Classical Editor: Rob Barnett


Music Webmaster
Len Mullenger: Len@musicweb-international.com


Reviews from other months
TCHAIKOVSKY: Manfred Symphony. LIZST: 'Tasso, Lamento e Trionfo'. Orchestre Nationale de la Redifussion Francaise, Philharmonia Orchestra Constantin Silvestri. Testament SBT 1129 79m ADD Rec: 1957/58.

 


Crotchet


Silvestri's adrenaline surges in the latter parts of this spectacular 'Manfred' are truly unforgettable souvenirs of the power that this underrated conductor managed to draw from his orchestras. Indeed, I would arguably place this Manfred at the top of the recorded pile as regards shattering white heat. One also marvels at the crystal-clear mono recording, almost one of the finest I ever heard emanating from the notorious Salle Wagram. Silvestri's 'Lento lugubre' is deeply eloquent and full of passion whilst the transition to the Allegro is quite simply disarming for its hedonistic and orgiastic intensity.

I always enjoy waiting for the final part of this movement and I must say that Silvestri's incredible tempo creates a cataclysmic wash of sound that make other contenders of the likes of Muti and Maazel pale away into insignificance. The Vivace con spirito is also ethereal in its fairy like intensity and once again, one has to admire the Parisian band for its incredible virtuosity. Silvestri's Andante con moto is quite disarming with melodies and deeply felt Tchaikovskian passions coming to the fore in what must be one of the most intensely gut-wrenching adagios ever committed to the Manfred discography.

Finally all is resolved in the grandest manner possible with an Allegro con fuoco that really breaks the barriers of recorded sound as we are accustomed to it! Silvestri and his Parisian players are veritably on Byron's clifftops, dicing with death all the way but surviving with miraculous escapades of ensemble. Some shoddy ensemble slips are obviously forgiven, but what excitement! It almost makes one feel emotionally drained after listening to such an incredible performance.

The Lizst filler has been described as the greatest performance of a symphonic poem ever committed to disc and I would do no less than agree wholeheartedly with that ambitious statement. The exploitations and adventures of Torquato Tasso come alive with unbridled vintage Philharmonia passion and those final triumphant bars are a veritable tour-de-force of orchestral virtuosity. Testament's crystal-clear remastering and copious notes are just an added embellishment to what must be one of the finest historical reissues of the decade.

Reviewer

Gerald Fenech

Performance:

Sound:

Reviewer

Gerald Fenech

Performance:

Sound:

Return to Index