CD Reviews

MusicWeb International

Webmaster: Len Mullenger

[ Jazz index ] [Nostalgia index]  [ Classical MusicWeb ] [ Gerard Hoffnung ]

Reviewers: Tony Augarde [Editor], Steve Arloff, Nick Barnard, Pierre Giroux, Don Mather, James Poore, Glyn Pursglove, George Stacy, Bert Thompson, Sam Webster, Jonathan Woolf


Buy through MusicWeb
for £9 postage paid World-wide.


The Music Maker -
A Centenary Tribute -
His 50 Finest




CD1 (1936-1941)

1 Spreadin’ Knowledge Around

2 I’m Coming, Virginia

3 Peckin’

4 Just A Mood

5 Sugarfoot Stomp

6 Jubilee (With Helen Humes)

7 Life Goes To A Party

8 Texas Chatter

9 One O’clock Jump

10 Out Of Nowhere

11 Big John’s Special

12 I’m In The Mood For Swing

13 They Say (With Billie Holiday)

14 Boo-Woo

15 Woo-Woo

16 Ciribiribin

17 Two O’clock Jump

18 I’ve Found A New Baby

19 Feet Draggin’ Blues

20 All Or Nothing At All (With Frank Sinatra)

21 Sleepy Time Gal

22 Flash

23 Concerto For Trumpet

24 Back Beat Boogie

25 The Flight Of The Bumble Bee

26 I’ll Get By (With Dick Haymes)

CD2 (1942-1962)

1 You Made Me Love You

2 Yes, Indeed! (With Dick Haymes)

3 I Don’t Want To Walk Without You (With Helen Forrest)

4 Strictly Instrumental

5 By The Sleepy Lagoon

6 Trumpet Blues And Cantabile

7 Easter Parade

8 Crazy Rhythm

9 Cherry

10 I Had The Craziest Dream (With Helen Forrest)

11 I’ve Heard That Song Before (With Helen Forrest)

12 I’m Beginning To See The Light (With Kitty Kallen)

13 I’m Confessin’

14 It’s Been A Long, Long Time (With Kitty Kallen)

15 I Can’t Begin To Tell You (With Betty Grable)

16 Cotton Tail

17 Tuxedo Junction

18 Would I Love You, Love You, Love You? (With Doris Day)

19 You’ll Never Know (With Rosemary Clooney)

20 Lush Life

21 Ring For Porter

22 Harry, Not Jesse

23 My Inspiration

24 Weather Bird Rag

Harry James (trumpet) with The Dean and his Kids; Teddy Wilson and his Orchestra; Benny Goodman and his orchestra; Harry James and his orchestra; Lionel Hampton and his orchestra; Harry James and his Boogie Woogie Trio; Harry James and his sextet; Harry James and his Octet and Septet

[79:25 + 79:51]

There’s certainly no shortage of Harry James out there and there never has been. This twofer, however, is released to acknowledge the centenary of his birth on 15 March 1916 and the compilation traces him from his youthful debut as a 20-year old to two tracks made in a July 1962 session. He was to die of cancer over twenty years later, in July 1983.

He emerged on the musical shore like Venus on her shell, fully formed. His bristling brio can be savoured as he leads The Dean and his Kids – a band including such outstanding players as Irving Fazola, Dave Matthews, Freddie Slack, and Ben Pollack (The Dean) anchoring them – in Spreadin’ Knowledge Around. The first disc, indeed, is a parade ground of elite colleagues and outstanding music making. He was soon recording with Teddy Wilson (and Billie Holiday – They Say is here) and obviously with Goodman and established his own orchestra soon after. By 1937 he was making sides with a contingent from Basie’s band including Buck Clayton, Herschel Evans, Walter Page and Jo Jones – they were members of James’ Orchestra for recording purposes, but it’s an amazing tribute to his cachet that at 21 he could stand shoulder to shoulder with them. His solo on One O’Clock Jump is an outstanding example of virtuosity, range, and power.

The two Boogie sides Boo-Woo and Woo-Woo with Pete Johnson on one side of the record and Albert Ammons on the other launched a thousand replicas but he was also a master of legato, his deep rich tone infusing many a song – and with that on-the-cusp eruptive feeling that so often flared up into the realism of bravura showmanship. He also had a blowsy, almost ironic approach at times, with an admixture of klezmer chutzpah – I always think that one eyebrow is arched in his solo on You Made Me Love You from 1941 – but he and his band provided diligent support to the steady stream of vocalists that he worked with; Dick Haymes, Helen Forrest, Kitty Kallen, Betty Grable, Rosemary Clooney, Doris Day and indeed Sinatra among them. They are all represented here, and rightly so.

There are some pleasing oddities along the way. Jack Matthias arranged Eric Coates’ By The Sleepy Lagoon for example, and James couldn’t escape either the Jazzin’ the Classics vogue – Rimsky’s pesky Bee – or Concerto-itis in Concerto for Trumpet, his own brilliant self-examination of technique and stamina. Some slush is inevitable but set against that there can be found wonderful nuggets such as Willie Smith’s alto solos with James’s 1947 small groups. Stereo was perfect for James and its spatial effects can be heard in the last 1962 session in which he goes back to basics, delivering a fine salute to King Oliver and Louis Armstrong on Weather Bird Rag in Matty Matlcok’s arrangement. The album from which it derives perhaps carries with it echoes of Louis’ own Musical Autobiography LPs of a few years earlier.

Digby Fairweather’s customarily scrupulous and insightful notes complement this fine and well transferred salute in excellent fashion.

Jonathan Woolf

Gerard Hoffnung CDs

Advertising on

Donate and get a free CD

New Releases

Naxos Classical


Musicweb sells the following labels
Acte Préalable
Cameo Classics
Northern Flowers
Toccata Classics

Follow us on Twitter

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing

Sample: See what you will get

Return to Index

You can purchase CDs, tickets and musician's accessories and Save around 22% with these retailers: