CD Reviews

MusicWeb International

Webmaster: Len Mullenger

Reviewers: Tony Augarde, Steve Arloff, Nick Barnard, Pierre Giroux, James Poore, Glyn Pursglove, George Stacy, Bert Thompson, Sam Webster, Jonathan Woolf

[ Jazz index ] [Nostalgia index]  [ Classical MusicWeb ] [ Gerard Hoffnung ]

AmazonUK   AmazonUS

Eyal Vilner Big Band


PRIVATE [20:08]





Maoz Tzur


Oh Hanukkah!

Mi Yemalel

Eyal Vilner (conductor, arranger, alto sax, clarinet, shofar); Bryan Davis (trumpet, shofar); Andy Gravish (trumpet); Wayne Tucker (trumpet); Jim Seeley (trumpet, shofar); Stuart Mack (trumpet); Itai Kriss (flute, track 3); Jay Rattman (alto sax, clarinet, flute); Bill Todd (alto sax, clarinet, flute); Evan Arntzen (tenor sax, clarinet); Dan Pearson (tenor sax, clarinet, flute); Eden Bareket (baritone sax, bass clarinet); Matt Musselman (trombone); Becca Patterson (trombone); Max Seigel (bass trombone); Jack Glottman (piano); George DeLancey (bass); Eran Fink (drums); Tamar Kern, Martina DaSilva, Vanessa Perea (vocals, track 4)

Recorded November 2016 live at Museum at Eldridge Street, NYC


Bandleader Eyal Vilner, Israeli-born but now a NYC resident, has arranged an EP sized disc (20 minutes only) of pieces based on traditional Jewish holiday songs. The result is a five-track album, though the opening track is a very brief prelude, that cleaves to the time-honoured verities of the swing band era.

That 90-second Prelude offers a brassy chorale more redolent, perhaps, of Salvation Army bands at Christmas – that’s the effect it had on me, at any rate. Once beyond that, Maoz Tzur picks up the theme and swings it in a way familiar from bands of the 1930s and 40s, courtesy of the spick and span, instrumentally excellent aggregation at his disposal. Vilner takes a sprightly alto solo, and there’s neat pianism from Jack Glottman whose bass pointing à la Basie shows good stylistic lineage. Itai Kriss’ flute leads, pirouetting fruitfully over Erán Fink’s percussion in the next track, Sevivon, that perhaps along the way evokes Sing Sing Sing procedurally speaking. The Jewish strain in Big Band jazz, as much as the ‘Spanish tinge’ in jazz noted by Jelly Roll Morton, is a vibrant component and the alchemical procedure by which Eastern European stage music infiltrated American popular music is something that can be seen reflected in arrangements such as this.

In Oh Hanukkah! a trio of vocalists deliberately summon up the shade of the Andrews Sisters, supported by a tenor solo from Evan Arntzen. The final offering is Mi Yemalel in which the most obviously Jewish elements are present, notably in the use of the shofar and the baleful menacing trumpet over percussion and pedal note. Some of the orchestration’s pastel elements are very reminiscent of Gil Evans but the first part of this 7-minute piece offers the most concentrated example of the Jewish elements Vilner is attempting to evoke; the second part of Mi Yemalel offers instead straight-ahead swing.

This is something of a conundrum as the disc is very short measure, there are no notes and there are some potentially contradictory musical aspirations at work. Don’t expect a consistent ‘Jewish tinge’ or you’ll be disappointed, perhaps, to encounter largely Basie-Goodman era music-making and some retro Andrews Sisters close harmony. I happen to like all of that.

Jonathan Woolf


Return to Index