CD Reviews

MusicWeb International

Webmaster: Len Mullenger

[ Jazz index ] [Nostalgia index]  [ Classical MusicWeb ] [ Gerard Hoffnung ]


Reviewers: Tony Augarde [Editor], Steve Arloff, Nick Barnard, Pierre Giroux, Don Mather, James Poore, Glyn Pursglove, George Stacy, Bert Thompson, Sam Webster, Jonathan Woolf



BUY NOW
AmazonUK   AmazonUS

GEORGE MELLY

Sings Doom

EL Records ACMEM 273 CD

 

 

1. Frankie And Johnny

2. I'm Down In The Dumps

3. Muddy Water

4. Miss Jenny's Ball

5. Organ Grinder

6. You've Got The Right Key But The Wrong Hole

7. Kingdom Coming

8. I'm A Ding Dong Daddy

9. Waiting For A Train

10. Railroadin' Man

11. My Canary Has Circles Under His Eyes

12. Heebie Jeebies

13. Send Me To The 'lectric Chair

14. Cemetery Blues

15. Blue Spirit Blues

16. Death Letter

17. Black Bottom

18. Magnolia

19. Michigan Water Blues

20. Ma Rainey's Black Bottom

21. St. Louis Blues

22. Spider Crawl

23. Abdul Abulbul Amir

24. Get Away, Old Man, Get Away

25. Granny's Old Armchair

26. Donald The Dub

27. Television interview concerning the popularity of jazz

Collective personnel

George Melly – Vocals

Alex Welsh, Mick Mulligan – Trumpet

Roy Crimmins, Frank Parr – Trombone

Ian Christie – Clarinet

“Poggie” Pogson – Tin whistle

Fred Hunt, Ronald Duff – Piano

Nevil Skrimshire, Nigel Sinclair – Guitar

Frank Thompson, Terry Forster, Alan Duddington – Bass

Pete Appleby - Drums

This is an anthology of singles and tracks from EPs recorded by George Melly between 1956 and 1959. The EPs includeGeorge Melly with Mick Mulligan’s Band, George Melly Sings “Doom”, George Melly Sings the Blues, and Abdul Abulbul Amir – George Melly Sings Songs of Frank Crumit.

Melly might be called a Renaissance man, given his interest in art (especially surrealism) and writing (author of several autobiographies as well as other books, besides working as a film and TV critic). But his public image was of a hard-drinking, garishly-dressed singer known as Good Time George. The tracks here give a sketch of his vocals before he retired temporarily from singing in the 1960s – a career which he resumed in the 1970s.

Melly’s idol was blues singer Bessie Smith, and you can hear some of her inflections in his vocals, although his voice sounds much younger – rather less mature - than it did in his later years. The blues dominate his repertoire, particularly given George’s obvious liking for the genre’s double entendres (e.g. You’ve Got The Right Key But The Wrong Hole) and the gloomier aspect of the blues (note the album title). As Melly says in his sleeve-notes “The two main subjects with which the blues are concerned are sex and death”.

Melly sings with patent, infectious enthusiasm, even if he is not the world’s greatest vocalist. And he is accompanied by equally enthusiastic musicians, including such top instrumentalists as clarinettist Ian Christie (listen to his fine solo on You’ve Got The Right Key) and pianist Ronnie Duff (contributing characterful solos to such tunes as Muddy Water). George is accompanied on many tracks by the Mick Mulligan Band, with which he sang for some years, mainly in the 1950s. Mulligan’s imperious trumpet comes through well on tracks like Organ Grinder and Cemetery Blues. Mulligan’s trombonist, Frank Parr, is heard soloing and commenting behind Melly’s vocal in Send Me To The ‘lectric Chair.

The album ends with four songs written or adapted by Frank Crumit, a singer who specialised in novelty songs which were often humorous or whimsical. Crumit is barely remembered today, although I listened to some of his recordings on 78 rpm records in my formative years. It is typical of George Melly that he respected the memory of an entertainer like Crumit who has been neglected. These songs are followed by a short 1959 interview in which Melly talks about jazz, musicians and his success as a singer. The interviewer asks such strange questions as “What is the difference between jazz and scat singing and pop singing?”

Tony Augarde
www.augardeBooks.co.uk

Error processing SSI file


Return to Index


You can purchase CDs, tickets and musician's accessories and Save around 22% with these retailers: