The above list of songs that comprise
this album will stir memories of films from as far back as the 1940s. Three
won Academy Awards: ‘Buttons and Bows’ sung by Bob Hope in his 1948 spoof western,
The Paleface; ‘Mona Lisa’ from the Alan Ladd starring post war Italian-based
melodrama, Captain Carey; and ‘Que Sera, Sera’ sung by Doris Day in the
1956 Hitchcock thriller, The Man Who Knew Too Much. The team of Jay Livingston
and Ray Evans also received a further three Academy Award nominations for: The
Cat and the Canary (song not included in this album); the song ‘Tammy’ sung
by Debbie Reynolds in Tammy and the Bachelor and ‘Almost in Your Arms’
from the Cary Grant and Sophia Loren film, Houseboat.
The album’s booklet is mainly devoted
to Michael Feinstein’s interview with the composing duo in which some fascinating
detail is revealed about how they came to work in Hollywood and about the development
of some of their songs, including how Doris Day was none too keen on recording
‘Que Sera, Sera’, thinking it sounded too much like a children’s song and how
the Christmas song ‘Silver Bells’. might have been called ‘Tinkle Bell’ until
somebody thought of the unfortunate connotations of such a title. They also
reminisce about how producers insisted on pop songs to help sell movies. They
were approached to write songs for When World’s Collide and Vertigo
(they asked the singer if he knew what vertigo meant; he thought it was the
name of a Caribbean island!) They were even asked to write a song for a film
called The Mole People. Some of the lyrics of their film/TV songs are
quite bizarre – listen to those of Bonanza – "We got a right
to pick a little fight, Bonanza. If anyone fights with any one of us, they’ve
got a fight with me".
Jay Livingston and Michael Finestein
sing with enthusiasm and expression, and if they sometimes lack polish their
piano accompaniments have style and imagination. Melissa Manchester is sultry
in ‘Never Let Me Go’, a song distinguished by some sexily expressive guitar
writing.
A Nice souvenir of another remarkable
Hollywood musical duo but it could have been so much better for using the talents
of the original artists.
Ian Lace
3½