CD Reviews

MusicWeb International

Webmaster: Len Mullenger

[ Jazz index ] [Nostalgia index]  [ Classical MusicWeb ] [ Gerard Hoffnung ]


Reviewers: Tony Augarde [Editor], Steve Arloff, Nick Barnard, Pierre Giroux, Don Mather, James Poore, Glyn Pursglove, George Stacy, Bert Thompson, Sam Webster, Jonathan Woolf



BUY NOW
AmazonUK   AmazonUS

DVD REVIEW

ARETHA FRANKLIN

The Legendary Concertgebouw Concert
Amsterdam 1968

Red Bullet J 43324

 

 

1. Arrival At The Concertgebouw + Interview

2. Satisfaction

3. Don’t Let Me Lose This Dream

4. Soul Serenade

5. Groovin’

6. A Natural Woman

7. Come Back Baby

8. Dr. Feelgood

9. Since You’ve Been Gone (Sweet, Sweet Baby)

10. Good To Me As I Am To You

11. I Never Loved A Man (The Way I Love You)

12. Chain of Fools

13. Respect

Aretha Franklin – Vocals, piano

Jerry Weaver – Guitar

Miller Brisker, Donald “Buck” Waldon – Tenor sax

David Squire – Baritone sax

Donald Townes – Conductor, trumpet

Russell Conway, Ron Jackson, “Little” John Wilson – Trumpet

Rene Pitts – Trombone

Gary Illingworth – Piano

Rodderick Hicks – Bass

George Davidson – Drums

Carolyn Franklin, Wyline Ivey, Charnessa Jones – Background vocals

Aretha Franklin is generally considered to be a soul singer, so why am I reviewing this DVD under “Jazz”? I chose to review this DVD because I remember Aretha’s early recordings, when she was definitely a jazz singer. There was an LP entitled Yeah!!!, recorded in 1965 before she moved to the Atlantic label and became a soul singer. It caught her at the piano accompanied by a small group and showing her jazz credentials. Although I admire most of her later work, I rather wish she had remained more of a jazz vocalist, a role in which she was as supreme as in the soul arena.

So the best parts of this DVD for me are tracks 8 to 10, where she goes to the piano and accompanies herself with her characteristic mixture of gospel and jazz. There’s a gospel feel in every note. In a segment of Dr Feelgood, she slides slowly upwards on one magical note, as though reaching to heaven. Good To Me As I Am To You is a nice slow number which lets us enjoy her incandescent voice.

The rest of the concert is marred by its unruly environment. The audience seems to be totally undisciplined and even walks across the stage while Aretha is singing. Many of the onlookers crowd the front of the stage, jostling against one another and clapping their hands as if they are hip. It is almost complete chaos, yet Aretha manages to ignore it and get on with the performance. She is also interviewed in a crowded dressing-room at the start of the DVD and seems shy as she deals with the usual fatuous questions.

Eventually the audience is persuaded to calm down and the atmosphere becomes more placid, although Aretha still receives a very noisy reception. A Natural Woman is a good example of the singer’s soulful vocals. Her voice is a remarkable instrument: always completely in tune and fed by the passion of her gospel roots. I Never Loved A Man illustrates her ability to improvise: possibly a factor from her jazz leanings. My copy of the DVD jumped after Chain Of Fools but it managed to put itself right for the remainder of the programme.

The DVD is filmed in black-and-white and lasts for only 42 minutes. The camerawork is sometimes shaky and moves too quickly from one shot to another. The backing band is frequently raucous and the trumpets miss notes rather too often. These drawbacks fade into insignificance because of the power of Aretha’s singing, which overcomes all obstacles.

Tony Augarde
www.augardebooks.co.uk

Error processing SSI file


Return to Index


You can purchase CDs, tickets and musician's accessories and Save around 22% with these retailers: