Classical Editor: Rob Barnett


Music Webmaster
Len Mullenger: Len@musicweb-international.com


Reviews from other months
ALAN HOVHANESS (1911-) Symphony No. 11 All Men Are Brothers (1970) [32:26] *  Armenian Rhapsody No. 1 (1944) [4:54] **  Prayer of Saint Gregory (1946) [4:47] **  Tzaikerk (1945) [10:32] ** * RPO/Alan Hovhaness ** Crystal Chamber Orchestra/Ernest Gold rec * London 6 July 1970; 31 Aug/1 Sept 1975 (composer present) CRYSTAL RECORDS CD801 [53:02]

Price 16.95 US dollars plus 2 US dollars per shipping within USA. Orders from outside the USA please contact Crystal direct for quote. Credit card orders (Visa or MC) are accepted. Crystal Records 28818 NE Hancock Rd Camas, WA 98607 phone 360-834-7022, fax 360-834-9680 email: order@crystalrecords.com

 




Alan Hovhaness's full name is Alan Hovhaness Chakmakjian. The 'Chakmakjian' has been discarded, at least for artistic purposes. The name is Armenian in origin although he was born in Somerville, Massachusetts on 8 March 1911 of Scottish and Armenian parents.

Hovhaness was way ahead of the mystic fashions of the 1960s and 1970s: hippiedom, TM, Indian mysticism (The Beatles visiting Maharishi Mahesh Yogi). The ethnic sound has become very popular these days so it is difficult to know why Hovhaness has not made more progress. You need only look at the rising reputation of Avet Terteryan (ASV and BMG Melodiya), whose regionally accented music is so distinctive, to wonder what has happened.

Hovhaness's Symphony No. 11 is, in the composer's words: 'an attempt to expressive a positive faith in universal cosmic love as the only possible ultimate goal for man and nature. Let all unite on our tiny planet, our floating village, our little space ship as we journey across mysterious endlessness.' As an aspiration who could argue with this? As for the reality we have known to date, well, let that not tarnish the goal. While much of the philosophical message sounds similar to Scriabin's grand visions the music is very different.

The Symphony was premiered in New Orleans conducted by Frederick Fennell on 21 March 1961 then completely rewritten and the new version given its world premiere with Werner Torkanowsky (whose name I always remember for a magical performance of Ned Rorem's Lions) with the New Orleans PO on 31 March 1970.

The first movement has an initial Brahmsian string density (perhaps not aided by the age of the recording?) moving into an interlude of harp passes and bell tolling exoticism. Then not, for the last time, we move into a Vaughan Williamsy soundbed of strings over which the brass cry out in austerity. The second movement is an oriental dance with, again, strange RVW-style sounds and Rózsa-like barbarian music. The folk dances suggested here might easily have come from Somerset! The finale ends all in a hymnal melody in praise of the universe. This melody is grounded by deliciously discordant strokes on the vibraphone. This is alternated with a string anthem with accents again fully worthy of RVW. 'And the voice of the Lord Buddha was heard like the sound of a great gong hung in the skies, saying that though one met a thousand men on his way they would all be one's brothers.' We return to the harp passes and bell tolling exoticism. The brass call across eternity and usher the work to a dignified and impressive close.

Armenian Rhapsody No. 1 is melodic music with a coursing pulse. The flavours of the Middle East are strong and instantly recognisable - sometimes close to Holst's Beni Mora. The twists and turns of the writing ground you firmly in the exotic. All three Armenian Rhapsodies are here to be experienced across three Crystal discs. The Prayer of St Gregory (from his 1944 opera Etchmiadzin) is a quietly sinuous trumpet psalm over a bed of strings - an Oriental extension of the Tallis Fantasia. Occasionally I thought also of the string essays of Gerald Finzi.

Tzaikerk is the second longest essay on the disc and is here delightfully and flutteringly done by Gretel Shanley (flute) with the serene, viola-toned violin of Eudice Shapiro underpinning and partnering the constant flighty activity of the flute. Gradually the flute calms into single held notes while the violin sings out in dignified reflection.

The music is there to discover and enjoy. I recommend this disc.

Reviewer

Rob Barnett

Price 16.95 US dollars plus 2 US dollars per shipping within USA. Orders from outside the USA please contact Crystal direct for quote. Credit card orders (Visa or MC) are accepted. Crystal Records 28818 NE Hancock Rd Camas, WA 98607 phone 360-834-7022, fax 360-834-9680 email: order@crystalrecords.com

web: www.crystalrecords.com

Reviewer

Rob Barnett

Return to Index