REVIEW INDEX
Robert Schumann
Symphonies

Return to Table of Contents

Return to Schumann Resource Page

Symphony 1

Suisse Romande O/Ernest Ansermet	Eloquence 4800078	review
Robert-Schumann-Philharmonie/Frank Beermann	CPO 7775362	review
Vienna PO/Leonard Bernstein	DG 4775167	review
London PO/Sir Adrian Boult	First Hand FHR07	review
London SO/Yondani Butt	Nimbus NI6181	review
	Nimbus NI7099	review
National SO/Piero Coppola	Pristine PASC335	review
Swedish CO/Thomas Dausgaard	BIS SACD1569	review
	BIS BIS2669	review
London SO/Sir John Eliot Gardiner	LSO Live LSO0844	review
SWR SO/Michael Gielen	SWR Music SWR19028CD	review
Berlin PO/Bernard Haitink	Arthaus 101760	review
O des Champs-Elysées/Philippe Herreweghe	Harmonia Mundi HMG508190/1	review
Royal Concertgebouw O/Mariss Jansons	RCO RCO15002	review
Bavarian RSO/Mariss Jansons	BR Klassik 900176	review review
Deutsche Kammerphilharmonie Bremen/Paavo Järvi	Sony RCA 88697 964312	review
	C Major 711908	review
London SO/István Kertész	BBC Legends BBCL42292	review
Phil or New PO/Otto Klemperer	EMI 4043092	review review
Israel PO/Paul Kletzki	Preiser 90730	review
Haydn O Bolzano & Trento/Gustav Kuhn	Col Legno 2CD60021	review
Cleveland O/Erich Leinsdorf	Opus Kura OPK7075	review
Boston SO/Charles Munch	Pristine Audio PASC403	review
	HDTT HDCD125	review
Phil O/Riccardo Muti	EMI 3714972	review
Vienna PO/Riccardo Muti	Newton 8802081	review
Royal PO/Grzegorz Nowak	RPO SP014	review
Detroit SO/Paul Paray	Eloquence 4843318	review
Berlin PO/Sir Simon Rattle	Berlin Phil Recs BPHR140011	review review
Südwestfunk O Baden-Baden/Hans Rosbaud	SWR Music SWR19085CD	review
Gürzenich-O Köln/François-Xavier Roth	Myrios MYR028	review review
Dresden Staatskapelle/Wolfgang Sawallisch	EMI 6090372	review
Netherlands Radio Chamber Phil/Michael Schønwandt	Challenge CC72553	review
Deutsche Radio Philharmonie/Stanislaw Skrowaczewski	Oehms OC707	review
Cleveland O/Georg Szell	Sony 5160272	review
Staatskapelle Dresden/Christian Thielemann	C Major 708504	review
Scottish CO/Robin Ticciati	Linn CKD450	review
San Francisco Symphony/Michael Tilson Thomas	SFS Media SFS0071	review review
Swan O/Kenneth Woods	Avie AV2233	review review
Paris CO/Thomas Zehetmair	ECM 2396	review

Symphony 2

Suisse Romande O/Ernest Ansermet	Eloquence 4800078	review
Robert-Schumann-Philharmonie/Frank Beermann	CPO 7775362	review
Vienna PO/Leonard Bernstein	DG 4775167	review
Boston PO/Leonard Bernstein	West Hill WHRA6048	review
Cappella Aquileia/Marcus Bosch	Coviello COV91621	review
Dresden Fest O/Ivor Bolton	Sony 88985 372122	review review
London PO/Sir Adrian Boult	First Hand FHR07	review
London SO/Yondani Butt	Nimbus NI6181	review
	Nimbus NI7099	review
Munich PO/Sergiu Celibidache	EMI 5568492	review
Swedish CO/Thomas Dausgaard	BIS SACD1519	review
	BIS BIS2669	review
New York PSO/George Enescu	Opus Kura OPK2122/3	review
London SO/Sir John Eliot Gardiner	LSO Live LSO0818	review
O des Champs-Elysées/Philippe Herreweghe	Harmonia Mundi HMA1951848	review
	Harmonia Mundi HMG508190/1	review
Deutsche Kammerphilharmonie Bremen/Paavo Järvi	C Major 711908	review
Phil or New PO/Otto Klemperer	EMI 4043092	review review
Haydn O Bolzano & Trento/Gustav Kuhn	Col Legno 2CD60021	review
Boston SO/Charles Munch	West Hill WHRA6015	review review
	ICA Classics ICAD5052	review
Phil. O/Riccardo Muti	EMI 3714972	review
Vienna PO/Riccardo Muti	Newton 8802081	review
Royal PO/Grzegorz Nowak	RPO SP014	review
Philadelphia O/Eugene Ormandy	Pristine Audio PASC578	review review
O Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia/Sir Antonio Pappano	ICA Classics ICAC5139	review
Detroit SO/Paul Paray	Eloquence 4842318	review
Minneapolis SO/Dimitri Mitropoulos	RCA 19439888252	review
Berlin PO/Sir Simon Rattle	Berlin Phil Recs BPHR140011	review review
Dresden Staatskapelle/Wolfgang Sawallisch	EMI 6090372	review
Netherlands Radio Chamber Phil/Michael Schønwandt	Challenge CC72553	review
Cleveland O/Georg Szell	Sony 5160272	review
Staatskapelle Dresden/Christian Thielemann	C Major 708504	review
Scottish CO/Robin Ticciati	Linn CKD450	review
San Francisco Symphony/Michael Tilson Thomas	SFS Media SFS0071	review review
Symphony Nova Scotia/Georg Tintner	Naxos 8.557235	review
NBC SO/Arturo Toscanini	Guild GHCD2362	review
	Pristine PASC584	review review
London PO/Franz Welser-Most	EMI 5209542	review
Swan O/Kenneth Woods	Avie AV2231	review review

Symphony 3

Robert-Schumann-Philharmonie/Frank Beermann	CPO 7775362	review
Vienna PO/Leonard Bernstein	DG 4775167	review
London PO/Sir Adrian Boult	First Hand FHR07	review
London SO/Yondani Butt	Nimbus NI6163	review
	Nimbus NI7099	review
Munich PO/Sergiu Celibidache	EMI 5556252	review
O Société des Concerts du Conservatoire/Piero Coppola	Pristine PASC335	review
Swedish CO/Thomas Dausgaard	BIS BISSACD1619	review
	BIS BIS2669	review
O Reichsenders Berlin/Max Fiedler	Pristine Audio PASC547	review review
Czech PO/Lawrence Foster	Pentatone PTC5186327	review
London SO/Sir John Eliot Gardiner	LSO Live LSO0844	review
Philharmonia O/Carlo Maria Giulini	Warner 9937392	review
O des Champs-Elysées/Philippe Herreweghe	Harmonia Mundi HMG508190/1	review
Deutsche Kammerphilharmonie Bremen/Paavo Järvi	Sony RCA 88697 964312	review
	C Major 711908	review
Royal PO/Dirk Joeres	Heritage HTGCD272	review
Phil or New PO/Otto Klemperer	EMI 4043092	review review
BBC SO/Otto Klemperer	ICA Classics ICA5145	review
Leipzig Gewandhaus O/Franz Konwitschny	Berlin Classics 0300491BC	review
Bavarian RSO/Rafael Kubelík	Sony SBK48270	review
Cologne RSO/Rafael Kubelík	Orfeo C726143D	review
Haydn O Bolzano & Trento/Gustav Kuhn	Col Legno 2CD60021	review
International SO/René Leibowitz	Chesky CD096	review
Minneapolis SO/Dimitri Mitropoulos	RCA 19439888252	review
Boston SO/Pierre Monteux	West Hill WHRA6022	review review
Phil. O/Riccardo Muti	EMI 3714972	review
Vienna PO/Riccardo Muti	Newton 8802081	review
Royal PO/Grzegorz Nowak	RPO SP014	review
Royal PO/Dirk Oeres	Regis RRC1237	review
Detroit SO/Paul Paray	Eloquence 4842318	review
Berlin PO/Sir Simon Rattle	Berlin Phil Recs BPHR140011	review review
	Euroarts 2060894	review
Dresden Staatskapelle/Wolfgang Sawallisch	EMI 6090372	review
Netherlands Radio Chamber Phil/Michael Schønwandt	Challenge CC72553	review
Stuttgart RSO/Carl Schuricht	Hanssler CD93292	review
Cleveland O/Georg Szell	Sony 5160272	review
London PO/Klaus Tennstedt	EMI 0944332	review
Staatskapelle Dresden/Christian Thielemann	C Major 708504	review
Scottish CO/Robin Ticciati	Linn CKD450	review
San Francisco Symphony/Michael Tilson Thomas	SFS Media SFS0071	review review
NBC SO/Arturo Toscanini	RCA 88985376042	review
	Pristine PASC584	review review
New York Phil/Bruno Walter	Opus Kura OPK2120	review
London PO/Franz Welser-Most	EMI 5209542	review
Swan O/Kenneth Woods	Avie AV2230	review review review

Symphony 4

Bamberg SO/Marc Andreae	Guild GMCD7412	review
Robert-Schumann-Philharmonie/Frank Beermann	CPO 7775362	review
Vienna PO/Leonard Bernstein	DG 4775167	review
London PO/Sir Adrian Boult	Documents 600045	review
	First Hand FHR07	review
NWDR SO/Fritz Busch	Pristine Audio PASC576	review
London SO/Yondani Butt	Nimbus NI6163	review
	Nimbus NI7099	review
Philharmonia O/Guido Cantelli	ICA Classics ICAC5081	review
	ICA Classics ICAC5143	review review
New York PSO/Guido Cantelli	Pristine Audio PASC510	review
Munich PO/Sergiu Celibidache	EMI 5556252	review
Swedish CO/Thomas Dausgaard	BIS BISSACD1619	review
	BIS BIS2669	review
Czech PO/Lawrence Foster	Pentatone PTC5186327	review
Lucerne Fest O/Wilhelm Furtwängler	Tahra FURT1088-89	review review
	Audite 23441	review
Berlin PO/Wilhelm Furtwängler	DG 4837288	review
	Warner 9029523240	review
Vienna PO/Wilhelm Furtwängler	Tahra FURT1099-1100	review
London SO/Sir John Eliot Gardiner	LSO Live LSO0818	review
Royal Opera House O/Reginald Goodall	Pristine Audio PASC581	review review
O des Champs-Elysées/Philippe Herreweghe	Harmonia Mundi HMA1951848	review
	Harmonia Mundi HMG508190/1	review
Deutsche Kammerphilharmonie Bremen/Paavo Järvi	C Major 711908	review
Concertgebouw O/Eugen Jochum	Eloquence 4840600	review
Vienna SO/Herbert von Karajan	Euroarts 2072118	review
Vienna PO/Herbert von Karajan	DG 4310952	review
Koln RSO/Joseph Keilberth	Profil PH18019	review
Phil or New PO/Otto Klemperer	EMI 4043092	review review
Philadelphia O/Otto Klemperer	Pristine Audio PASC467	review
Dresden Staatskapelle/Hans Knappertsbusch	Tahra TAH606-09	review
Vienna PO/Hans Knappertsbusch	IDIS 6655	review
Bavarian RSO/Rafael Kubelík	Sony SBK48270	review
Haydn O Bolzano & Trento/Gustav Kuhn	Col Legno 2CD60021	review
Berlin RSO/Erich Leinsdorf	Arthaus 101153	review
Boston SO/Erich Leinsdorf	ICA Classics ICAD5043	review
Südwestfunk SO Baden-Baden/Erich Leinsdorf	Euroarts 2001338	review
San Francisco SO/Pierre Monteux	Music & Arts CD1192	review
London PO/Charles Munch	Eloquence 4840219	review
New PO/Riccardo Muti	EMI 3714972	review
Vienna PO/Riccardo Muti	Newton 8802081	review
Royal PO/Grzegorz Nowak	RPO SP014	review
O Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia/Sir Antonio Pappano	ICA Classics ICAC5139	review
Detroit SO/Paul Paray	Eloquence 4842318	review
Berlin PO/Sir Simon Rattle	Berlin Phil Recs BPHR140011	review review
Südwestfunk O Baden-Baden/Hans Rosbaud	SWR Music SWR19085CD	review
Gürzenich-O Köln/François-Xavier Roth	Myrios MYR028	review review
BBC PO/Kurt Sanderling	ICA Classics ICAD5042	review
Dresden Staatskapelle/Wolfgang Sawallisch	EMI 6090372	review
Netherlands Radio Chamber Phil/Michael Schønwandt	Challenge CC72553	review
Staatskapelle Dresden/Giuseppe Sinopoli	Profil PH0753	review
Deutsche Radio Philharmonie/Stanislaw Skrowaczewski	Oehms OC707	review
Cleveland O/Georg Szell	Sony 5160272	review
	Somm 5011-12	review review
Berlin PO/Klaus Tennstedt	EMI 0944332	review
Staatskapelle Dresden/Christian Thielemann	C Major 708504	review
Scottish CO/Robin Ticciati	Linn CKD450	review
San Francisco Symphony/Michael Tilson Thomas	SFS Media SFS0071	review review
NBC SO/Bruno Walter	Guild GHCD2362	review
Swan O/Kenneth Woods	Avie AV2232	review review review