Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
review may be sent to:
76 Lushes Road
Essex IG10 3QB
Ph. 020 8418 0616
Support us financially by purchasing this from
Ludwig van BEETHOVEN (1770-1827) Symphony No.7 in A, Op.92 (1811/12) [40:46]
Die Geschöpfe des Prometheus
(The Creatures of Prometheus), Op.43 (1801) [62:19]
Freiburger Barockorchester/Gottfried von der Goltz (concert master)
rec. February and June 2020, Teldex Studio, Berlin. DDD.
Reviewed as downloaded in 24/96 sound from
eclassical.com. HARMONIA MUNDI HMM 902446.47
[40:46 + 62:19]
There we were thinking that ‘Beethoven Year’ ended in December 2020, when
Harmonia Mundi had been making it clear all along that theirs was a project
to run from 2020 to the bi-centenary of the composer’s death, in 2027; it’s
there to remind us in the logo on the cover of this and the other
recordings in this period-instrument series. The earlier releases in the
series have been directed by more starry names, but here the orchestra’s
leader, Gottfried von der Goltz, as first among equals, sits very well in the
hot seat. I liked the recording of Mozart early symphonies and late
dances which they made together -
review - but they make an even finer job of this more substantial
How appropriate that Beethoven’s ‘apotheosis of the dance’ should be
coupled with his only ballet, the work which first brought us the theme
which he developed in the ‘Eroica’ symphony and the ‘Eroica Variations’.
It’s appropriate, too, that this recording should follow hard on the heels
of my review of the Seventh and Eighth symphonies with the New York
Philharmonic Orchestra and Bruno Walter, which I singled out as one of the
plums of the Sony Complete Bruno Walter Columbia set –
I wouldn’t want to use that classic Walter Seventh as any sort of a
template. The new Harmonia Mundi clearly gains by its availability on CD
and as a download, up to 24-bits, whereas the Sony is a very good transfer
of a 1951 mono LP. The Sony is no great ordeal to listen to, especially for
someone who owned the Philips LP back in the day, but there’s a wealth of
greater detail in the new recording.
That extra inner detail is also down to the use of a smaller ensemble,
playing period instruments. Walter’s NYPO certainly didn’t swamp the music
– they were too sensitively attuned to his conducting for that – but the
Freiburg players bring us something more intimate, yet just as imposing.
Right from the start, this performance makes it clear why Wagner described
this symphony as ‘the apotheosis of the dance’, and set out to prove it to
Liszt. The notes in the booklet remind us that the music has not always
been associated with the dance, but the performance throughout amply
justifies the description. Von der Goltz doesn’t need to rush his partners
to achieve an athletic account of the first movement; no speed merchant,
his basic tempo is actually slightly slower than Walter’s, but you wouldn’t
realise it in practice.
The almost balletic account of the second movement is not rushed, either.
There’s no actual slow movement, and, though this is one of the faster
accounts on record, there’s real feeling for the music without undue
sentimentality. Nor is the scherzo rushed, though there’s plenty
of sense of the music skipping along – and moving us forward with it.
There’s contrast, too, between the presto and assai meno presto sections, whatever Beethoven understood assai to mean. (It’s been suggested that he mistakenly believed it
to mean the same as the French assez.) It’s plain, if it wasn’t
before, how much the Freiburg Baroque players are enjoying this music.
The real test of any performance of the Seventh comes in the finale. It has
to spin along almost like a whirling dervish, but it must not fall over in the
process, or come off the tracks like a train wreck. It mustn’t even sound
as if it might come off the tracks, as Walter’s stereo remake with the
Columbia Orchestra does. With the NYPO, he whistles through in just over
six minutes; watch out on that unmanned crossing!
Von der Goltz gives the road traffic a little more time to clear the
crossing, though the difference is less than the three minutes indicated by
the stopwatch, with the Freiburg players more generous with repeats. What
matters is that there is plenty of energy in this account of the finale
and, with every strand audible, it’s clear that nobody is letting the side
down. I’m pretty sure that I’ve just found my modern Beethoven Seventh of
choice, perhaps even in preference to Carlos Kleiber's Five and Seven with the VPO (DG Originals 4474002, mid-price CD or budget
download), and repeated hearing is not likely to change that. Sir John
Eliot Gardiner, in 2011, with the ORR, is faster in the finale, described
by John Quinn as ‘exciting’ –
– but not necessarily livelier (SDG717, with No.5).
The symphony, contained on the first CD, is not the whole story. The Eighth
makes a good pairing for the Seventh – they arose almost simultaneously –
but so does the much earlier Prometheus. If you really don’t want
the ballet on CD2, you can download CD1 separately for around £5 in
lossless sound, but the coupling of Prometheus, Beethoven’s sole
work in that form, is apt. For a story that ends so tragically, with
Prometheus punished by the gods for bringing fire to humanity, the music is
The Overture is familiar, but we don’t often get the full ballet. Leif
Segerstam and the Turku Philharmonic gave us a decent account of the
complete work in Beethoven year (Naxos 8.573853). If you already have a
Seventh that you like, you could do much worse than lay out £7.50 or so on
that (around £5.50 as a lossless download). Robert Cummings thought the
Naxos ‘a fine performance … with excellent sound’ –
– and I found it enjoyable –
– but my money is now on the new Harmonia Mundi – inevitably, the
smaller-scale ensemble brings us lither performances and sharper tempi. The
new recording is closer to George Petrou's with Armonia Atenea (Decca
4787655). Without the
choreography, the original version of which has not survived, not all the
music will hold your attention, but you won’t find yourself wandering
off-message too much with any of these performances.
The beautifully lilting account of the finale, the theme of which would
obsess Beethoven, amply demonstrates why it bugged him, and rounds off an
hour and three-quarters of delightful listening.
I’ve already indicated how good the recording is, especially in 24-bit guise. The CDs
cost around £19, with lossless downloads around £16 and 24-bit around £22,
but the good news is that the
download from which I reviewed this recording is initially available in
24-bit for the same price as 16-bit ($18.98).
A first-rate Seventh and a persuasive account of Prometheus.