Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Abraham Lincoln Portraits CD 1 Charles Ives (1874-1954)
Lincoln, the Great Commoner (c. 1921) [3:39] Vincent Persichetti(1915-1987)
A Lincoln Address (1973) [13:22] Roy Harris(1898-1979)
Abraham Lincoln Walks at Midnight (1953) [14:10] Ernst Bacon (1898-1990)
Ford’s Theatre: A Few Glimpses of Easter Week, 1865 (1940) [29:43] CD 2 Morton Gould (1913-1996)
Lincoln Legend (1941) [16:36] George Frederick McKay(1899-1970)
To a Liberator (A Lincoln Tribute) (1939) [11:18] Paul Turok (b.1929)
Variations on an American Song: Aspects of Lincoln and Liberty (1963) [9:18] Aaron Copland (1900-1990)
Lincoln Portrait (1942) [14:31]
Barry Scott (narrator: Persichetti
and Copland); Sharon Mabry (mezzo: Harris);
Mary Kathryn Van Osdale (violin: Harris); Anthony LaMarchina (cello: Harris);
Roger Wiesmeyer (piano: Harris); Nashville Symphony Chorus/George
Mabry;
Nashville Symphony/Leonard Slatkin
rec. Laura Turner hall, Schermerhorn Symphony Center, Nashville
1 July 2007 (Gould, Turok, Copland), 6 July 2008 (Ives,
Persichetti, Bacon, McKay), 27 September 2008 (Harris).
Text by Jane Vial Jaffe. DDD NAXOS AMERICAN CLASSICS
8.559373-74 [60:54 + 51:43]
This
set is a tribute, in his bicentennial year, to America’s
sixteenth president. The works have been chosen by Leonard
Slatkin and Naxos and, varied as it is, the set contains
only a small fraction of the musical compositions written
about the Great Emancipator. As the program notes point
out, the eight works here describe Lincoln the man, his
life, his times and perhaps most important, the feelings
evoked by Lincoln in the composers and so many others.
Since the works in the set were written over most of the
first three-quarters of the 20th century, looking
at them in chronological context can perhaps tell us most
about how Lincoln has appeared to his fellow Americans,
both musically and historically.
Ives’ Lincoln,
the Great Commoner was originally written as a song,
either right before or right after World War I. The choral
version is mostly a unison work and quotes fewer folk
tunes than we might expect from Ives, but when it develops
into dense tone clusters, accompanied by some of the
composer’s best orchestration, it becomes an extremely
impressive picture of Lincoln’s idealism. The progression
to the finale is inexorable and it would not be too much
to say that this is the composer’s premier contribution
to the choral repertoire, short as it is.
More
than forty years later we have a work of Paul Turok, a
well-known critic and broadcaster in New York City. He
is also known as a composer and has long been interested
in American history. His variations area based on a folk
tune that was used in Lincoln’s campaign for President
in 1860. It is a very simple tune and can be played solely
on the white notes of the piano. I found Turok’s piece
very enjoyable and an able handling of variation form,
though not especially Lincolnesque. Written yet another
ten years later and very different in intensity is Persichetti’s A
Lincoln Address, which sets the speech Lincoln gave
at his Second Inauguration. This is one of the most moving
works in the set-the music accompanying the words “…and
the war came…” and “…both read the same Bible…” plumbing
great depths of feeling. After a central interlude there
is a very spare accompaniment to “…with malice towards
none…” and a subdued statement of the opening material
before the narrator reiterates the word “Peace”. A wonderful
work that should be better known.
Four
of the eight works in this set date from the years 1939-1942
when the approach of World War II and its coming to America
generated many statements of the nation’s values in this
terrible time. McKay’s To a Liberator was written
in the light of the events of the late thirties and is
a compendium of the feelings evoked in the composer by
Lincoln. The first section is actually entitled Evocation,
and like the beginning of Copland’s work, portrays the
Lincoln of destiny, albeit in a more personal manner. A
wordless chorus is added for the second section which deals
with the common man’s faith in democracy. This is an excellent
variation of the opening material, making it almost sound
like folk or gospel music. The third section, a March,
and the fourth, titled Declaration, continue the
musical and philosophical threads of what has come before.
The Epilogue returns to the opening material, but
very quietly and in a ruminative vein, not at all what
one would expect. I think it safe to say that this is the
most substantial of McKay’s works to appear since Naxos
started recording them.
Throughout
his career Morton Gould moved back and forth between serious
works and more populist ones, almost like an American Arthur
Benjamin. Lincoln Legend definitely lives up to
the seriousness of the times (1941). Gould takes a different
approach towards his subject than McKay, fashioning various
patriotic and folk material associated with the Civil War
into a symphonic poem that while portraying that past conflict
ends with questioning emotions about the conflict to come.
Gould’s always piquant orchestration and sense of construction
use the well-known material to produce a wide range of
emotions - a work that is truly more than the sum of the
parts.
Yet
another approach is taken by Ernst Bacon in Ford’s Theatre:
a Few Glimpses of Easter Week, 1865. This work was
originally incidental music to a play about Lincoln by
Paul Horgan, which Bacon later orchestrated. In its twelve
numbers it covers a very wide range of emotions, from pathos
to cynicism to the final tragedy. It has always been one
of Bacon’s best-known works and is very welcome here as
its last incarnation was a Desto LP from about fifty years
ago that was unlistenable even then. It is a wonderful
introduction to an unjustly neglected composer. Last of
the four 1939-1942pieces
is Copland’s ubiquitous Lincoln Portrait, a work
so well-known as to need no description.
The
Roy Harris work in this set falls into a separate category
from the others for a variety of reasons. It requires a
piano trio accompaniment as opposed an orchestral one and
a vocal soloist rather than a chorus. It was not written
to strengthen the nation’s resolve or meditate on the greatness
of Lincoln as were many of the others. Rather it is an
angry work, asking what Lincoln would have thought of the
continuance of war and prejudice almost a century after
he had died to end such things. What is more, it cannot
be looked at in comparison to the other works in the set
as it can in the context of all the pieces the composer
wrote throughout his career dealing with Lincoln. In style
it is an eerie work, with the ghost of the President walking
back and forth pondering the continuance of evil in the
world. Harris’s use of open chords and a recurring descending
passage for the soloist add both the atmosphere and the
musical momentum. Especially impressive is the setting
of the last paragraph the poem which increases the sense
of lamentation.
Aside
from the fine quality of the music, the most notable feature
of this set is the fine quality of the sound in the new
Laura Turner Hall, the new home of the Nashville Symphony.
The hall has a wonderful acoustic and the Naxos engineers
make the most of it. The orchestra itself mostly lives
up to their new surroundings, although there is some cluttered
playing in the Persichetti and the Gould. The chorus does
well with the difficult Ives piece. As for the instrumental
soloists in the Harris work they definitely understand
Harris, although one could ask for a little more verve
in their playing. The mezzo-soprano Sharon Mabry is excellent
at getting to the drama of text and music, especially in
her wordless singing in the first three minutes of the
Harris work. My one complaint is with the narrator Barry
Scott, who appears in the Persichetti and Copland works.
In the former he is totally convincing, without a shred
of false emotion. But in the Lincoln Portrait he does what
so many others have done: he acts. Copland himself cautioned “against
undue emphasis in the delivery of Lincoln’s words …they
no added ‘emotion’…” As for Leonard Slatkin he not only
delivers forceful leadership of each work, but shows himself
capable of treating each one completely on its own terms.
Since
only the Copland and Ives works are presently available
on CD, this set is a must for collectors of American music,
aside from patriotic associations. The Harris and the Persichetti
works alone make it an essential purchase.
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.