1934)
† [4:34] The Lark Ascending - Romance
for Violin and Orchestra (1921) ‡ [15:36]
A London Symphony (Symphony No. 2)
(1913) § [47:41]
Michael Davis (violin) London Philharmonic
Orchestra/Vernon Handley * London Symphony
Orchestra/Bryden Thomson †‡§ rec. dates
and venues not supplied but made 1980s and
1990s
CHANDOS INTRO CHAN 2028 [78:09] [DH]
Thomson’s
mighty London risks creating a following.
This is a magnificent performance which
impresses more with each hearing ... see
Full Review