Classical Editor: Rob Barnett


Music Webmaster
Len Mullenger: Len@musicweb-international.com


Reviews from previous months
BRIAN, Havergal. The Complete Piano Music. Prelude: John Dowland's Fancy; Double Fugue in E Flat; Four Miniatures; Prelude and Fugue in D minor / major; Three Illuminations, also in a version for speaker with piano. Three songs: The Land of Dreams, The Birds, The Defiled Sanctuary.    Tessa Spong (speaker), Esther King (mezzo), Raymond Clarke (piano) Athene ATH CD12 [DDD] [76' 34"].

 


Crotchet




William Havergal Brian was born in Staffordshire in 1876 and died in 1972. Like Elgar, he had no professional musical training but, unlike Elgar, he was subject to consequent criticism as being an 'amateur'. He left school at 12 and in 1927 completed his massive Gothic Symphony. He composed 32 symphonies , the last 20 in the last twelve years of his life. He wrote five operas, a cello concerto, songs and some piano music.

Many British composers simply could not write for the piano and such include Vaughan Williams, Elgar and Walton. I am not convinced that Brian could either.

The Double Fugue, as the other fugal works, are academically and technically competent but predominantly serious, slow and uneventful. Some pages of the Double Fugue and the D major Fugue contain unplayable stretches of the hand. No pianist or able composer would have written like this. Without copying the example of a previous recording, where two pianists were employed for these passages, Clarke plays the music by arpeggiating the chords.

Of the piano music, apart from the attractive Dowland's Fancy the music is very serious and unremitting; there is no sparkle or cheer, nothing to raise any shouts of encouragement or spontaneous rapturous applause.

I found the Three Illuminations in the version for speaker and piano awkward, patronising and an embarrassment producing a sort of sense of shame. The songs were of no real consequence.

But this is an interesting and important disc. Clarke's playing is, as usual, exemplary and the recording is clear and vibrant.

Reviewer

David Wright

Performances
(Raymond Clarke solos)

Recording

David Wright

Performances

(Raymond Clarke solos)

Recording

See also review by Rob Barnett

Visit
Athene



see compilation of reviews here

Return to Index