Very nicely recorded, this is a
Goldberg Variations with extras.
This recording originally appeared in 2001 as Céline Frisch’s debut for
Alpha with all its double-CD added bells and whistles but this apparently
didn’t reach any of the MWI reviewers. Frisch has gone on to record widely
as a member of and soloist with the excellent early music ensemble Café
Zimmerman. The re-release ‘Alpha Classics Collection’ has this as volume 4
in its distinctive red livery – vegans please note, the cover illustration
is not of Autumn leaves.
The opening
Aria from Frisch is something of a Marmite version.
You may love its floating qualities, but the Erroll Garner right-hand delay
can be distracting. Spreading chords is an accepted technique for
harpsichord playing, but this vertical de-coupling in a two-part piece is
rather exposed. Frisch’s vertical rhythmic crispness is in fact a strong
feature of most of the variations. She doesn’t go in for mannered stretching
of phrases for expressive effect, keeping a strict pulse from within which
there is just enough elasticity to avoid things becoming mechanical. Tempi
are often swifter than you might expect, with the dancing notes of
Variatio 7 or
Variatio 19 for instance creating a bracing
impression. We’re leafing through the
Goldberg Variations at pace,
but with repeats observed there is time for the mind to accommodate and
assimilate. I wouldn’t say this is a rushed sounding performance, but if you
are used to the more extreme slowness occasionally delivered by some piano
players then the forward flow of even more measured pieces such as
Variatio 13 will feel a little more busy than usual – again with
that right-hand delay occasionally introducing the odd moment of reduced
clarity. This is also a feature in
Variatio 15 that you may or may
not like. I can see what Frisch is aiming at, but personally find the result
a bit tiresome after a while.
That stylistic performance detail aside, this is a very good recording of
the
Goldberg Variations. Frisch doesn’t overly go in for grandeur,
but where the music demands as in the
Variatio 16 Ouverture she
gives us plenty of orchestral richness from her instrument. There is no lack
of contrast and there is a great deal of beauty even given the often swift
tempi. The elegance of
Variatio 21 is gorgeous, and that ‘Black
Pearl’
Variatio 25 is deeply expressed, those spread notes coming
more into their own with that two-part accompaniment to Bach’s awe-inspiring
melody. This can still become a bit much, but having come this far and
become immersed in the performance the thought of metaphorically stopping
the car and turning back wasn’t really a consideration by this stage.
Bach’s
Goldberg Variations has become a staple with pianists, but
there is no shortage of good harpsichord recordings available. Steven Divine
on Chandos is very good (
review), as are
Trevor Pinnock,
Aapo Häkkinen and, if you want an in-depth education on
the work,
Colin Booth. This is to name just a few that are
available and that have come my way and remained memorable
. I’ve heard versions where the vocal parts of the
Quodlibet were sung, but the
14 Canons BWV 1087 are more
often the domain of complete Bach box sets. The string players of Café
Zimmerman show us how much fun and how much expressive music is to be found
here, each canon played without much embellishment but with a palpable sense
of respectful enjoyment. There are indeed also some magical moments, such as
the
sotto voce Canon A 5 on track 12. With added instruments, the
songs integrated by Bach into his
Quodlibet are given unrestrained
and characterfully folksy performances by counter-tenor Dominique Visse. He
is to be heard in more than one part of his remarkable vocal range, so that
he seems to be in a duet with himself during
La Bergamasca.
All in all this wouldn’t be my absolute tip-top choice for the
Goldberg Variations on harpsichord, but with the added value of the
Canons and songs this release does have many attractive qualities.
Céline Frisch is absolutely a top performer and this is a very fine
recording indeed. You will have to decide for yourself if the
Erroll-Garner-effect slow music works or not.
Dominy Clements
