index page/monthly listings/May/

For those wishing to print these reviews with CD cover  graphics there are scrolling copies available
Month by Month index Alphabetical composer index

  COMPETITION - WIN a CD

Return to the June Index with thumbnails                       Part 1                         [Part 1]  [ Part 2]

Ancient Rome Feature

Hans ZIMMER and Lisa GERRARD
The Gladiator
OST
DECCA 467 094-2 [61:49]
Purchase from: Crotchet  Amazon UK  Amazon USA

It is suggested that this review is read in conjunction with the interview with Hans Zimmer, new on this site, this month, in which Zimmer comments in-depth on his music for Gladiator.

I have to say from the outset that the album impressed me more than the usage of the music in the film. In fact I have grown to like this album more and more on repeated hearings.

As Hans Zimmer says, he wanted to equate Lisa Gerrard’s music with Maximus’s, the Gladiator’s, thoughts of family and home in Spain. I have to confess feeling rather ambivalent about this choice, I was not entirely convinced. The music has a definite Middle-Eastern, almost Arabic feel about it, which might be thought to be at odds with the rather lush Spanish countryside where Maximus comes from. One can argue and justifiably, that the Moorish influence spilled over into Spain and Middle-Eastern modes strongly influenced European music well into the early centuries of the last millennium but that is to be unnecessarily academic. Anyway the opening shot, of the film, of a hand brushing over wheat is accompanied by this type of music with the voice of Lisa Gerrard, before the scene dissolves to reveal Maximus daydreaming of home in a wintry forest landscape just before the battle with the northern barbarians. This occupies the first two tracks of the CD segueing into the substantial 10-minute cue ‘The Battle’.

As Hans explained, ‘The Battle’ is based on the Viennese Waltz -- but brutalised. I will confess I was amazed at this explanation but listening carefully to the cue again, I could recognise the pattern. If you think about it, Hans may have a point, the Viennese Waltz is very formal, disciplined and the men often in uniform. Zimmer’s brutal, disciplined music is often submerged beneath the action as the legions, like some well-oiled monstrous machine, smash through the barbarian enemy. The rich, multi-layered music is a study in crescendo with many interesting facets including droning voices (anticipating mourning?), Spanish-rhythmed guitar chords, staccato jabs and slurs, and war-like trumpet figures. In places ‘Mars’ from Holst’s The Planets is recalled; at others, Walton’s ‘Battle in the Air’ from Battle of Britain. A seething cauldron, this music which can be enjoyed independently of the rest of the album (just forget the quotes, enjoy the ride). It’s a hi-fi enthusiast’s delight. So too is the 5½-minute cue ‘The Might of Rome’ although in this case I was disconcerted, when I saw the film, with Zimmer’s Wagner quotations (from Götterdämmerung – Siegfried’s Journey to the Rhine and Funeral Music). The associations created seemed confused, a real mixed metaphor—the mental link one could make between Wagner, Hitler, Commodus, Rome (before Commodus has a chance to exert his evil machinations) is somewhat tortuous and tentative, and anyway Siegfried was a hero! That apart, the music makes an impact, beginning in barbaric splendour, it is brutal and proud and hints at carnal pleasures before the Wagner-like music heralds majesty and solemnity. The other big set piece is the 11-minute cue, ‘Barbarian Horde’, exciting, fierce, crushing, very energetic; very much akin to the Battle music, with the Holst influence again apparent. The rhythms seem to have a swaying motion rather suggestive of the progress of a closed phalanx of soldiers moving relentlessly forward into battle confrontation, the brass braying in fury.

Of the other cues, I particularly liked the emotional restraint of ‘Patricide’. This is the music that underscores the complex scene between Commodus and Marcus Aurelius, in which the father is torn between sincere paternal affection for his wayward, dissolute and cowardly son and his duty to provide a strong succession for Rome. Commodus is devastated when he learns that his father has decided to favour Maximus and so suffocates Marcus Aurelius to inherit power. Zimmer’s music nicely captures these strong emotions and the dilemma, culminating in a crescendo for the murder. The music then segues into the cue ‘The Emperor is Dead’ in which the cymbalom/zither-like Chinese instrument is used. Again, this choice puzzled me because I could see no relevance, and when it reappeared during a scene between Commodus and his sister I was nonplussed unless it was some sort of signal for Commodus’s madness and evil? Whatever, it sounds good.

I would just mention ‘Am I Not Merciful?’ and ‘Now We Are Free’. The former is apparently music of the arena, in the aftermath of the fighting. It begins with an oblique reference to the Dies irae stated on double basses, low in the strings. The music’s heavy, mournful tread picks up as the music moves up through the strings and the tempo quickens but the atmosphere remains tragic and there is an echo of Lisa Gerrard’s music, men’s voices, wordless intoning, until a requiem-like climax is reached. The concluding cue, ‘Now we Are Free’ brings more relaxed, warmer music with Lisa Gerrard singing a muted celebration of victory mixing joy and optimism with grief; this is a victory bought at a price. This might be the commercial exploitation track that usually comes with big blockbuster epics these days.

Gladiator might be regarded as a flawed minor masterpiece in the Zimmer canon.

Reviewer

Ian Lace

---

Miklós RÓZSA
Ben-Hur Suite; Spellbound Concerto; Concerto for Piano and Orchestra
Danielle Laval (piano); Northern Hungarian Symphony Orchestra, Miskolc Conducted by László Kovács
VALOIS AUVIDIS (naïve) V 4841 [63:01]
Purchase from: Crotchet  Amazon UK  

Based on his own score for the 1945 Alfred Hitchcock production, Rózsa’s Spellbound concerto starts out as unequivocally romantic and yet because the story of the film centred around the lead character’s psychosis, an underlying darker tone gradually takes precedence and by the mid-way point we have truly descended into the heart of darkness. For me this is by far the best section of the piece, as it perfectly conjures the discord that can sometimes seize the human mind. The more routine romanticism that bookends it is less interesting however, although the finale itself stands up rather well.

The highlight of this CD though is unquestionably the suite from the multi-Oscar winning Ben Hur (including best score for Rózsa himself). Opening with the stunning ‘Prelude’, this is a rousing, majestic incorporation of the main themes from the film and in particular introduces the ‘Love Theme’ that is then expanded and given a fuller rendition in the next cue. A truly beautiful, emotional melody for strings and woodwind, this ranks as one of the great themes of cinema.

The next two pieces ‘Rowing of the Galley Slaves’ and ‘The Burning Desert’ drive along with a pounding urgency and are as fine an example of dramatic film music from this era as you are likely to hear. And when you think you have heard the best ‘The Mother’s Love’ proves beyond question what an incredible talent Rózsa really was with a heart-rending theme of real tenderness.

Finally ‘Parade of the Charioteers’ demonstrates his skill with fanfares, something that has been proven time and time again by his work on such historical blockbusters as Quo Vadis, King of Kings and El Cid. In fact, it could be argued that Rosza is the very voice of the movie epic. His sound and style have now become a part of our musical and cinematic consciousness.

Alongside his contemporary Bernard Herrmann, Miklos Rozsa was one of the true godfathers of film music, in the sense that his greatest work remains both timeless and influential. There is no sense of a style that has become outmoded or unsophisticated. Instead it sounds as fresh and original as it did when first heard.

To conclude the CD, Rózsa’s ‘Opus 31’, a work commissioned by pianist Leonard Pennario and completed in 1966, is given a full-blooded interpretation and makes a very interesting companion to his music written especially for film.

Made up of three movements, the first is the dark and dangerous ‘Allegro Energico’ with dissonant piano that is as intense as anything you are likely to find in his film work. Actually, this is similar to ‘Spellbound’ as it also evokes a sense of some troubled inner conflict.

‘Adagio’ features oboe and piano working together to bring to life a gentler theme, although there is still a sense of unrest with strings taking a firmer hold mid way through, before the piano is finally given its head in strident, incisive manner. This then subsides, fading out with genteel simplicity.

The tempo quickens with ‘Vigoroso’, the percussive and xylophone backing used to good effect. A number of different instruments take brief centre stage to create a mosaic of sound and although there are some respites, the tempo becomes steadily more manic, galloping on towards an almost frenzied conclusion.

For any established Rósza admirer this would appear to be a must-have. But also for those who have yet to discover this outstanding composer, this seems a very good place to start.

I suppose if there was a fault to be found with this collection it might be that for those who have more modern sensibilities, the two concertos are a little dense and demanding. But for those with an appreciation of more classical work or simply those looking to sample a taste of one the greatest film composers of the last century, they will certainly be in for a treat.

Reviewer

Mark Hockley

Ian Lace adds:-

The interest in this 1998 recording is that the orchestra is Hugarian (Rózsa was born in Budapest).

Their performance of this six-movement Ben-Hur Suite is generally very good; the majestic Prelude with those magnificent themes resounding splendidly. Kovács delivers a brilliant finale in which the ‘Parade of the Chariotteer’ fanfares really reach out and grasp you, and then there is a marvellously brutal ‘Rowing of the Galley Slaves’ with its accelerating cross-rhythms. The ‘Love Theme’ is sweetly eloquent too and ‘The Burning Desert’ nicely scorching, with that beatific music, most affecting, for the sequence where Jesus brings water to Ben-Hur.

The glamorous Danielle Laval attacks the bravura passages in the Spellbound concerto like a tigress and caresses the more delicate figures that end the Adagio of the Piano Concerto. Kovács eshews the theremin in the Spellbound concerto, opting for the same effect using brass and strings. This is a strong and enjoyable interpretation, full of romantic passion, if a little coarse-grained and wayward at times. The Piano Concerto fares even better. This is strong, diamond hard music more reminiscent of Rózsa’s film noire scores but with the more tender episodes very much akin to the Spellbound music.

Reviewer

Ian Lace

---

************************************************************** EDITOR’s CHOICE Classical Score June 2000 **************************************************************

Dimitri TIOMKIN
More Music from The Fall of the Roman Empire
CLOUD NINE/SILVA SCREEN CAN 7016 [44:35]
[As this title is now officially deleted finding a copy might prove difficult. Best "first port of call" would be SOUNDTRACKS DIRECT. Their new web-site is:www.silvascreen.co.uk and they can be e-mailed on: info@silvascreen.co.uk]

I very much regret that my choice this month is of a recording that has been deleted but assiduous searching may well reward keen Tiomkin fans (I saw one copy in HMV’s London Oxford Street flagship store). But quite frankly this score stands head and shoulders above practically all the material that has come into this office this month.

(With the exception of Rozsa’s Ben-Hur music but that was only a short suite in the Rózsa album reviewed this month)

Last month John Huether reviewed the Sony-PEG original soundtrack recording of Tiomkin’s The Fall of the Roman Empire music and in his concluding paragraph, John said that it would be nice to have another 20 or 30 minutes of the score in an expanded release. The Sony-PEG disc lasts for some 39 minutes. This expanded original soundtrack edition, boasting some 14 new selections, when it was released in 1991, clocks in at 44:35 minutes (an additional five minutes or so of music).

I agree with everything John Huether said last month about this score -- it is absolutely magnificent. That huge organ chord at the beginning of the Prelude lifts you from your seat and the magnificence and majesty of the treatment of the love theme through the Prelude with those powerful brass flourishes is hair-raising.

Pax Romana never fails to impress either no matter how many times one hears it, what a wonderful processional and as John Heuther aptly observed how it heightened the effectiveness of that long scene where the rulers of Rome’s far flung Empire paid tribute to the ailing Marcus Aurelius. And the Forum Romanum music, too, is full of splendour.

I will now pass on to a description of those 14 new selections that are included in this album.

The ‘Fanfares and Flourishes’ are heard as the cinema/theater lights dim and are a tingling anticipation. The misty delicate music of ‘Dawn on the Northern Frontier’ heralds a new day as Marcus Aurelius prepares to preside over the gathering of tribunes, consuls and kings – that is the Pax Romana. A busy orchestral flourish heralds ‘Livius’s Arrival’ speeding his chariot along treacherous Alpine byways. ‘Old Aquaintances’ underscores the early scenes where Livius (Stephen Boyd) warmly embraces Marcus Aurelius (Alec Guiness) and greets Timonides (James Mason) before the lovers reunion with the beautiful Lucilla (Sophia Loren); at this point the love theme is serene, unsullied by the dark portents of the Prelude. ‘Decoy Patrol’, ‘Battle in the Forest’ and ‘Reinforcements’ are all brilliant combat evocations steel clashing on steel, braying brass, fiery cross-rhythms and most impressive of all, wild and brutal timpani cross-rolls and hammer-like blows -- all tremendously muscular and immensely thrilling. Brutish, angular, oddly-accented rhythms for the barbarians are pitched against the remorseless formality of the Roman legions.

The Intermezzo: Livius & Lucilla is a vocal arrangement of the love theme. ‘Conflict in the Caverns’ is another wild confrontation with material very akin to ‘Battle in the Forest’ and ‘Decoy Patrol’. ‘Aftermath and the Journey to Rome’ has dissonances for the evil excesses perpetrated by Commodus. There is also more noble material as the rebellion (led by Lucilla with brief reference to the love theme) gains momentum. ‘The Army Enters Rome’ is music of celebration – pomp mixed with festive mandolins suggesting more intimate celebrations as the legions enter Rome but they have been won over by Commodus's gold. The cue finishes on a sour note reflecting Commodus’s increasingly unstable mental condition and continues in a twisted manner as the personal duel between Commodus and Livius becomes startlingly public and the two men engage in mortal combat.

Summing up, for those who already have a version of this score in their collection including the Sony-PEG edition which John Heuther reviewed last month (that seemed to contain yet other selections not included on this album), I am listing below what were claimed to be, when this album was released in 1991, the new selections so that you can see if there is some gap you might want to fill:-

Fanfares and Flourishes (0:51 set before the Prelude)

Dawn on the Northern Frontier (2:17)

Livius’ Arrival (1:02)

Old Aquaintances (4:31)

Decoy Patrol ():57)

The Battle in the Forest/Reinforcements (3:49)

Intermission Title (?)

Intermezzo: Livius & Lucilla 92:17)

Conflict in the Caverns (1:45)

Aftermath & the Journey to Rome (2:27)

The Army Enters Rome/The New God/The Challenge (4:03)

Restoring this masterpiece

This recording comes in part mono-part stereo format for when the record producers approached the owners of the film’s rights they discovered that the original music masters were no longer available. A world-wide search was instigated and it was three years before an excellent tape of certain cues was discovered – albeit in mono sound.

To quote from the booklet: "Although this find in no way constituted all or the best of the full score, it still contained some prime material and it was possible to draw additional selections from the Music and Effects track – including the original mix of the PRELUDE music, the opening fanfares and choral INTERMEZZO (these in stereo). All the available cues were transferred to digital tape and subsequently edited, sequenced and equalised utilising solely digital technology. However the recordings have not been "limited" in any way – effectively preserving the broad acoustic gained during the original sessions at Shepperton Studios and the Central-Hall at Westminster where the massive pipe organ had to be warmed by an array of electric fires for two days to bring it up to concert pitch. Much of the music on this album is being heard on disc for the first time – with other more familiar pieces being presented in the relatively fresh guise of their original soundtrack performances".

The 16 page booklet contains David Wishart’s full and articulate track analysis, two essays, "Profile of an Epic" (about the background and the making of the film) and "Dimitri Tiomkin’s score for The Fall of the Roman Empire" plus many colour and black and white stills from the film.

A magnificent score and an invaluable album. Although it is now deleted, perhaps Silva Screen will one day decide to reissue it for Tiomkin’s many fans, old and new?

Reviewer

Ian Lace

---

************************************************************** Editor Recommends June 2000 **************************************************************

James NEWTON HOWARD
Snow Falling on Cedars
OST
DECCA 466 818 2 [67:30]
Purchase from: Crotchet  Amazon USA

Yes, I know that we carried a review of this score on this site recently but our reviewer Paul Tonks got his review copy way before most other UK reviewers including myself. Paul was unenthusiastic and awarded the score only one star. I beg to differ. But that’s what Film Music on the Web is all about -- why we like to include more than one review to embrace a spectrum of opinion.

Snow Falling on Cedars, based on David Guterson’s best selling novel is set in 1954 on an island in the Pacific Northwest. It is a story of love thwarted by social pressures and familial customs. The drama stems from the crisis of Pearl Harbour following which there was a general feeling of paranoia and suspicion towards Japanese-Americans who were relocated to internment facilities where they remained for the duration of the war. The film focuses on the Anglo and Japanese-Americans who had lived in relative harmony on San Piedro a fictitious island off Puget Sound before the outbreak of hostilities. And the focus narrows to the childhood friendship and then the frowned-on teenage love of American Ishmael Chambers and Japanese-American, Hatsue. Nine years later, in 1954, Ishmael returns to find Hatsue’s husbnd, Kazuo is on trial for his life accused of murder.

James Newton Howards’s score is restrained and low key with its more vibrant colours provided by oriental instrumentation and harmonies. Tempi are slow, often very slow. There is no denying that this 67 minute-album does have its longeurs, as Paul Tonks intimates, particularly in the middle stretches where there is a measure of sameness that can become soporific. However, if one is selective of cues for future listenings (and they are worth it) there is much to admire here. The cues are played seamlessly without a break. Much use is made of a solo cello adding an autumnal glow and conveying a nostalgic sadness and poignancy. Voices add an element of mysticism.

The opening cue, ‘Lost in the Fog’, begins slowly, quietly and mistily with long held string chords and isolated bass drum strokes, gradually the music gathers momentum as though we see, through shredding mists, shapes gradually becoming distinct. The iron grip of winter, a desolate white landscape and a glassy calm sea is implicit in Newton Howard’s very evocative music. In many cues the intense winter chill is wonderfully sound-painted; the music glistens, it is crystalline and diamond hard. You can ‘see’ rows of cedars heavy with snow, gaunt’; the landscape frozen, still. At one point, what sounds like an aeolian harp allows random music to be plucked from the frosty air.

There are many cues that are very imaginative. ‘Moran finds the boat’ seems to suggest a boat rocking in a slight sea swell. ‘Typest’ and ‘Typing’ are little gems with most intriguing oriental orchestration and harmonies, very colourful. ‘The evacuation’ is infinitely sad and poignant speaking of alienation, separation and prejudice. A desolate chorale is followed by a battery of heavy, bass-drum gunfire that resounds around the sound stage.

One of the most moving cues is ‘Humanity goes on trial’, scored for strings and choir. It proceeds very much like Vaughan Williams’s Fantasia on a Theme of Thomas Tallis, very cathedral-like. In the middle a solo voice poignantly suggests complete isolation and alienation.

A very interesting score and one of Newton Howard’s best of late

Reviewer

Ian Lace

---

John BRION
Magnolia
Reprise 9 47696-2 [48:44]
Purchase from: Crotchet  Amazon UK  

The 3 hours plus of this movie seemed to have wall-to-wall music. It was a surprise to discover only 50 minutes of it on this disc. A disappointing surprise in fact, because this reviewer found the film to possess one of the most intriguing sound designs heard in a long time. The film is bracketed by documentary-like vignettes that offer a disclaimer on the fragmentation and randomness of life. This is the writer / director’s ruse to string together the lives of a disparate collection of character sketches. By having extremely lengthy musical cues develop over the top of the many jumps to and from these separate lives, a cohesive element was added. During the dramatic set-pieces, something like the 10 minute "Showtime" really helped in making sense of why one person’s problem might have anything to do with another’s.

Despite the album’s short-changing on running time (and even if you haven’t seen the film), these lengthy cues are a standalone treat. Only one small 45-second burst of inappropriateness disturbs the accumulative effect, and that’s the "WDKK Theme" sequenced in the middle of the cues.

Stylistically, much of the music bounces along like some jovial quaint circus accompaniment; which isn’t to be taken as negative by any means. Elsewhere, the time-stretching effect is achieved by sustaining notes at great length, making for an almost quasi-religious tone for many of the character’s falls from grace and / or redemption. Although a liner note comment suggests this all fell like divine inspiration from the pen of Brion, the cue "I’ve Got A Surprise For You Today" bears a distinct resemblance to Hans Zimmer’s The Thin Red Line. Same trick. Same result.

My recommendation is to see the movie to truly appreciate the ideas this music represents. Then listen to in isolation and enjoy the opportunity to create ideas of your own.

Reviewer

Paul Tonks

---

Angelo BADALAMENTI
The Beach
OST
LONDON RECORDS 4344311362 (40.41)
Purchase from:  Amazon UK  Amazon USA

With its at times striking mixture of strings, synth, drums and reverberating sound effects, Angelo Badalamenti has concocted a score that despite its ultimate shortcomings, certainly cannot be accused of being predictable.

‘Bizarre City’, all synth embellishments and pounding drums, kicks things off before making way for the very different approach of ‘The Beach Theme (Swim to Island)’ featuring traditional strings, piano and some restrained choral work. This is a lush, old-fashioned romantic melody, although it does switch mid-way into ominous synth and rhythm, before finally returning to the tinkling, syrupy main theme.

This gushy ultra romanticism is nothing new for Badalamenti and has been evident in past projects such as ‘Twin Peaks’. Although some may find it appealing, in this particular case I found it hard to take very seriously. It’s so overtly schmaltzy that it becomes almost like a parody. If that was the intent then it was very successful, but if not, it really is a quite nauseating.

These first two pieces sum up quite succinctly the main styles used throughout the score, with on the one hand ‘The Beach Theme’ dominating tracks like ‘Starnight’, ‘Mythical Waters’ and ‘Waterfall Cascade’, while strong synthesizer and rhythmic work highlights cues such as ‘Vision of Fantasy’ and ‘Killing Fields’. This latter piece is actually one of the most effective on offer with the imposing drum work really getting the adrenaline pumping, augmented mid-way through by a simple but powerful ascending four-note motif.

Probably the best of the string based pieces is ‘Mournful Myth’ which also incorporates some more subtle vocal work and really is as mournful as the title suggests and all the better for it! Another of the stronger pieces, ‘Pure Victims’, employs strings and brass in a powerful, disturbing cue with additional rumbling sound effects, that eventually trails away into low-key foreboding.

It’s a pity really that the highs do not outweigh the lows, because this does undoubtedly have its moments. But inevitably the cloying main theme undermines the entire score and I’m left with the distinct impression that Angelo Badalamenti’s dark side is far more interesting than his sweetness and light.

Reviewer

Mark Hockley

---

Harry GREGSON-WILLIAMS
The Tigger Movie
Original Score
PROMO [30:21]
Purchase from: Crotchet  Amazon UK  Amazon USA

It is said that to become a man one must put away childish things, including the fear of being child-like and the wish to be very adult. The manliest critique of Harry Gregson-Williams' score for "The Tigger Movie" you will ever read is probably this: "The Tigger Movie" is fun, fun, fun, fun, fun.

The composer appropriately uses a pure symphonic tone for all but the most assertive moments (and excluding a big band arrangement). He gives a few touching nods to the Tigger-ific Sherman Bros. songs from the "Winnie the Pooh" shorts. The interpolation of 'Winnie the Pooh' for the 'Main Title' got me grinning, and the adaptation within 'The Seasons Change' sparked the fire of my earliest memories. That the score is episodic as it accompanies our stuffed-with-fluff friends on another adventure creates small friction. It is otherwise charming and playful, at times heartfelt and dramatic. There is a dearth of 'mature' aesthetic baggage in the orchestrations that allows the direct (but by no means simplistic) structuring to work in its own way. The music sounds smart, youthful -- vigorously and entertainingly so. It is as animated as its catalyst.

Disney shortchanged the underscore with its 'songs & story' release. That this appears on a limited demonstration CD-R rather than appearing on store shelves says more of politics than art... or entertainment.

Reviewer

Jeffrey Wheeler

---

Pino DONAGGIO
Up at the Villa
OST
VARÈSE SARABANDE VSD-6128 [55:30]
Purchase from: Crotchet  Amazon UK  Amazon USA

I’m finding it more and more difficult to remember the Pino Donaggio of the 70s and early 80s. The contemporary Donaggio, unlike his youthful, perhaps somewhat impetuous self, seems to lack the spirit and originality that was so much a part of his earlier work. When I recall his beautiful, emotional melodies from Carrie (despite the fact that it was a horror movie!) Donaggio’s work here appears so devoid of inspiration. To my ears it is nothing more than background music, to be seen and not heard. And is that really all we want from a composer who is capable of so much more?

Primarily a string based work for a romantic drama set in the composer’s native Italy in the 1930’s, the main title, ‘Up at the Villa’ is a rather old-fashioned piece (although sadly not in the best sense) which is oddly oblique and much more about mood than melody. It’s all very low-key and unmemorable and this sets the tone for the work as a whole.

Brief moments of interest surface in tracks like ‘A Pistol in Florence’, ‘Tennis Plot-Flowers’ and ‘Arrivederci’, but these are very much in the minority and short-lived. The majority of the score is devoted to meandering, rather dull string and piano pseudo romanticism, which eventually becomes very tiresome. The only other distinctive score element features in tracks like ‘Party at Peppino’s’ and ‘Florence Two-Step’ which attempt to capture the authentic flavour of the musical styles of the era, but to be perfectly honest they are far from compelling and pass by without making any impact at all.

I truly can’t imagine many of Donaggio’s fans enjoying this. Melodic invention, surely the very thing that won them over in the first place, is sadly missing almost entirely here. Unfortunately, it’s all nothing more than wallpaper music.

A score that tries for an old-fashioned romantic sensibility from movies of long ago, but only really succeeds in emulating those who few of us actually remember.

Reviewer

Mark Hockley

---

Brian TYLER
The 4^th Floor
OST
GNP CRESCENDO 8064 [34:19]
Purchase from:   Amazon USA

I’m a little torn for how to summarise the experience of listening to this disc. The last album that had the same effect on my ear was Don Davis’ House On Haunted Hill. What I’m referring to is an over-abundance of different styles, but my problem this time around is in having absolutely no frame of reference. All I can find on this album (without researching elsewhere) is a reference to the film being "a story with otherworldly, horrific elements." It’s got Juliette Lewis and William Hurt in it – that’s horror enough for me right away, but since there is some fine melodic content here I’d like to be complimentary in context. It’s definitely an example of a CD needing explanatory booklet notes.

In just "Main Titles" alone there’s a disparate collection of things working together: a smoky female vocal, Armenian duduk, tinkling piano, gamelan (possibly sampled), and long-line tragic motif for strings and piano. It’s almost an overture, except for the absence of the cacophonous action style that later pervades cues like "Attack The Locksmith".

Twenty tracks follow in 30 minutes which means it all flies by far too fast as well. When you’re skipping between brushed cymbals in a lounge jazz environment ("Jane & Collins"), sprightly string ensemble providing a waltzing piece of faux period background ("Belle"), then back to the general bucket and spade throw together of styles ("Movers") – it’s what I’d call a jumble. The director is certainly taken by the results from his enthusiastic booklet spiel – just a shame he didn’t think to give us a précis of the story so we’d understand why it jumps about all over the place.

Reviewer

Paul Tonks

---

 

Marco BELTRAMI
The Crow: Salvation
Enhanced Score Disc KOCH KOC-CD-8075 [51:53]
Purchase from:   Amazon USA

This continuation of "The Crow" comic book ('graphic novel' to the fanatics) story has a pleasantly puzzling underscore by Marco Beltrami, a decidedly modernist composer whose work is relatively unaccustomed to my ears. Beltrami, like Elliot Goldenthal, does attention-getting deeds for these types of projects, including metallic clanking, stinger chords, snarling brass, wordless soprano airs, driving rhythms, and other dark traditions where a smattering of melody may serve as the kindest reprieve. There are the bothersome heartbeats most recently heard in "Rules of Engagement," slightly muted to be just slightly noisome. Beltrami, unlike Goldenthal, is not too innovative about these effects, and so much of "The Crow: Salvation" appears to be temp-track offspring. I hear bits of Graeme Revell, who appropriately scored the first two films, and Danny Elfman, and Goldenthal...

Beltrami is praiseworthy in that he brings to these casual references a feel of his own. The music flows almost seamlessly on the album, and it is customarily involving both musically and dramatically. From the ominous 'Main Title' to the incredibly lush finale there is an obvious current pushing the music forward. Action music in particular is difficult to compose as there are only so many dynamics to work with, but Mr. Beltrami laces together ideas into a coherent, cohesive whole while changing the dynamics frequently, keeping the sound fresh and exciting. The result is at least enjoyable. Also of note is the love theme, which follows conventionality very little insofar as I can tell.

I never heard of flutter tonguing woodwinds quite like this during a love theme, and it sounds magical as the string section skips and glides thorough the braided melody. 'Meet Again,' the end credits pop version with generic lyrics by Lauri Crook, is antithetical to the ardent significance Beltrami provides. Jane Jensen's vocal performance, if one can call it that, sounds like a cat climbing glass, and has all the genuineness of a whited sepulcher.

A lack of track numbers make programming the album a chore, and the track times appear solely inside the booklet. The disc's sound is slightly hollow, from what I assume is too much digital compression. As for the CD-ROM bits, they contain web links, a screensaver, and a tiny gallery of pen & ink artwork by "The Crow" creator, James O'Barr. While the enhanced portion is considerably more than most releases provide, I trust a section devoted to the music, rather than to the publicity, is a reasonable expectation for a soundtrack album. No such animal exists here.

Still, "The Crow: Salvation" soundtrack is above average. It prompts a recommendation. It works:

Reviewer

Jeffrey Wheeler

---

Next Page >>>>>

Search the Crotchet database below

All our reviews also appear at

Return To Film Music on the Web

e-mail:  info@musicweb.uk.net