MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2024
60,000 reviews
... and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs
 

Presto Music CD retailer
 
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Some items
to consider

new MWI
Current reviews

old MWI
pre-2023 reviews

paid for
advertisements

Acte Prealable Polish recordings

Forgotten Recordings
Forgotten Recordings
All Forgotten Records Reviews

TROUBADISC
Troubadisc Weinberg- TROCD01450

All Troubadisc reviews


FOGHORN Classics

Alexandra-Quartet
Brahms String Quartets

All Foghorn Reviews


All HDTT reviews


Songs to Harp from
the Old and New World


all Nimbus reviews



all tudor reviews


Follow us on Twitter


Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor
   
Rob Barnett
Editor in Chief
John Quinn
Contributing Editor
Ralph Moore
Webmaster
   David Barker
Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf
MusicWeb Founder
   Len Mullenger


Support us financially by purchasing from

William BYRD (1543–1623)
1588
Psalmes, Sonets & songs of sadnes and pietie
Grace Davidson (soprano)
Martha McLorinan (mezzo)
Nicholas Todd (tenor)
Fretwork
Alamire/David Skinner
rec. All Saints, Holdenby, Northamptonshire, 27–29 August 2020 (vocal consort) & 21–24 September 2020 (viols and solo consort songs).
Texts included
Reviewed as downloaded in 24/96 sound from press preview.
INVENTA INV1006 [78:54 + 78:20]

There have been other partial recordings of this 1588 collection, notably a 65-minute selection from Emma Kirkby and others with the Consort of Musicke and Anthony Rooley (Decca British Music 4750492, Presto CD, or download), but this is the first complete account.

The 1588 collection was Byrd’s first publication after his joint enterprise with Tallis, the Cantiones Sacræ of 1575, and his first solo publication, made with the patronage of Sir Christopher Hatton, a bright star in the Elizabethan firmament. Having recorded the 1575 Cantiones for Obsidian Records with distinction (CD706: Recording of the Month – review March 2011 DL Roundup), it’s apt that David Skinner and Alamire should follow up with this new recording. The change of label, from Obsidian to Inventa, has not meant any diminution in quality. I could just repeat what I wrote back in 2011 and say that the new release ‘sweeps the board’. Job done.

The earlier publication contained Latin settings appropriate to the pre-reformation Roman rite. Both Tallis and Byrd made little secret of their continued adherence to the old faith, and Queen Elizabeth, who favoured the retention of as much as possible of the old ways, including vestments and music, often to the exasperation of her more reform-minded subjects, graciously accepted the dedication of the set, with 17 works by each composer, to mark the years of her reign. It’s possible to assume that much of the music could have been – and perhaps was – sung as the anthem at the end of Mattins and Evensong, as provided in the English Prayer Book. (The rubric ‘In quires and places where they sing here followeth the anthem’ dates only from 1662, but it reflects a practice which had become established long before.)

By 1588, however, the mood had changed, and it was more dangerous to be a known recusant. The papal bull Regnans in excelsis, absolving anyone who murdered the heretic queen, had made every adherent of the old faith a potential terrorist. Though the bull had been issued in 1570, the threat had become more real in the 1580s with the intrigues surrounding Mary Queen of Scots.

In the summer of 1588, the Spanish Armada had come perilously close to invading England and deposing Elizabeth.  Those sympathtic to the old faith had to be more careful: that applied to Byrd and to his patron Hatton.  Though himself believed to be an adherent to the old ways, Hatton was instrumental in bringing to book the Babbington plot against the queen and Mary Queen of Scots’ part in it.

Even before then, both Tallis and Byrd had provided settings of English texts for the new Church of England. Some of these, such as Byrd’s Great Service and Second Service, contain polyphony little different from pre-reformation settings. A good way to explore the Great Service is from The Tallis Scholars Sing William Byrd, a 2-CD-for-one set which also contains his three Masses – paradoxically, because they were composed for private use, in many ways plainer than the English music. (CDGIM208 – review: CDs or download from hyperion-records.co.uk, the download, with pdf booklet, just £7.99.)

But the new religion also required something much simpler for use in small churches, perhaps without an organ, or for domestic performance, in both cases with accompaniment from a viol consort. With a composer such as Tallis, ‘simple’ could be very moving, as in the case of the settings which he contributed in the early years of Elizabeth’s reign to Archbishop Parker’s Psalter. One of these became the basis of Vaughan Williams’ haunting Fantasia on a Theme of Thomas Tallis. A good way into Tallis, both in Latin and in English, is via another Tallis Scholars’ twofer, The Tallis Scholars sing Thomas Tallis (CDGIM203 – review: CDs or download from hyperion-records.co.uk).

As with the Tallis Psalter, simpler settings are far from dull or boring. There’s a great deal of variety in the 1588 collection, and David Skinner and his team duly vary their performing style. The publication’s title suggest a division of the music into various categories, and the recording observes them as follows: CD1 contains five psalm settings, eight ‘sonnets and pastorals’, three ‘songs of sadness and piety’ and concludes with the Funeral Song of Sir Philip Sidney, ‘Come to grief for ever’. CD2 offers five more psalms, eight ‘sonnets and pastorals’, four ‘songs of sadness and piety’, and concludes with another lament for Philip Sidney.

These English settings may look politically ‘safe’ on the face of things, but one piece has received a good deal of attention in recent years. Why do I use my paper, inke and penne? – No.33 in the original collection, CD2, track 14 here – is believed to refer the execution of Father Edmund Campion in 1580 and to the fate of the adherents of the old faith in general. It has been recorded, among others, by I Fagiolini and Concordia (The Caged Byrd: Chandos CHAN0609). The Chandos recording places the work among other pieces inspired by Byrd’s feelings of detachment and anger at the fate of his co-religionists, and includes the pairing of settings of the lament of the Israelites in their Babylonian exile by Byrd and his continental contemporary, Philippe de Monte. Another recording which examines Byrd’s ambiguous place in the reformed England, though without the lament for Campion, comes from the Tallis Scholars: Playing Elizabeth’s Tune (Gimell CDGIM992, CD – review – or GIMPD901, DVD – review).

If you like a bit of inter-varsity rivalry, with David Skinner based at Sidney Sussex, Cambridge, there’s a recording from Magdalen College Oxford and Bill Ives of the Byrd Second Service which also includes Why do I use my paper, inke and penne? and some of the other pieces from the 1588 collection (HMU907440: Recording of the Month – review ; download only). Though I enjoyed it overall, some of the treble singing on this collection is often a little too raw for me.

The realisation of this piece by Nicholas Todd on Inventa is resigned in tone, as if in despair. Perhaps there is a case for making the words sound more angry – the equivalent of imagining Byrd laying on his quill so hard that the paper was spattered with ink – but the effect of this commemoration of ‘the glorious dead’ is very telling. If you want something a little more forceful, Rogers Covey-Crump on the Harmonia Mundi may be a little more to your taste.

I’ve already mentioned the Decca collection with Emma Kirkby, but she also made a recording of Byrd’s Consort Songs, with Fretwork, for Harmonia Mundi (HMU907383 – review, download only). At $16.76, the lossless download from eclassical.com is better value for US$ purchasers than for those paying in GB£, and none of the downloads that I checked comes with the booklet, but this is Emma Kirkby and well worth laying out the hard-earned. I was going to write that her singing is incomparable, but that would forbid comparing it with the new recording.

The Kirkby collection opens with as bright a performance of My mind to me a kingdom is as you are likely to hear, and Fretwork in their 2008 incarnation offer superb accompaniment. They also intersperse the songs with instrumental items. Skinner takes this piece a fraction more slowly and, though Grace Davidson comes very close to matching Kirkby, the effect is slightly more contemplative. I shall not be disposing of the Kirkby/Harmonia Mundi collection, but the new Inventa recording will certainly be supplementing it. The Harmonia Mundi comes in 16-bit only, still sounding very well, even by comparison with my 24-bit review copy of the Inventa.

CD1 of the new recording ends with Come to me grief for ever, the first and better-known of two laments for the death of Sir Philip Sidney, and CD2 with the second, O that most rare breast. I listened first to these two pieces from the Consort of Musick and Rooley on Decca, where they conclude the programme with these twlo laments, in that order. Rooley moves the pace along in both laments, though there is never any sense of undue haste, and the singing is all that we would expect from this distinguished group in the first and counter-tenor John York Skinner in the second.

When first released on Oiseau Lyre Florilegium DSLO596, the Rooley selection received well-deserved high praise, and it remains well worth considering. If you already have it, it’s a keeper. At over £11, however, without booklet, this download-only recording is over-priced. The Presto special CD is better value.  The new Inventa, on which the two laments are sung solo by the clear tones of Martha McLorinan rather than by the ensemble, gives the music a little longer to breathe, and the effect is, if anything, even more effective.

There’s one more Byrd recording that I should mention. On a budget-price Hyperion Helios album of the consort songs, Robin Blaze with Concordia includes even longer-breathed accounts of these two laments, together with Byrd’s lament for the death of his older colleague Thomas Tallis, in 1585, Ye sacred Muses. The splendid performance of the Tallis lament – shorter and simpler than those for Sidney, but no less moving – and the opening Rejoice in the Lord make this an ideal supplement to the new Inventa, and an inexpensive one at that: it was on offer for just £6.50 on CD or as a download from hyperion-records.co.uk when I checked (CDH55429). At full price, this was a highly recommended recording; at budget price, it’s irresistible.

Were I to take you on an excursion around the rival recordings of the Lullaby, sweet little Baby, nigh-ubiquitous on Christmas recordings, we would be here till kingdom come. (What a comment on the sad lack of linguistic awareness nowadays that Word should take exception to my two subjunctives in that sentence.) Suffice it to say that Skinner and his team give this lullaby a moving performance.

I could carry on comparing individual items here with other interpretations. These few spot checks against some other very fine recordings of Byrd have, however, sufficiently confirmed my initial impression that David Skinner and his team can stand comparison with and emerge as complementary to my older favourites. With so much music here that no other recording contains – I haven’t counted, but it must be well over an hour – this has to be the prime recommendation, but not to the exclusion of those other recordings. Some dealers are asking more for the 16-bit lossless download than for the CDs, which sell for the equivalent of mid-price, and much more for 24-bit.  Shop around, however, and Qobuz have the 16-bit for £8.99 and 24-bit for £14.99, both with booklet.

The recorded sound, as heard in 24/96 format, is first-rate, as is the booklet, with its very striking cover. That also comes as part of the deal if you choose to download; scandalously, so many download releases, even when they cost as much as or more than the CD, still come without a booklet. That’s the case of the Decca and Harmonia Mundi recordings that I have mentioned, especially reprehensible when we are bereft of the words. I’m not sure I accept the contention that this 1588 publication was meant to heal the rift between the Reformed and the Roman Catholics, but that’s a very small and arguable point when the booklet is otherwise a valuable part of the deal. Certainly, it's interesting that Byrd set the metrical versions of the psalms, which the more extreme reformers – the opposite end of the religious spectrum of the time – preferred to the poetic prose of the official Prayer Book psalms.

One year after the 1588 publication, Byrd was to throw caution to the winds and produce a second volume of Latin-texted Cantiones sacræ, with a third following in 1591. New College Choir, Oxford, and Edward Higginbottom are reliable guides to selections of these (CRD3420 and 3439, or CRD5003, 3 CDs, all three collections), and other very fine accounts can be found on various recordings by The Cardinall’s Musick, for ASV (download only) and Hyperion (see CDA67779: Recording of the Month - review; DL Roundup February 2010, and CDA67568: Recording of the Month - review), but, with two very fine recordings under their belt, I very much hope that Alamire and David Skinner will turn their attention to them in the near future. Perhaps, too, to the further recordings of the more intimate music that Byrd continued to produce.

Brian Wilson


Contents
CD1 (numbers in original publication in square brackets):
Psalms
1. O God give ear [1]
2. Mine eyes with fervency of sprite [2]
3. My soul oppressed with care and grief [3]
4. O Lord how long wilt thou forget [5]
5. O Lord who in thy sacred tent [6]
Sonnets and pastorals
6. O you that hear this voice [16]
7. Ambitious love [18]
8. Although the heathen poets [21]
9. My mind to me a kingdom Is [14]
10. Farewell false love [25]
11. If women could be fair [17]
12. Who likes to love [13]
13. La Verginella [24]
Songs of sadness and piety
14. Lullaby, my sweet little baby [32]
15. All as a sea [28]
16. Prostrate, O Lord, I lie [27]
Funeral Song of Sir Phillip Sidney
17. Come to me grief forever [34]

CD2:
Psalms
1. Even from the depth [10]
2. Blessed is he that fears the Lord [8]
3. How shall a young man prone to ill [4]
4. Help Lord for wasted are those men [7]
5. Lord in thy wrath reprove me not [9]
Sonnets and pastorals
6. Though Amaryllis dance in green [12]
7. Constant Penelope [23]
8. I joy not in no earthly bliss [11]
9. As I beheld I saw a herdman wild [20]
10. Where fancy fond [15]
11. What pleasure have great princes [19]
12. In fields abroad [22]
13. The match that’s made [26]
Songs of sadness and piety
14. Why do I use my paper, ink and pen? [33]
15. Care for thy soul [31]
16. Susanna fair [29]
17. If that a sinner’s sighs [30]
Funeral Song of Sir Phillip Sidney
18. O that most rare breast [35]

Alamire:
Emma Walshe (soprano)
Helen Charlston (mezzo)
Steven Harrold (tenor)
Nicholas Todd (tenor)
Timothy Scott Whiteley (baritone)
Robert Macdonald (bass)



Advertising on
Musicweb


Donate and keep us afloat

 

New Releases

Naxos Classical
All Naxos reviews

Chandos recordings
All Chandos reviews

Hyperion recordings
All Hyperion reviews

Foghorn recordings
All Foghorn reviews

Troubadisc recordings
All Troubadisc reviews



all Bridge reviews


all cpo reviews

Divine Art recordings
Click to see New Releases
Get 10% off using code musicweb10
All Divine Art reviews


All Eloquence reviews

Lyrita recordings
All Lyrita Reviews

 

Wyastone New Releases
Obtain 10% discount

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing