Only one operetta of the four Edward German composed is represented
in full on disc. That sole entry is an old EMI recording of
Merrie
England with William McAlpine and June Bronhill in the 1960s
(CfP 757 6727). The arrival of
Tom Jones is a welcome
addition as it allows a better assessment of German’s quality
of penmanship. Over the last few years CD recordings of German’s
symphonies and theatre incidental music have appeared on
the Dutton and Marco
Polo. A 1966 EMI highlights disc of
Tom Jones (coupled
with
The Beggar’s Opera) was reissued a few years ago
on Classics for Pleasure CfP 759 7227 in a recording by the
largely
forgotten Gilbert Vinter with the Nigel Brooks chorus. Naxos
offer us the full opera.
When
Tom Jones
was staged in 1907 it was greeted with success that equaled that
of
Merrie England premiered five years earlier. The
new opera was believed by many to be German’s operatic masterpiece.
Its success was understandable since the composer deliberately
used a similar format, structure and ballad-style to that he
provided
in
Merrie England.
German was born in deep country (Whitchurch, Salop) and had received
a good grounding in musical education at the Royal Academy of
Music. He provided incidental music for a number of Shakespearian
plays that was much admired. Unusually, he was given a rare opportunity
to discover the secrets of a successful operatic composer when
invited to complete
Emerald Isle, the comic opera Arthur
Sullivan left unfinished when he unexpectedly died. The D’Oyly
Carte establishment had decided that German was the most competent
craftsman in Britain at the time to complete the master’s work
and entrusted him with the task, which he did competently.
Thus
German had an unexpected operatic foundation on which to build
his newly found talents.
In this first full
recording of the complete
Tom Jones we have a fresh and
sprightly reading by David Russell Hulme. Hulme is no stranger
to German, having for many years researched and studied the late
19
th Century operatic tradition where German received
his grounding. From the opening of Act I we can imagine a sun-drenched
Somerset countryside with bustling villagers going about their
business on Squire Western’s estate. German successfully creates
that idyllic country charm of the olde English idiom made popular
in his
Nell Gwyn dances and later recalled by Coates and
Grainger. The second Act is set at the Inn at Upton, … and yes
the small hamlet of Upton in Somerset does exist. The Ranelagh
Gardens setting for Act III may well be related to the palace
gardens at
Wiveliscombe near Taunton.
To my ears, the highlights
of the opera are the Introduction and Act I opening, the “Wisdom
says” trio, the “Barley Mow” sextet, a haunting Barcarolle and
the Morris Dance of Act III.
There is a well-founded
belief in the theatre that too many characters in a show leads
to a complex plot. It may also result in insufficient exposure
of a character to develop the personality sufficient to hold
an
audience’s interest. The characters in this comic opera are many.
Thirty are catalogued in the vocal score, many of whom are individually
listed in this recording. Fortunately in
Tom Jones, many
of these characters are embedded in the chorus and so the difficulties
mentioned above do not occur. With a book fairly close to Fielding’s
original novel, Squire Western, the jovial squire of the village
- sung with purposeful authority by Donald Maxwell - wishes to
see his mischievous and flirtatious daughter, Sophia, engaged
to an insipid Mr Blifil. Sophia has other plans as she is increasingly
enamoured by the advances made by villager Tom Jones, a lad who
is champion of the chase and is seen as a lovable rascal by the
Squire and villagers. Richard Morrison as Tom manages to provide
that carefree charisma needed to attract attention and sings well
with clear diction in “West Country lad”.
Sophia, sung by Marianne
Hellgren Staykov, is charming, especially in the languid and
sleepy “Love makes the Heart”, admirably supported by equally fine singing
by Rachel Harland (Betty) and Elizabeth Menezes (Peggy) in ‘The
Barley Mow’. Betty and Peggy have little input to the plot yet
are vital to the balance of numbers. Honour, Sophia’s maid is
given as large a part as Sophia and sings in many numbers. Heather
Shipp plays the role with the protective innocence that a servant
might have for her mistress. In her two solo numbers, I found
her very responsive to the situation in a cheery rendering of
‘The Green Ribbon”.
The comedy in this
opera is carried by two G&S patter-men, Simon Butteriss (the
servant, Gregory) and Richard Suart (village barber, Ben). Gregory
who regularly has to cart a drunken Squire off to bed delivers
the zaniest of West Country numbers in “Jan Tappin oi niver did
zee”, with its phrase-echoing chorus. Ben, who after an introduction
reminiscent of John Wellington Wells (The Sorcerer), launches
into a patter song ‘A Person of Parts’ that is amusing and well
sung, yet with its off-beat Latin adds nothing to the plot’s development.
Where was the writers’ joke? A laughing trio, “You have a Pretty
Wit” is a jolly, vivacious piece that is engaging because of
its brisk pace.
This
comic opera, with fast-flowing and witty dialogue, is given a
broad West Country setting by its authors Thompson and Courtneidge
with its libretto written phonetically; e.g. ‘Somersetshire’ written
as ‘Zummersetsheer’, to make sure the words are delivered in
the vernacular! In a budget label recording, it would be too
much
to expect the booklet to contain a full libretto, but one expects
too much for words to be heard above a full orchestra. I would
have preferred to pay a little extra for its inclusion (see Editor's
Note below). Amongst the notes is an interesting section where
Hulme mentions the
evolution
of the original production and explains the origination of three
additional numbers provided at the end of CD 2. Amongst them
are
two very appetizing numbers: a romantic song for Sophia, “By
Day and Night” and a catchy trio with skipping rhythm, “Come
away”
(Tom, Sophia, & Honour).
David Russell Hulme
imbues the score with freshness in his spirited reading. The
orchestra plays magnificently in the warm acoustic of the RNCM’s Concert
Hall. I was amused to see that the same name, ‘Donald Maxwell’,
has been copy/pasted as electronic text as artist in all track
numbers yet I don’t think he plays the role of Sophia or Honour
although indicated as such!
German’s two symphonies
can be found on Dutton CDLX7156/7202.
Raymond J Walker
Ian Lace has also listened to this recording
This welcome new release is the first complete recording of Edward
German’s comic opera. It is quite inexplicable why this
jolly, tuneful operetta has remained unrecorded so long. It seems
scandalous that nearly fifty years have passed since German’s
most popular operetta, Merrie England was recorded in 1960
by EMI. This was re-released as a 2 CD set by its offshoot, Classics
for Pleasure in 1996. That venerable recording featured June Bronhill
as Bessie Throckmorton, William McAlpine as Sir Walter Raleigh
and Peter Glossop as The Earl of Essex with Monica Sinclair as
Queen Elizabeth.
A sprinkling of Edward German’s light music has also occasionally
appeared. In 1991 Marco Polo released a CD of music by Edward
German in their British Light Music series (Marco Polo 8.223419)
with the Czecho-Slovak Radio Symphony Orchestra conducted by Adrian
Leaper. It included Sophia’s Waltz Song from Tom Jones
Act III as well as tuneful material from Merrie England,
Nell Gwyn, Henry VIII and Romeo and Juliet.
Another Marco Polo 1994 release, 8.223695
with the RTE Concert Orchestra conducted by Andrew Penny included
German’s music from Richard III and The Seasons.
More recently, John Wilson conducting the BBC Concert Orchestra,
has recorded German’s Symphony No. 1 with the Symphonic
Poem, Hamlet; The Tempter; Romeo and Juliet; and
The Willow Song on Dutton Epoch CDLX7156; and Symphony
No. 2 ‘The Norwich’ with German’s Symphonic
Suite ‘Leeds’ on Dutton Epoch CDLX 7202
Before I go on to discuss this latest release, I have to say that
it really is quite amazing how diffident we English are about
our composers and their music. Leaving aside the case of British
composers of more serious music, English light music has largely
been ignored with notable exceptions since the 1990s of the outputs
of record companies such as Hyperion and Guild.
The operetta is, based on Henry Fielding ‘s greatest work,
Tom
Jones (1749), a meticulously constructed picaresque
novel telling the convoluted and hilarious tale of how Tom,
a foundling, came into a fortune and finds romance with Sophia,
Squire Western’s daughter. For the operetta, Fielding’s
raciness was reined in to protect the sensibilities of Edwardian
audiences. Tom Jones was produced at London’s Apollo
Theatre in 1907 and ran there for 110 performances.
Conductor, David Russell Hulme is clearly passionate about Tom
Jones; he made a strong contribution to the recording’s
booklet, see below. He leads the National Festival Orchestra and
Chorus and his soloists in a wholehearted and sparkling performance
with many keenly observed, animated solos. The orchestra respond
heartily to German’s lovely melodies, so beautifully crafted
and orchestrated. German was the natural successor to Sullivan
- indeed German worked, although not always very harmoniously,
with W.S. Gilbert - and the influence of Sullivan can be heard
at odd moments but German’s own original voice predominates.
Elgar and German were friends and the impact of Elgar on German’s
music sometimes shines through. Take, for instance, Sophia’s
Act II aria, ‘Love maketh the heart a garden fair’
- so redolent of golden Elgarian wistfulness. ‘The Uncrowned
King of Light Music’, Eric Coates was beginning to write
his songs about this time: 1906-1910 - his first published orchestral
piece, his Miniature Suite came in 1911. Coates admired German.
I was reminded vividly of Eric Coates’s style and orchestrations
while listening to Tom’s Act III aria, ‘If love’s
content’.
The Overture sets the mood of overall joyousness and exultation
with its hunt motifs, romance and delightful, memorably tuneful
rustic dances. Act III’s justly famous and delightful opening
‘Morris Dance’, is splendidly, vivaciously played
here, rhythms nicely taut, dynamics strongly contrasted. German
had the happy knack of composing dance music that seemed so appropriate
to the period of the productions, be it the Merrie England
of Tudor times or the 18th century setting of Tom
Jones. There are so many orchestral delights and this review
would become unbearably long if I included them all. Listen, for
instance, to how German’s orchestra comments between the
sung lines of ‘The Green Ribbon’. Listen to how the
violins trip along daintily as the innocent young maid goes to
the fair to seek the green ribbon to tie in her hair and the clarinet's
wittily, sly comments at the young man’s motivations in
offering to buy her the ribbon if she will dance with him - and
other things afterwards, for “she gave him her heart then
and there…”.
Mezzo-soprano, Heather Shipp as Honour, Sophia’s maid, delights
in the wry humour of this Act III song, ‘The Green Ribbon’.
But the real highlight of the show is the lyric soprano voice
of Marianne Hellgren Staykov singing the part of Sophia. Just
listen to her honeyed tones and clarity of diction in her lovely
tender Act I song, ‘Today my spinet’ and secure colatura
agility in that famous Act III waltz song ‘For tonight’
She is partnered by a sturdy-voiced Richard Morrison as Tom Jones,
muscular but yearning for better things in his Act I song “West
Country Lad’. He is ideally matched with Staykov their voices
beautifully blending and entwining in their duets, especially
the enchanting Act I finale song, ‘For aye, my love’.
As Squire Western, Donald Maxwell has a pleasing oaken voice and
he is expressive enough even if his West Country accent is a bit
amiss. German’s operettas are enlivened by their patter
songs. Here a sextet, including Honour and maids and servants
to Squire Western deliver a hilarious ‘The Barley Mow’
with all six becoming ever more inebriated and their West Country
accents are much more convincing. I should add that the extended
10-minute-or-so finales to Acts I and II enchant.
Usually so stingy with their notes, Naxos has provided a 16-page
booklet with this release that includes a biographical note about
Edward German by John Prince, a commentary on Tom Jones by this
production’s conductor, David Russell Hulme and a plot synopsis
including track references. The operetta’s lyrics can be
accessed at www.naxos.com/libretti/660270.htm
Wonderful and too long in being recorded. One of my recordings
of the year. Now, Naxos, Hyperion, Epoch - let’s have some
of Ivor Novello’s and Noel Coward’s productions.
Ian Lace
Note
The libretto is available as a PDF download from the Naxos
website.