  | 
           
             Hoffnung Music 
              Festivals 1956,58,61 
              $33.75 
              £19 World 
              $37£21 post free 
              This is a must 
              for all Hoffnung enthusiasts. 
              Purchase 
              here    see 
              review 
            | 
           
             Hoffnung - A 
              Last Encore 
              On 2 CDs lasting 
              1 hour 45min, this contains all the recordings 
              of Hoffnung preserved in the BBC archives. 
              They include the famous and hilariously 
              funny Bricklayer story. $22 
              £14 post 
              free world-wide Purchase 
            | 
         
        
       
       
      An ALL-ARNOLD 
        Study Day and Concert 
        at the Royal Festival Hall 24-9-04 
        
      NEW 
        and RECENT ARTICLES 
       JASCHA 
        HORENSTEIN (1898-1973) A 
        CD DISCOGRAPHY by Donald Clarke 
       CARLOS 
        KLEIBER 
        (1930-2004) 
        
        View from the Audience 
        Knight 
        Foundation Administers Tough 
        Love to American Symphony Orchestras to Encourage 
        Building of New Audiences 
        Frank 
        T. Manheim 
       "Has 
        the time come to set Mozart aside and let a 
        new generation discover him?" Hans-Theo 
        Wohlfahrt on Glyndebourne's new Magic Flute. 
         
        
        View from the Audience 
        WHAT 
        IS CLASSICAL MUSIC? 
        WHO LISTENS TO IT? Vignettes from the American 
        scene Frank T. Manheim 
       PERCY 
        YOUNG - 1912-2004 
        Obituary by Philip Scowcroft  
       Georges 
        Charles GOUNOD 
        (1818-1893) Faust 
        - an opera in five acts - Faust on record; 
        a look back and into the future 
       HISTORY 
        OF MUSIC Part 2 Music of the Renaissance 
        and Reformation Periods Dr David C F Wright 
      Ever 
        wondered if record companies take any notice 
        of technical criticisms of their production 
        standards? Read 
        on ...  
      Are 
        you able to help? Shostakovich's works were 
        premiered and recorded in Estonia by the conductor 
        Roman Matsov. This was to ensure availability 
        of Shostakovich's works for posterity should 
        they be be supressed in the Soviet Union. This 
        priceless collection, in the hands of the son, 
        Mark Matsov, is now endangered. Read more from 
        the Australian 'The 
        Age' 
        
      MusicWeb 
        recommended recordings 2004 
        
        If 
          you wish to flip between this page and the 
          latest reviews use the button marked "Return 
          to previous page" to get back to here 
        
        
        LATEST  
        
        CD REVIEWS (last two days) 
        
        Recordings 
          of the Month Bargains of 
          the Month 
         
         
         
        Have you signed up for our weekly 
          hyperlinked mailing of all the discs reviewed 
          in the week? 
          [NOTE: For some people these mailings may 
          be rejected as spam unless you put me on your 
          white list. They are large mailings so keep 
          your mailbox clear] 
         Click 
          here for MUSICWEB 
          Special Offers 
           
          
          Johann 
          Sebastian BACH 
          (1685 -1750) Goldberg 
          Variations, BWV 988 (1741) [70.55] 
           András 
          Schiff, piano Recorded Live at Stadtcasino, 
          Basel, Switzerland, 30 October 2001. Notes 
          in English and Français. Photo of the 
          performer and musical examples.   
          ECM NEW SERIES 1825 [70.55] [PSh]  
        
 Yet 
          another essential recording of the Goldberg 
          Variations, maybe good enough to topple Glenn 
          Gould from his pedestal ... see Full 
          Review  
           
          Havergal BRIAN 
          (1876 - 1972)Symphony No. 
          1 The Gothic (1919-27)  
          Eva Jenisová (sop.), Dagmar Pecková 
          (alto), Vladimír Dolezal (ten.), Peter 
          Mikuláš (bass) 
          Slovak Opera Chorus, Slovak Philharmonic Choir, 
          Slovak Folk Ensemble Chorus, Lúcnica 
          Chorus, Bratislava City Choir, Bratislava 
          Children’s Choir, Youth Echo Choir, Pavol 
          Procházka (Chorus Master) Slovak Radio 
          Symphony Orchestra,   
          Slovak Philharmonic Orchestra/Ondrej Lenárd 
          Rec. Concert Hall of Czechoslovak Radio, Bratislava, 
          29-31 March and 16-22 October 1989.Reissue 
          - first released on Marco Polo 8.223280/1 
            
          NAXOS 8.557418/9 [59'11 + 54'56 = 114'07] 
          [PSe] 
         
         The 
          only First, in spite of the ‘Titan’. An excellent 
          recording of a fervent performance, which 
          is just as well, because it’s the only one. 
          ... see Full Review 
           
          Anton BRUCKNER 
          (1824-1896) 
          Piano Works:- Sonata 
          Movement in G minor (1862) Stille Betrachtung 
          an einem Herbstabend (1863) Steiermärker 
          (c.1850) Lancier-Quadrille (c.1850) 
          Klavierstücke in E flat major (c.1856) 
          Fantasie in G major (1868) Erinnerung 
          (1868) Adagio from Symphony No. 
          7, arr. Cyrill Hynais (c. 1895)   
          Fumiko Shiraga (piano) Rec 18-20 July 
          2001, Friedrich-Ebert-Halle, Hamburg   
          BIS-CD-1297 [64.50] [TB]  
        
 Hardly 
          central to the repertory but offers fascinating 
          insights into the lesser known byways and 
          the artistic development of this remarkable 
          composer ... see Full 
          Review  
           
          MOZART 
          IN TURKEY (Die 
          Entführung aus dem Serail) Belmonte 
          (Tenor) Paul Groves Konstanze 
          (Soprano) Yelda Kodalli Blonde 
          (Soprano) Désirée 
          Rancatore Pedrillo (Tenor) Lynton Atkinson 
          Osmin (Bass) Peter Rose Pasha Selim 
          (Speaker) Oliver Tobias   
          Scottish Chamber Orchestra and Choir/Sir Charles 
          Mackerras Opera directed and filmed by Elijah 
          Moshinsky Film produced and directed by Mick 
          Csáky The opera highlights can be played 
          as a special feature, lasting 64 minutes. 
            DVD 
          Opus Arte OA0891D [88'04"] [JPo]  
        
 As 
          a production this disc gives a very reasonable 
          synopsis of the whole; it would be nice to 
          think that a DVD of the whole opera was in 
          preparation. ... see Full 
          Review  
           
          Wolfgang Amadeus 
          MOZART (1756-1791) 
          Concertos 
          for Wind: Clarinet Concerto in A, K622 
          (1791) [29’19). Sinfonia concertante in E 
          flat, K297b (1778) [30’05]. Oboe Concerto 
          in C, K314/285d (1778) [20’11]. Bassoon Concerto 
          in B flat, K191/186e (1774) [18’00]. Horn 
          Concerto No. 4 in E flat, K495 (1787) [14’57]. 
            
          Anthony Pike (clarinet); John Anderson 
          (oboe); Richard Berry (K495), John Thurgood 
          (K297b) (horns); Julie Price (bassoon); English 
          Chamber Orchestra/Ralf Gothóni. Rec. 
          Gateway Studios, Kingston upon Thames in February 
          2002 (K622), St Paul’s Church, London, N1 
          in May 2000.   
          AVIE AV0035 [59’39 + 53’27] TWO 
          for the price of ONE post-free 
        
 Retailing 
          at budget price, this is well worth snapping 
          up. Authenticists might not agree with everything, 
          but surely even they would get sucked in to 
          the spirit of it all. ... see 
          Full Review  
           
           
          Pyotr Ilyich 
          TCHAIKOVSKY (1840-1893): 
          Symphony 
          No. 6 in B minor (Pathétique), 
          Op. 74 (1893) [43’12"] Francesca da 
          Rimini, Fantasy for Orchestra, Op. 32 
          (1876)* [24’48"]   
          Gothenburg Symphony Orchestra/Neeme Järvi 
          Rec. Gothenburg Concert Hall on 23 & 24 
          Jan 2004 and *1 Sept 2003    
          BIS – SACD – 1348 [69’02"] [JQ]  
        
 In 
          a fiercely competitive field I fear I can’t 
          give this a strong endorsement. ... see Full 
          Review  
           
          Richard 
          WAGNER (1813-1883) 
          Siegfried 
          [abridged]: Act 1 - Scene 1: Preludea; 
          Zwangvolle Plage!b; Hioho! Hioho! 
          Hau’ ein! Hau’ ein!c; Als zullendes 
          Kind zog ich dich aufc; Soll ich 
          der Kunde glaubenc; Scene 2: Heil 
          dir, weiser Schmiedd; Dein Haupt 
          pfänd ichd; Scene 3e: 
          Fühltest du nie im finstren Wald; Nothung! 
          Nothung! Neidliches Schwert; Hoho! Hoho! Hahei! 
          … Schmiede, mein Hammer. Act 2 - Scene 1f: 
          In Wald und Nacht; Deine Hand helitest du 
          vom Hort?; Scene 2: Dass der mein Vater nicht 
          istg; Du holdes Vöglein!g; 
          Haha! Da hätte mein Liedh; 
          Scene 3: Wohin schleichst du eilig und schlauh; 
          Da lieg’ auch du, dunkler Wurm!i; 
          Hei! Siegfried erschlug nun den schlimmen 
          Zwergi. Act 3 – Scene 1j: 
          Prelude; Wache, Wala; Stark ruft das Lied; 
          Dir Unweisen ruf ich ins Ohr; Scene 2k: 
          Kenntest du mich, kühner Spross; Zich 
          hin!; Scene 3: Selige Öde auf sonniger 
          Höh’!l; Das ist kein Mann!l; 
          Heil dir Sonne!m; O Siegfried! 
          Siegfried!n; Ewig was ichn; 
          Dich lieb ichn; Ob jetzt ich dein?n. 
            
           ceghiklnLauritz Melchior, bcdhHeinrich 
          Tessmer, eAlbert Reiss (tenors); 
          iNora Grubn, mnFlorence 
          Easton (sopranos); jMaria Olszewska 
          (contralto); fhEduard Habich (baritone); 
          dfFriedrich Schorr, kRudolf 
          Bockelmann (bass-baritone); a-i, k,lLondon 
          Symphony Orchestra/a-d, fhlRobert 
          Heger, egikAlbert Coates, jVienna 
          State Opera Orchestra/Karl Alwin; mnOrchestra 
          of the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden/Robert 
          Heger  
          Performance background and plot synopsis included. 
          From HMV a-dDB1713 and 1578/81, 
          eD 1690/1, fDB1582, 
          gD1692, hiD1693, jDB1533/4, 
          kDB1694, lD1836/7; Rec. 
          a-d,fLondon, a-dMay, 
          fMay 21st, 1931, lMay 
          12th, 1930, mnMay 29th, 
          1932, egQueen’s Hall, London on 
          May 16th-g17th, 
          1929, iMay 17th and 
          ik22nd, 1929, hMay 
          21st, 1931, jVienna 
          in 1929.  
            
          NAXOS HISTORICAL 8.110091/92 [151’30: 
          79’04 + 72’26]. [CC]  
        
 Products 
          such as this are increasingly valuable. The 
          ‘Golden Age’ of singing should be remembered. 
          If you have ever shied away from Siegfried’s 
          magnificent edifice, now would be a good time 
          to investigate ... see Full 
          Review  
           
          Mirijam Contzen 
          Johann Sebastian BACH 
          (16.85-1750) Partita 
          No. 3 in E Major BWV 1006: Preludio [3.22], 
          Loure [3.46], Gavotte en Rondeau 
          [2.53], Menuet 1 – Menuet II – Menuet I 
          [3.57], Bourée [1.23]. Gigue 
          [1.46] Tibor VARGA 
          (1921-2003)  
          Le Serpent [6.41] Béla 
          BARTÓK (1881-1945) Sonata 
          for solo violin Sz 117: Tempo die Ciaccona 
          [9.14], Fuga [4.07], Melodia [6.36], 
          Presto [5] Igor 
          STRAVINSKY (1882-1971) Élegie 
          [5.26] Eugène 
          YSAŸE (1858-1931) Sonate Op. 
          27 No. 4: Allemande. Lento maestoso 
          [6.16], Sarabande. Quasi lento [3.30], 
          Finale. Presto ma non troppo [3.05] 
           Mirijam 
          Contzen (violin) Recorded Reitstadel Neumarkt, 
          12-14 January 2004   
          BMG ARTE NOVA CLASSICS 82876 57741 
          2 [67.53] [EM] 
        Not 
          a disc I would personally recommend, but of 
          its kind (publicity-machine compilation disc), 
          it is probably one of the better. ... see 
          Full Review  
          
           
           
          
        Erik 
          CHISHOLM (1904-1965) 
          Straloch 
          Suite (1933) [15:59] Scottish Airs 
          for Children (1940s) [27:54] Sonata in 
          A An Riobain Dearg (abridged version, 
          2004) (1939)   
          Murray McLachlan, piano Rec. Whiteley Hall, 
          Chethams School, Manchester, 5-7 April 2004. 
          DDD   
          DUNELM RECORDS DRD0222/LC-12952 [77:24] 
          [DHJ] 
        The 
          Sonata - a major example of 20th century piano 
          writing ... the effect is almost overwhelming. 
          Self recommending ... see Full 
          Review  
         
          Claude DEBUSSY 
          (1862–1918) 
          Mélodies 
          de Jeunesse: Apparition, Romance, 
          Les paillons, Calmes sans le demi-jour, 
          Regret.Ariettes Oubliées: C’est 
          le extase, Il pleure dans mon coeur, 
          L’ombre des arbres, Paysages belges: 
          chevaux de bois, Aquarelles - Green, 
          Aquarelles - SpleenProses lyriques: 
          De rêve, De grève, 
          De fleurs, De soir.Trois poèmes 
          de Mallarmé: Soupir, 
          Placet futile, Éventail 
            
          Sandrine Piau (soprano), Jos van Immerseel 
          (piano) rec. Liège, July 2002. DDD 
            
          NAÏVE V4932 [57’25"] [AO] 
        Piau's 
          careful phrasing and deft articulation of 
          the musical line throw the structure of the 
          songs into focus, allowing us to appreciate 
          their beauty in pure form ... see Full 
          Review 
         
          Gaetano 
          DONIZETTI (1797-1848)L’elisir 
          d’amore (excerpts) Adina – Mariella 
          Devia (soprano) Nemorino – Roberto Alagna 
          (tenor) Belcore – Pietro Sapgnoli (bartone) 
          Dulcamara - Bruno Pratico (bass-baritone) 
          Giannetta - Francesca Provvisionato (mezzo-soprano) 
            
          Tallis Chamber Choir English Chamber Orchestra/Marcello 
          Viotti Rec. All Saints Church, Petersham, 
          1992   
          WARNER APEX 2564 61496-2 [71.44] [RH] 
        An 
          ideal introduction to this delightful opera 
          ... buy it anyway to hear what the young Alagna 
          could do ... see Full 
          Review  
         
          Sergei PROKOFIEV 
          (1891-1953) 
          Piano 
          Concerto No. 1 in D flat major, op. 10 [15:27] 
          Nikolai Lugansky, piano Royal Scottish National 
          Orchestra/Alexander Lazarev Symphony No. 
          5 in B flat major, op. 100 [43:31]   
          National Youth Orchestra of Great Britain/Yan 
          Pascal Tortelier Rec. live Royal Albert Hall, 
          London, 8 Sept 2003 (No. 1); 9 Aug 2003 (No. 
          5) DDD  
          WARNER CLASSICS 2564 61551-2 [59:08] [KS] 
           
         A 
          document of what must have been a very impressive 
          live concert ... not certain that they live 
          up to an international standard. A hedged 
          recommendation ... see Full 
          Review  
         AUDIOPHILE 
          RECORDING OF THE MONTH Peter 
          Ilyich Tchaikovsky 
          (1840 - 1893) Swan 
          Lake Ballet Op 20 (1875/7) [104.46] 
            
          Utah Symphony Orchestra/Maurice Abravanel 
          Recording location and date not given [1967?] 
          On disk extras: photos and documents of artists; 
          memorial tribute speech by Ardean Watts [16.00]; 
          "remembering the Utah Symphony Orchestra 
          3.00];" Composer biography; Technical 
          documentary [6.00]; Speaker set-up utility. 
          DVD-Audio 2.0 and 5.1. DVD 2.0 and 5.1 AC-3. 
          ADD Playable on all 
          DVD players   
            
          SILVERLINE CLASSICS DVD-AUDIO 
          288235-9 [104.46 + 25.00] [PSh]  
         The 
          greatest Tchaikovsky, brilliantly performed, 
          a pinnacle of recorded surround sound ... 
          see Full 
          Review  
          
          Richard WAGNER 
          (1860-1911) 
          Der fliegende Holländer Hildegard 
          Behrens - Senta Matti Salminen - Daland Franz 
          Grundheber - The Dutchman Riamo Sirkiä 
          - Erik Anita Välkki - Mary Jorma Silvastri 
          - Steersman Ilkka Bäckmann - Director 
            
          Savonlinna Opera Festival Orchestra and 
          Chorus/Leif Segerstam Savonlinna Opera Festival 
          1989 DVD-9 Region: 2,3,4.5.6    
          NVC ARTS/YLEISRADIO-TV1. WARNER MUSIC VISION 
          9031-71486-2RM [139.00"] [AO] 
            
         
         The 
          simplicity of this film reflects the Savonlinna 
          ethos. It is unpretentious, almost to the 
          point of seeming superficially casual. Musically 
          and artistically, however, the standards are 
          very high indeed. ... see 
          Full Review 
          
          The Best of 
          British Vol. 1 Ralph 
          VAUGHAN WILLIAMS (1872-1958) Flourish 
          for Wind Band Percy 
          GRAINGER (1882-1961) Lincolnshire 
          Posy Alun HODDINOTT 
          (b.1929) Welsh Airs and Dances 
          Gustav HOLST 
          (1874-1934) (arr. John Boyd) Japanese 
          Suite Edward 
          ELGAR (1857-1934) (arr. M. Retford) 
          Pomp and Circumstance March No. 4 Pomp 
          and Circumstance March No. 1 Percy 
          GRAINGER (1882-1961) (edited by R. 
          Mark Rogers) The Gum Suckers’ March 
            
          Tokyo Kosei Wind Orchestra/Douglas Bostock 
          Recorded at Sun Azalea, Suitama, October 21 
          and 22, 2003 DDD   
          KOSEI PUBLISHING COMPANY KOCD-8011 [57:46] 
          [CT] 
         
         Fine 
          playing from the Tokyo Kosei Wind Orchestra 
          in the first of a series of discs celebrating 
          British music. ... see Full 
          Review  
          
          Seiji Ozawa Hall 
          10th Anniversary Celebration  
          Ludwig Van BEETHOVEN 
          (1770-1827) 
          String Quartet No. 12 in E-flat, Opus 127 
          (1st movement) Juilliard String Quartet July 
          1, 2001 Johannes 
          BRAHMS (1833-1897) Sonata in D 
          minor, Opus 108 (2nd movement) Yo-Yo Ma, cello; 
          Emanuel Ax, piano July 19, 2001 Béla 
          BARTÓK (1881-1945) String 
          Quartet No. 2, Opus 17 (2nd movement) Emerson 
          String Quartet July 25, 1995 Frédéric 
          CHOPIN (1810-1849) Berceuse 
          in D-flat, Opus 57 Dubravka Tomsic, piano 
          July 16, 2003 Claude 
          DEBUSSY (1862-1918) La Danse 
          de Puck Richard Goode, piano August 1, 
          2002 György 
          LIGETI (1923-) Fém Pierre-Laurent 
          Aimard, piano July 20, 2003 Toru 
          TAKEMITSU (1930-1996) Shuteiga 
          ("In an Autumn Garden"): Enbai 
          ("Melisma") Reigakusha July 23, 
          1996 Augusta Read 
          THOMAS (1964-) Two movements from 
          Spirit Musings Fellows of the Tanglewood 
          Music Center July 18, 2003 Johannes 
          BRAHMS "Unbewegte laue Luft," 
          Opus 7, No.8 Lorraine Hunt Lieberson, mezzo-soprano; 
          Peter Serkin, piano July 10, 2003 Franz 
          SCHUBERT (1797-1828) "Irrlicht" 
          from Winterreise, D. 911 Matthias Goerne, 
          baritone; Eric Schneider, piano July 10, 2002 
          Hugo WOLF 
          (1860-1903) "Kennst du das Land" 
          Mitsuko Shirai, mezzo-soprano; Harmut Höll, 
          piano July 18, 1996 Wolfgang 
          Amadeus MOZART (1756-1791) Leporello’s 
          Catalogue Aria from Don Giovanni Thomas 
          Quasthoff, bass-baritone; Freiburg Baroque 
          Orchestra August 11, 1999 Idris 
          LEWIS "Bugail Aberdyfi" 
          ("Shepard of Aberdovey") Byrn Terfel, 
          bass-baritone; Malcolm Martineau, piano August 
          11, 1998 TRAD. (arr. 
          James Erb and Donald Bartholomew) "Shenandoah" 
          Chanticleer August 5, 1999 Astor 
          PIAZZOLLA (1921-1992) (arr. José 
          Bragato) Escualo  
          KREMERata Baltica/Gidon Kremer, artistic director 
          and violin soloist August 5, 1998   
          BOSTON SYMPHONY ORCHESTRA - NO NUMBER [75:57] 
          [C Andres]  
         A 
          collection of first-rate souvenirs that is 
          ultimately less than the sum of its parts 
          ... see Full Review 
           
           
         
           
         BOOK 
          REVIEWS 
          
          ALMA 
          ROSÉ: VIENNA TO AUSCHWITZ by 
          Richard Newman with Karen Kirtley   
          Amadeus Press ISBN 1-57467-051-4 [CF] 
        Her 
          native Vienna has marked her life with a street 
          named after her but this book is a more fitting 
          testimonial. ... see 
          Full Review 
        The 
          Amadeus: Forty 
          years in pictures and words 
        What 
          an apt title for this splendid publication 
          ... see Full Review 
           
         
          There was a 
          Time…Ralph Vaughan Williams - A pictorial 
          journey from the collection of Ursula Vaughan 
          Williams Edited 
          by: Stephen Connock, Ursula Vaughan Williams 
          and Robin Wells Albion Music Ltd (a division 
          of the RVW Society) hardback; 152 pages ISBN 
          0-9528706-4-9 £25 
        A 
          valuable addition ... but disappoints somewhat 
          considering that it is published by the Ralph 
          Vaughan Williams Society ... see 
          Full Review 
          
         
           
          UNEASY 
          LISTENING - A caricature guide to 20th 
          century composers  
          by John Minnion 109pp 
          Paperback ISBN 0-9544499 1 6 [RB] 
        
 This 
          is wonderfully well done as a book of illustrations. 
          It tells us something of the psychology of 
          the composer in each case and does so wittily 
          and not without taking a few dangerous corners. 
          ... see Full 
          Review  
          
             
         
         
         RECORDINGS 
        OF THE MONTH 
          
       
       
       
         
          Alan BUSH (1900-1995) 
          Symphony 
          No. 1 in C Op. 21 (1940) [32:54] Symphony 
          No. 2 Op. 33 Nottingham (1949) [35:20] 
            
          Royal Northern College of Music Orchestra/Douglas 
          Bostock rec. 7-8 Feb 2004, RNCM, Manchester, 
          DDD   
          CLASSICO CLASSCD 484 [71:28] [RB]  
         Music 
          of a distinctive mastery with a peculiarly 
          British rigour and a constrained emotionalism. 
          ... see Full Review 
           
          
          Paul 
          Le FLEM (1881-1984) 
          Piano 
          Quintet (1905) [36:40] Violin Sonata (1905) 
          [28:57]   
          Philippe Koch (violin) Alain Jacquon (piano) 
          Quatuor Louvigny rec. Villa Louvigny, Luxembourg, 
          Nov 2003-Jan 2004. DDD   
          TIMPANI 1C1077 [65:37] [RB]  
         The 
          surging romance of this music will attract 
          anyone open to the youthful melodic rush of 
          Howells, Ravel, Bax and Ropartz. Outstanding. 
          Glorious. ... see Full 
          Review  
         Gustav 
          MAHLER (1860-1911) 
          Des 
          Knaben Wunderhorn   
          Thomas Hampson, baritone, Wolfram Reiger, 
          piano Rodney Greenberg, director Théâtre 
          Musical de Paris, Châtelet, 25 October 
          2002 DVD-9 Region: All RM ASSOCIATE/THÉÂTRE 
          MUSICAL DE PARIS – CHÂTELET/MEZZO "Voices 
          of Our Time"   TDK 
          DVD DVVTTHEUR [91.00"] [AO]  
           
         "Song 
          is a metaphor for the giving of the soul", 
          says Hampson, and the Wunderhorn poems helped 
          Mahler express ideas dear to him. Altogether, 
          an unmissable, enriching experience. ... see 
          Full Review 
           
          
          Sergei PROKOFIEV 
          (1891-1953) 
          Sonata 
          No. 2 for violin and piano in D, Op. 94a [24:10] 
          Eugène YSAŸE 
          (1858-1931) Sonata No. 3 in d minor 
          "Ballade" for unaccompanied violin, 
          Op. 27, no. 3 [6:59] Ernest 
          CHAUSSON (1855-1899) Poème, 
          op. 25 [14:41] Camille 
          SAINT-SAËNS (1835-1921) Sonata 
          for violin and piano no. 1 in d minor, op. 
          75 [23:51]   
          Jack Liebeck, violin Katya Apekisheva, piano 
          Rec. Wathen Hall, St. Paul’s School, England, 
          25 May, 2 July 2003. DDD   
          QUARTZ QTZ 2002 [70:00] [KS]  
         Brilliant 
          performances. Recommended without a moment’s 
          hesitation. ... see Full 
          Review   
           
         Ferdinand 
          RIES (1784 
          – 1837) Symphony 
          No. 7 in A minor Op. 181 (1835) Symphony 
          No. 8 in E Flat, Wo0 30 (1822)   
          Zurich Chamber Orchestra/Howard Griffiths. 
          Rec. 2-7 May 2002, Neumunsterkirche, Zurich, 
          Switzerland. DDD   
          CPO 999 904-2 [67.16] [JPh]  
         I 
          recommend this disc without reservation, and 
          look forward to hearing the others in this 
          superbly played, conducted and recorded series. 
          ... see Full Review 
           
         Camille 
          Saint-Saëns 
          (1835 - 1921) Symphony 
          #3 in c, Op 78 "Organ Symphony" 
          (1886) [35.57] Frederick Minger, organ Baltimore 
          Symphony Orchestra/Sergiu Comissiona Recorded 
          National Presbyterian Church, Washington, 
          D.C., USA, 1980. Cesar 
          FRanck (1822 - 1890) Symphony in 
          d, M.48 (1888) [38.58]   
          Houston Symphony Orchestra/Sergiu Comissiona 
          Recorded Jesse Jones Hall, Houston, TX, USA, 
          April 1982. Notes in English, track-list and 
          artists and technicians roster. On screen 
          extras: Speaker set-up utility, background 
          documentary, composer bios. DVD Audio 2.0 
          and 5.1. DVD 2.0 and 5.1 AC-3 Dolby Digital 
          Surround  DVD-Audio 
          playable on all DVD players   
          SILVERLINE CLASSICS 288231-9 [74.55] [PSh] 
          
         Brilliantly 
          performances of difficult and spectacular 
          orchestral music, gorgeous recorded sound 
          ... see Full 
          Review  
         Peter 
          Ilyich Tchaikovsky 
          (1840 - 1893) Romeo 
          and Juliet, Overture-Fantasia in b (1870) 
          [28.38] Concerto for Piano & Orchestra 
          #1 in bb, Op 23 (1875) [34.07]   
           John Ogdon, piano Symphony #5 in e, Op 
          64 (1888) [45.24] London Symphony Orchestra/Pierre 
          Monteux Recorded live at the Grosser Konzerthaussall, 
          Vienna, Austria, 31 May 1963 Notes in English: 
          track list, artist and technical credits. 
          On disk extras: composer biography, technical 
          documentary ADD DVD-Audio 
          playable on all DVD players.   
           SILVERLINE 
          CLASSICS 288 228-9 [108.09] [PSh]  
         One 
          of the finest Tchaikovsky disks ever produced, 
          sound and performance, equally a must-have 
          for seasoned collectors as well as those just 
          starting out ... see Full 
          Review  
          
          Songs 
          after Poems by Theodor Storm: Hermann 
          REUTTER (1900-1985)Fünf Lieder 
          nach Texten von Storm, Die Stadt, Hyazinthen 
          Verirrt, O bleibe treu den Toten, Wohl fühle 
          ich, wie das Leben rinnt Johannes 
          BRAHMS (1833-1897)Über die 
          Heide hallet mein Schritt, Heinrich 
          van EYKEN (1861-1908) Nun geht 
          der Mond durch Wolkennacht Felix 
          MOTTL (1856-1911) Schließe 
          mir die Augen beide Gustav 
          JENNER (1865-1920) Noch einmal 
          Paul CARRIÈRE 
          (1887-1929) Schließe mir die Augen 
          beide Alban BERG 
          (1885-1935) Die Nachtigall Gustav 
          STOLZ (1873-1957) Als ich dich 
          kaum geseh’n Hans 
          von BLOME (1834-1921) Die Nelken 
          Gustav EGGERS 
          (1835-1861) So dunkel die Straßen 
          Richard TRUNK 
          (1879-1968) Die Stadt Othmar 
          SCHOECK (1886-1957) April Alban 
          BERG (1885-1935) Schließe 
          mir die Augen beide Richard 
          MANDL (1859-1918) Gode Nacht Max 
          REGER (1873-1916) Nelken Franz 
          SCHREKER (1878-1934) Wohl fühl 
          ich, wie das Leben rinnt Joseph 
          MARX (1882-1964) Schließe 
          mir die Augen beide Gustav 
          JENNER (1865-1920) Die Nachtigall 
          Hans HERMANN 
          (1870-1931) Nelken Hans 
          Christian DÉTLEFSEN (* 1951) 
          Fünf Gedichte von Theodor Storm , 
          Meeresstrand, Die Stadt, Ein grünes Blatt, 
          Schließe mir die Augen beide, Zur Nacht 
            
          Ulf Bästlein (baritone), Charles Spencer 
          (piano) Recorded Bad Arolsen, August 21-24, 
          2003. DDD   
          MUSIK DABRINGHAUS UND GRIMM MDG 603 1234-2 
          [66'33] [AO]  
         A 
          wonderful landmark recording that demonstrates 
          how poetry is translated into song ... see 
          Full Review  
           
           
       
       
       
       
       
        BARGAIN OF THE MONTH 
          
          
          Béla BARTÓK 
          (1881—1945) 
          Yehudi 
          Menuhin, violin and viola CD1 Violin Concerto 
          No. 1, BB 48a (1907—8) Viola Concerto, BB 
          128(1945) (ed. Tibor Serly) New Philharmonia 
          Orchestra/Antal Dorati Rhapsody No. 1 for 
          violin and orchestra. BB 94b (1928—9) Rhapsody 
          No. 2 for violin and orchestra, BB 96b (1928, 
          rev. 1935) BBC Symphony Orchestra/Pierre Boulez 
          CD2 Violin Concerto No.2, BE 117 (1937—8) 
          New Philharmonia Orchestra/Antal Dorati Six 
          movements from 44 Duos for two violins, BB 
          104 (1931): Sorrow; New Year’s Greeting; Harvest 
          Song; Bagpipes; Scherzo; Arabian Song   
          Yehudi Menuhin and Nell Gotkovsky, violins 
          Sonata for solo violin, BR 124 (1944) Recorded: 
          1965 (Violin Concertos), 1966 (Viola Concerto),Kingsway 
          Hall, London;1965 (Duos), 1968 (Rhapsodies), 
          1974, 1975 (Sonata), Abbey Road Studios, London 
            
          EMI CLASSICS 7243 585487 2 [67:28 + 72:46] 
          [JL] 
        A 
          bargain double-disc package that brings together 
          one of the twentieth century’s greatest composers 
          with one of its leading performing artists 
          in renderings of unmatched authority. ... 
          see Full Review 
           
        Frank 
          BRIDGE (1879-1941) 
          Enter Spring (Rhapsody) (1927) [19:20] 
          Summer (Tone Poem) (1914) [9:40] Two 
          Poems for orchestra (1915) [10:56] The 
          Sea - Suite (1911) [21:39]   
          New Zealand SO/James Judd rec. Michael Fowler 
          Centre, Wellington, NZ, 11-15 Nov 2002. DDD 
            
          NAXOS 8.557167 [62:17] [RB]  
         A 
          good inexpensive introduction to Frank Bridge 
          - a by no means parochial composer. The music 
          is unsettling and startlingly original in 
          the case of Enter Spring. ... see Full 
          Review  
         Benjamin 
          BRITTEN (1913-76) 
          Peter 
          Grimes, Op.33 (1945) Glenn Winslade 
          – Peter Grimes Janice Watson – Ellen Orford 
          Anthony Michaels-Moore – Captain Balstrode 
          Jill Grove – Auntie Catherine Wyn-Rogers – 
          Mrs Sedley Nathan Gunn – Ned Keene   
          London Symphony Orchestra and Chorus/Sir Colin 
          Davis Recorded live at the Barbican 10-12 
          January 2004. budget price, www.lso.co.uk 
            
          LSO LIVE LSO0054 [55’06 + 48’32 + 39’05] 
          [MB]  
         Quite 
          easily the best-played Grimes on disc ... 
          see Full Review 
           
         David 
          DIAMOND (b.1915) 
          Psalm 
          (1936) [8:39] Kaddish (1987) [10:44] 
          Symphony No. 3 (1945) [31:08]   
          Janos Starker (cello) Seattle Symphony Orchestra/Gerard 
          Schwarz. Rec. 11-12 Sept 1990; 6 Jan 1991, 
          Seattle Center Opera House. DDD Originally 
          issued on Delos DE3103 American Classics series 
            
          NAXOS 8.559155 [59:19] [RB]  
         A 
          disc not to be missed if you are at all sympathetic 
          to the tonal-melodic strain in twentieth century 
          music. Music written from the heart to the 
          heart ... see Full 
          Review  
          
          Gioachino 
          ROSSINI (1792-1868) 
          La 
          Cenerentola - opera buffa in two acts 
          Angiolina (Cenerentola), Jennifer Larmore 
          (mezzo); Don Ramiro, Raúl Giménez 
          (ten); Dandini, Gino Quilico (bar); Don Magnifico, 
          Alessandro Corbelli (buffa-bass); Alidoro, 
          Alastair Miles (bass)   
          Chorus and Orchestra of the Royal Opera House, 
          Covent Garden, London/Carlo Rizzi Recorded 
          in Abbey Road Studios, London, in February 
          1994   
          WARNER APEX 2564 61503-2 [74.48] 
          [RJF]  
         This 
          generously timed and tracked selection of 
          highlights from an exhilarating performance 
          is thoroughly recommended. If it tempts you 
          to purchase the full recording you will enjoy 
          that too. ... see Full 
          Review 
          
          Robert SCHUMANN 
          (1810 
          – 1856) Symphony 
          No. 1 in B Flat major The Spring, Op. 
          38 (1831) Symphony No. 2 in C Major, Op. 61 
          (1848) Symphony No. 3 in E Flat The Rhenish 
          Op.97 (1850) Symphony No. 4 in D Minor, 
          Op.120 (1851)   
          Tonhalle Orchestra, Zurich/David Zinman Recorded 
          13 – 16 October 2003 in the Tonhalle, Zurich. 
            
          ARTE NOVA 82876 57743-2 [65.39 + 57.38] 
          [JPh]  
         If 
          you see Schumann as a radical, a bit of a 
          firebrand pushing back the barriers of symphonic 
          thought, then Zinman is definitely for you. 
          Would compete with alternative sets at any 
          price ... see Full 
          Review  
          
           
          Ralph VAUGHAN WILLIAMS 
          (1872-1958) 
          The Nine Symphonies A 
          Sea Symphony* (1909) [65’43"] Symphony 
          No. 2 "A London Symphony" 
          (1914) [46’20"] A Pastoral Symphony 
          (Symphony No. 3) ** (1921) [38’03"] 
          Symphony No. 4 in F Minor (1935) [33’58"] 
          Symphony No 5 in D (1943) [41’53"] Symphony 
          No. 6 in E Minor (1947) [34’25"] Sinfonia 
          Antartica (Symphony No. 7) *** (1952) 
          [44’01"] Symphony No. 8 in D Minor (1955) 
          [28’34"] Symphony No. 9 in E Minor (1958) 
          [38’39"] Concerto Accademico for 
          Violin and Orchestra in D Minor**** (1925) 
          [15’59"] The Wasps: Overture (1909) 
          [8’59"] Three Portraits from "The 
          England of Elizabeth" (Suite adapted 
          by Muir Matheson) (1955) [17’26"] Concerto 
          for Bass Tuba and Orchestra in F Minor ***** 
          (1954) [12’19"] * Heather Harper (soprano); 
          John Shirley-Quirk (baritone); London Symphony 
          Chorus ** Heather Harper (soprano); William 
          Bennett (flute); Roger Lord (oboe); Anthony 
          Camden (cor anglais); Gervase de Peyer (clarinet); 
          Anthony Halstead (horn); Osian Ellis (harp); 
          John Georgiadis (violin); lexander Taylor 
          (viola); Douglas Cummings (cello) *** Heather 
          Harper (soprano); The Ambrosian Singers; Sir 
          Ralph Richardson (speaker) **** James Oliver 
          Buswell IV (violin)  
          ***** John Fletcher (bass tuba)   
           London Symphony Orchestra/André 
          Previn Recording dates and venues not given. 
          Recording dates from other sources: Sea, 
          1970; London 1972, Concerto Accademico, 
          1969; Wasps, 1972; Pastoral, 
          1972; 4, 1969; 5, 1972; Three Portraits, 
          1968; Concerto for Tuba, 1972; 6, 1968; 9, 
          1971; Antartica, 1967; 8, 1968. London. 
          ADD  
          Previously issued as RCA Gold Seal GD90500/01/03/06/08/10. 
          Originally issued on LP 1968-1972.   
          BMG-RCA RED SEAL 82876-55708-2 [6 CDs: 
          65’43" + 71’18" + 72’13" + 
          72’16" + 73’09" + 73’ 02"] 
          [JQ]  
         Wonderful, 
          life-enhancing music. I enjoyed this set enormously 
          from start to finish ... one of Previn’s finest 
          achievements in the recording studio. Recommended 
          with great enthusiasm. ... see Full 
          Review  
           
         English 
          Choral Music  Sir 
          Charles Villiers STANFORD (1852-1924): 
          Magnificat 
          in G, op. 81* [4’13"] Nunc Dimittis in 
          G, Op. 81 [4’18"] Justorum Animae from 
          Three Latin Motets [3’24"] Sir 
          Edward ELGAR (1857-1934): Ave verum 
          corpus, Op. 2, No 1 [2’39"] Give unto 
          the Lord (Psalm XXIX), Op. 74 [7’50"] 
          Ralph VAUGHAN WILLIAMS 
          (1872-1958): The Call* [2’05"] Herbert 
          HOWELLS (1892-1983): Magnificat, 
          St. Paul’s [6’33"] Nunc Dimittis, St. 
          Paul’s [4’59"] Paean for organ ** [6’03"] 
          Take him, earth, for cherishing [7’44"] 
          Peter HURFORD 
          (b. 1930): Litany to the Holy Spirit* 
          [2’56"] Gerald 
          FINZI (1901-1956): Welcome Sweet 
          and Sacred Feast, Op. 27, No. 3 [7’31"] 
          Edmund RUBBRA 
          (1901-1986): Tenebrae Motets – Third Nocturne, 
          Op. 72: I Eram quasi agnus innocens [2’50"]; 
          II Una hora non potuistis [2’02"]; III 
          Seniores populi [2’22"] Magnificat in 
          A flat [4’18"] Gerald 
          FINZI: God is gone up, Op. 27, 
          No. 2 [4’24"] Sir 
          William WALTON (1902-1983): Set 
          me as a seal upon thine heart [3’34"] 
          Soloists: Oliver Lepage-Dean (treble) and 
          Edward Lyon (tenor) Coronation Te Deum (arr. 
          Simon Preston & Mark Blatchly) [9’50"] 
          Gloria from Missa Brevis  [3’24"] 
          Soloists: Oliver Lepage-Dean (treble) and 
          Geoffrey Silver (tenor) Benjamin 
          BRITTEN (1913-1976): A Hymn to 
          the Virgin [3’06"] Soloists: William 
          Goldring (treble); Christopher de la Hoyde 
          (alto); Simon Wall (tenor); Reuben Thomas 
          (bass) Jubilate Deo [2’38"] Hymn to St. 
          Cecilia, Op. 27 [10’20"] Soloists: Benedict 
          Giles, Ben Harrison (trebles); Richard Moore 
          (alto); Jonathan Bungard (tenor); Reuben Thomas 
          (bass) Lennox BERKELEY 
          (1903-1989): The Lord is my Shepherd, 
          Op.91, No. 1 [4’21"] Soloist: Benjamin 
          Durrant (treble) Crux Fidelis, Op. 43, No. 
          2 [6’53"] Soloist: Alan Clayton (tenor) 
          Look up, Sweet Babe, Op. 43, No.2 [4’34"] 
          Soloist: James Geidt (treble) Kenneth 
          LEIGHTON (1929-1988): Magnificat 
          and Nunc Dimittis, Collegium Magdalenae 
          Oxoniese {8’16"] An Easter Sequence 
          – Sortie [4’11"] Soloist: Crispian Steele-Perkins 
          (trumpet) Sir John 
          TAVENER (b. 1944) The Lamb [3’47"] 
          The Lord’s Prayer [3’30"] Song for Athene 
          [5’43"]   
          *Oliver Lepage-Dean (treble) **Iain Farrington 
          (organ) The Choir of St. John’s College, Cambridge/Christopher 
          Robinson Recorded in the chapel of St. John’s 
          College, Cambridge on: 13 - 16 March, 1999 
          (Howells); 13 - 15 July, 1999 (Britten); 24 
          – 26 March, 2000 (Rubbra); 11 – 13 July, 2000 
          (Tavener); 17 – 19 March, 2001 (Finzi); 10 
          – 12 July, 2001 (Walton); 9 – 11 July, 2002 
          (Leighton); 12-13 July, 2002 (Stanford); 20 
          – 22 March, 2003 (Berkeley); 8 – 10 July, 
          2003 (Elgar); * February 2002. DDD   
          NAXOS 8.557557-58 [2 CDs: 149’51"] 
          [JQ] 
        I 
          recommend this excellent and enjoyable collection 
          with great enthusiasm. ... see 
          Full Review  
          
           
        
       
       
       
       
       Detailed listing (last two 
        days)] 
        [Part 1 New]  [Part 2 A-B] [Part 
        3 C-L] 
        [Part 4 M-R]  
        [Part 5 S-Z] 
        [Part 6 Misc A-L]  
        [Part 7 Misc M-Z] 
       
       
       
       
        
        
       
      Error processing SSI file 
       
        
       We 
        are grateful to 
        clipart.com for some of the special graphics 
        used on these pages  
       
       
       
        
        
        
        
        
           
             
               
                 
                  
                  Disclaimer 
                 Any 
                  opinions expressed in reviews or articles 
                  on this site are those of the author 
                  and  do not necessarily represent 
                  the views of the site owner, Len Mullenger 
                  or the Editors.  Reviewers and 
                  authors retain copyright in their 
                  work unless it has been paid for or 
                  commissioned by the site owner. 
                
             | 
           
         
      
       
        
         
          
          
          
           
           Return 
          to Front page 
      
  
       
         
        |