CD Reviews

MusicWeb International

Webmaster: Len Mullenger

Reviewers: Tony Augarde, Steve Arloff, Nick Barnard, Pierre Giroux, James Poore, Glyn Pursglove, George Stacy, Bert Thompson, Sam Webster, Jonathan Woolf

[ Jazz index ] [Nostalgia index]  [ Classical MusicWeb ] [ Gerard Hoffnung ]

AmazonUK   AmazonUS


On Tour! Germany 1973 & 1974

Merry Makers Record Company MMRC-CD-55



1. Murphy Interview

2. Panama

3. 50 Miles of Elbow Room

4. Introduction of band members

5. Saint Louis Blues

6. The Blues My Naughty Sweetie Gave to Me

7. Doctor Jazz

8. Evolution Mama

9. Trouble in Mind

10. Bay City

11. When the Saints Go Marching In

12. Murphy Interview

13. I Am Pecan Pete

14. Sugarfoot Stomp

15. Perdido Street Blues

16. Aunt Hagar’s Blues

17. Bull Trombone

18. Nobody Knows You When You’re Down and Out

19. Helm Interview

20. Come Back, Sweet Papa

21. London Blues

22. When You’re Smiling

23. When the Saints Go Marching In

24. Radio Sign off.

Turk Murphy – Trombone, leader, vocals (tracks 3, 5, 8, 9, 11, 23)

Leon Oakley – Cornet, vocals (tracks 7, 16)

Bob Helm – Clarinet & soprano sax, vocals (tracks 3, 5, 7, 8, 11, 23)

Pete Clute – Piano

Bill Carroll – Tuba & trombone (track 17)

Carl Lunsford – Banjo, vocals (track 6)

Jimmie Stanislaus – vocals (tracks 18, 22, 23)

Recorded at several concerts and from radio shows in Germany, various dates and places in 1973 and 1974. Details are given in liner notes.

The performances on this CD were taken from recordings made at several concerts during the band’s tour of Germany in the early seventies and from radio broadcasts there. The personnel of the band at this time was one of the best that Murphy assembled, and this tour was designed to be the first of four; but for unknown reasons Murphy decided it would be the first and last. Such decision was not made, according to Oakley, on the basis of the reception the band got—it was outstanding. To this day the abandonment remains a mystery.

Some five tracks are given to speaking and contain no music. For the radio segments, a certain PFC Craig Miller interviews some of the band members for his radio show, giving it his best shot but betraying an almost total lack of familiarity with the music. Murphy is asked to differentiate between “traditional jazz” and “dixieland jazz,” for instance, (in a nutshell Murphy points to trad. as being oriented toward the ensemble, dixieland toward the individual musicians); and Helm to elucidate any changes between the instruments of “yesterday” and “today” (and he replies, “Not too many that we use in this band”). So there isn’t a whole lot to be gained from these verbal tracks.

The music, however, is a different story. It is rich, full bodied, Oakley playing as if on fire and seeming to inspire the rest to do likewise, Doctor Jazz (track 7) exemplifying this perfectly—such energy! Oakley’s lip is sure (there are advantages to being in one’s early thirties!) and he has perfect control, flubbing no notes, providing the ideal backing to vocals and soloists. His vibrato is so fitting of anything he does. His vocals, too, are on the mark, as are those taken by Helm and Murphy. On these recordings Helm shows no trace of the “sour” tone (a certain flatness) he so often had on the Yerba Buena Jazz Band recordings, especially when he plays soprano sax. Murphy, as he did until the end of his life, plays a blustery trombone and demonstrates an amazing tonguing technique, especially on numbers such as I Am Pecan Pete (track 13), Murphy’s own composition, which charges at “take-no-prisoners” tempo.

The back line does not enjoy the best of acoustics and is, for the most part, barely heard except for the odd solos, such as Clute’s onLondon Blues (track 21) or Lunsford’s and Carroll’s on Saint Louis Blues (track 5). And that leads to the one flaw in this recording—there are so many locations and probably most had less than top-the-line recording equipment, the result being a lack of balance on occasion or a kind of “muddiness” to the overall sound.

But these are minor cavils. This disc more than makes up for any shortcomings by the sheer exuberance, the fire, the joy of the playing. It is very fortunate that Leon Oakley made the tapes available and Ted Shafer had them transcribed, then issued this CD.

Merry Makers records are available at several on-line outlets, such as cdUniverse and Amazon, and from City Hall Records, 101 Glacier Point, Suite C, San Rafael, CA 94901, tel. 415-457-9080.

Bert Thompson




Return to Index