Georg Philipp TELEMANN (1681-1767) Overture and Concertos for Darmstadt Overture (Suite) in F, TWV 55:F3 [24:06]
Violin Concerto in a minor, TWV 51:a1 [7:16]
Flute Concerto in D, TWV 51:D1 [16:15]
Concerto for Flute and Violin in e minor, TWV 52:e3 [9:24]
Flute Concerto in D, TWV 51:D2 [12:49]
Les Ambassadeurs/Alexis Kossenko (transverse flute)
rec. 3, 4 and 7 September 2014, Temple Saint-Marcel, Paris. DDD.
ALPHA COLLECTION 499
[70:23] Previously released as ALPHA 200.
Released at full price as recently as 2015, this very fine recording returns
as one of the picks of Alpha’s latest, fifth, series of additions to their
mid-price Collection series, selling for around £8.75.
Its original appearance was widely welcomed, not least by David Billinge,
who summed up his response thus: ‘I cannot praise this lovely disc highly
enough both to those who know Telemann and those still in doubt’ –
I see that I was rather niggardly, merely pointing out that purchase of
the album didn’t involve too much duplication –
DL News 2015/3.
At least I did call these ‘stylish and well-paced performances sound[ing]
The music, composed for the Darmstadt court is now housed in the Hessische
Landes- und Hochschulbibliothek. From this varied collection, containing
some of Telemann’s most appealing work, Les Ambassadeurs have made an
attractive collection of Overture and Concertos. The Overture TWV55:F3, a
suite of dance movements, is worthy to stand alongside Bach’s four
better-known works in this style and it’s played with a lilt that ranks
with the best recordings of the Bach. Those who hate the horn - prominent
here - should stay away; others will enjoy.
The rest of the programme features concertos for flute, violin, and the two
together. It’s only fair that director Alexis Kossenko gets the lion’s
share of the solo parts – and how he plays! (I’m not much given to
exclamations, but the whole team deserve one.)
I said that there was not much overlap with other recommendable
collections, but I must list a few for comparison – from which the Alpha
reissue emerges at the very least a worthy equal.
The Flute Concerto in D, TWV51:D1 appears on a recent Naxos collection of
virtuoso baroque concertos, the title Grand Mogul, taken from
Vivaldi’s flute concerto Il gran Mogol. It’s performed by Barthold
Kuijken with the Indiana Baroque Orchestra. I liked that recording –
– though marginally preferring some of the music in other contexts, for
example the Telemann in the CPO series of his wind concertos from La
Stagione. It’s hard not to like the Naxos, but at least equally hard not to
enjoy the Alpha.
The other Flute Concerto, TWV51:D2 receives the Reinhard Goebel treatment from Concerto
Köln, with Wilbert Hazelzet as the nimble soloist. It’s
available as a full-price DG Archiv CD or as a Presto special CD for £9.75
(4767253). With Goebel at the helm, one often gets the feeling that the wheels are
about to come off but, though the tempi are marginally faster than
Kossenko’s, that’s not the case with this concerto; in fact, you may prefer
Hazelzet and Goebel in their sensitive treatment of the third movement, largo. Overall, honours are about even between the two.
I should also mention Simon Standage’s recording of the Violin Concerto,
TWV51:a1, and the 5-movement Concerto for Flute and Violin, TWV52:e3, on
one of the very fine Chandos series of Telemann recordings made by
Collegium Musicum 90 in the 1990s. The other works include the
Overture-Suite La Changeante, TWV55:g2, which forms the title of
this, the first of the Chandos series (CHAN0519, CD, or download in mp3 or
lossless, with pdf booklet, from
chandos.net)1. I marginally prefer the sprightly
performances on Alpha. Standage is more mellifluous than Zefira Valova the
Alpha violin soloist, but there’s very little in it.
It’s possible to prefer one movement from Chandos and another from Alpha,
and there’s much else to enjoy on both recordings.
With very good recorded sound, the Alpha reissue is a winner at the new
price. I’m not sure that the picture of coloured plastic balls floating on
the cover is an improvement on the original painting of monkeys playing (?)
backgammon – perhaps it’s meant to support David Attenborough’s
anti-plastic campaign. I’m pleased that the booklet notes are largely
retained from the original release; they are slightly abridged, but there’s
also a link to the original. That’s an improvement on earlier volumes in
the series which come with quirky booklets.
There’s so much bounty in Telemann’s locker from this collection alone that
you will want to discover more when you have heard this CD. Three different
Overture-Suites from the Darmstadt library feature on a Naxos recording in
performances by Helmut Müller-Brühl and the Cologne Chamber Orchestra on
Naxos 8.554244 (in g minor, TWV55:g4; in C, TWV56:C6, and in D, TWV55:D15).
The programme is less varied than the Alpha and the performances – modern
instruments but period style – a degree less sprightly, but I enjoyed
hearing it. The recording is, if anything, even better than the Alpha. And
it’s even less expensive, at around £7.50, or as little as £4.79 for the
lossless download with pdf booklet.
Comparatively less expensive still is a 2-CD Teldec Das Alte Werk
collection of Darmstadt Overtures from Concentus Musicus Wien and Nikolaus
Harnoncourt (Warner 2564690523: TWV55:a2, 55:C6, 55:D15, 55:d3, 55:f1,
55:g4, around £9.50)2.
Telemann’s music really is worth exploring to the full. Not for nothing did
the Leipzig town council consider him their preferred candidate, though
they did pretty well, as it happened, with Bach. Don’t be surprised if this
very fine Alpha reissue leads you discover more. If your credit card is
maxed out, there’s always the very useful Naxos Music Library streaming
service, where you can find everything that I’ve mentioned in this review.
Then there’s the other Darmstadt music, from the court composer Christoph
Graupner, another prime candidate for the Leipzig post, but that’s another
story. A violin concerto by a later Darmstadt court composer, Johann Kress,
features with Telemann and other composers on a recent Audax recording
Winter 2018-19/2). First and foremost, however, snap up this Alpha reissue of Telemann.
The other works are: Concerto TWV 40:201 in G for 4 violins without basso
continuo, Concerto TWV 54:A1 in A for 4 violins, strings & b.c., and
Violin Concerto in E TWV 51:E2. Annoyingly, the Chandos booklet doesn’t
include the TWV numbers, which have been standard since 1983.
Don’t even think of paying the £50.65 being asked by one dealer.
We are currently
offering in excess of 51,000 reviews
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger