CD Reviews

MusicWeb International

Webmaster: Len Mullenger

[ Jazz index ] [Nostalgia index]  [ Classical MusicWeb ] [ Gerard Hoffnung ]

Reviewers: Tony Augarde [Editor], Steve Arloff, Nick Barnard, Pierre Giroux, Don Mather, James Poore, Glyn Pursglove, George Stacy, Bert Thompson, Sam Webster, Jonathan Woolf

AmazonUK   AmazonUS


Four Classic Albums

Avid AMSC 1161




A Tribute To Clifford Brown
1. Joy Spring
2. Where It Is
3. Sandu
4. Once In A While
5. Jordu
6. It Could Happen To You
7. Easy To Love
8. A Message From Boysie

Lem Winchester – Vibes

Ramsey Lewis – Piano

Eldee Young – Bass

Isaac “Redd” Holt – Drums

Winchester Special

9. Down Fuzz
10. If I Were A Bell
11. Will You Still Be Mine?
12. Mysticism
13. How Are Things In Glocca Morra?
14. The Dude

Lem Winchester – Vibes

Benny Golson – Tenor sax (tracks 9-13)

Tommy Flanagan – Piano

Wendell Marshall – Bass

Art Taylor - Drums


Lem’s Beat
1. Eddy’s Dilemma
2. Lem And Aid
3. Friendly Persuasion
4. Your Last Chance
5. Lady Day
6. Just Friends

Lem Winchester – Vibes

Curtis Peagler - alto sax

Oliver Nelson – Tenor sax

Roy Johnson - Piano (tracks 1, 4)

Billy Brown - Piano (track 5)

Wendell Marshall - Bass

Art Taylor - Drums

Another Opus
7. Another Opus
8. Blues Prayer
9. The Meetin’
10. Like Someone In Love
11. Both Barrels

Lem Winchester – Vibes

Frank Wess – Flute

Hank Jones – Piano

Eddie Jones – Bass

Gus Johnson – Drums

Lem Winchester’s career is basically a sad and surprising story. The vibes-player’s first album was privately recorded in 1957 but someone sent a copy of it to Leonard Feather. Leonard invited Lem Winchester to appear at the 1958 Newport Jazz Festival, where Lem’s success persuaded record companies to sign him up for more discs. And that success eventually convinced Lem to give up his career as a police officer and go professional full-time as a musician. He swiftly recorded about a dozen albums but he was killed on 13 January 1961 while performing a trick with a handgun.

Lem Winchester was highly lauded after his appearance at Newport but these four albums make me wonder if the praise was entirely justified. Lem’s technique on vibes might be compared to that of Milt Jackson but he is nowhere near as fluent as Milt. On several tracks he sounds uncertain and he often plays wrong notes or pauses worryingly as if he doesn’t know what to do next.

The first LP in this compilation of four, A Tribute To Clifford Brown, is a homage to a close friend of Lem’s from his high school days. Unfortunately in Clifford’s Joy Spring, Lem fluffs a few notes while stating the theme - a bad start. The same thing happens in Jordu. In Sandu he uses a repetitive single-note technique which reappears later in this double album. Easy To Love also contains uncertainties. The accompanying Ramsey Lewis Trio holds the session together.

Winchester Special from 1959 features tenorist Benny Golson and pianist Tommy Flanagan. Lem seems more relaxed on this session and hence seems to make fewer mistakes than before. Golson and Flanagan contribute excellent solos. Lem is in danger of getting lost in the up-tempo Will You Still Be Mine? But the track gives drummer Art Taylor the chance for some flamboyant fours.

For Lem’s Beat, an LP from April 1960, Oliver Nelson not only played tenor sax but wrote all the arrangements, which gives the session some extra class. Nelson also composed three of the tunes. In the first of these, Eddy’s Dilemma, Winchester plays almost a whole chorus on one note. This may have been deliberate, as he gradually brings in other notes as harmony, but it sounds amateurish. The Oliver Nelson touch is particularly noticeable in the subtle arrangement of Dimitri Tiomkin’s theme song from the film Friendly Persuasion. Lem’s solo is quite delicate and he is only soloist on the track. However, in Just Friends he seems to falter in the theme statement. Pianists are only credited as playing on tracks 1, 4 and 5, so who is the pianist on tracks 2 and 3?

Another Opus is from June 1960, and this one rings the changes neatly by importing flautist Frank Wess, whose skilful playing makes a nice contrast with the vibes – and with Hank Jones’ dependable piano. Lem wrote three of the tunes here, to which are added Oliver Nelson’s The Meetin’ and the jazz standard Like Someone In Love. The title-track is an easy-going blues, where Winchester sounds more confident than elsewhere. Blues Prayer is a very slow blues which seems to hark back to Lem’s liking for the same note repeated almost to exhaustion. The Meetin’ shows up some of Lem’s weaknesses again, with pauses which seem out-of-context. I think this was Lem Winchester’s penultimate album. Given the tragic events which were to take place only a few months later, the title of the last tune is unfortunate but Lem copes well with the fast tempo.

Listening to the playback of a track from Lem’s Beat, Winchester said “This is the best session I have made so far…I feel that I am finally in the first stages of joining the professionals”. I regret to say it but Leonard Feather’s invitation to Winchester to appear at Newport encouraged Lem to try running before he could walk. He was not such a hugely talented artist as many critics seemed to believe, but someone who was still making the difficult transition from amateur status. Despite its drawbacks, this double album is a good way of getting nearly half of Lem Winchester’s recorded output in one handy place.

Tony Augarde

Error processing SSI file

Return to Index

You can purchase CDs, tickets and musician's accessories and Save around 22% with these retailers: