Choosing one recording from the more than
2000 reviews we published in the last twelve months is a near
impossible task, yet pick one we must.
In some years,
there is a significant composer anniversary which produces an
outstanding release that makes for a suitable choice. In other
years, the selection is determined by a recording which garners
a significant number of nominations, both in the Recording of
the Year awards, but also throughout the year as a Recording of
the Month or a Recommended tag. This year the final selection
met both those criteria.
Robert
SIMPSON Symphonies 5 & 6 - London SO/Andrew Davis, London
PO/Sir Charles Groves rec. 1973/80 LYRITA SRCD.389
So it came down to a choice between the Simpson and the Ives,
both having collected three nominations - either would have been a
worthy winner. The decision to pick the Simpson was made partly
because it is the centenary of his birth, and because it also gained an "honourable mention" from one of
the reviewers in his ROTY preamble, as well as three Recommended
awards (out of three reviews) throughout the course of the year.
Read the three reviews by clicking on the cover image here,
but a few quotes from those reviews are appropriate: "one of the
most revelatory archive/historical discs of the year" (Nick
Barnard), "the closing pages which are absolutely electrifying
here" (David McDade), "a thrilling, visceral complimentary
experience" (Richard Hanlon).
|