One of the most grown-up review sites around

51,000 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

  Founder: Len Mullenger             Editor in Chief: John Quinn               Contact Seen and Heard here  

Some items
to consider


colourful imaginative harmony
Renate Eggebrecht violin

Leticia Gómez-Tagle
Chopin, Liszt, Scarlatti

Bax Piano Music

Guillaume LEKEU

Book 1 Book 2 Book3
Mota The Triptych: -Website

Acte Prealable returns
with New Releases

Superior performance

Shostakovich 6&7 Nelsons

Verdi Requiem Thielemann

Marianna Henriksson
An outstanding recital

Arnold Bax
Be converted

this terrific disc

John Buckley
one of my major discoveries

François-Xavier Roth
A game-changing Mahler 3


Bryden Thomson


Vaughan Williams Concertos

RVW Orchestral


Support us financially by purchasing this from

Hector BERLIOZ (1803-1869)
Grande Messe des Morts, Op. 5 (1837, rev. 1852 & 1867)
Bror Magnus Tødenes (tenor)
Choir of Collegium Musicum; Edvard Grieg Kor; Bergen Philharmonic Choir
Eikanger-Bjørsvik Musikklag; Bergen Philharmonic Orchestra/Edward Gardner
rec. live, 21-24 May 2018, as part of the Bergen International Festival
Reviewed as a 24/96 Studio download from
Pdf booklet includes sung texts

The highlight of Edward Gardner’s tenure with the Bergen Philharmonic – he’s been their principal conductor since 2015 – is a vividly dramatic recording of Janáček’s Glagolitic Mass. That set up high expectations for his take on another choral masterpiece, Schoenberg’s Gurre-Lieder, which, alas, weren’t met. Now he’s got to Berlioz’s truly grand Op. 5, a work I’ve known and admired for forty years. My introduction to the Requiem was the Louis Frémaux set with the CBSO, now part of a 12-CD box from Warner. I’ve owned many versions since, but for me the late, great Sir Colin Davis’s 1969 recording for Philips – reissued on SACD by Pentatone – has never been surpassed. Even his Dresden memorial concert from 1994 (Profil), and his 2012 account for LSO Live, don’t really challenge that old classic, although, as you’ll see from the link above, John Quinn thought very highly of the London remake.

Having nailed my colours to the mast, it’s clear Gardner’s performance will have to be very special indeed if it’s to supplant my hardy favourite. First impressions aren’t good, the soft-grained, seemingly underpowered Kyrie lacking any sense of devotion or impending drama. As for the less-than-immediate sound – perhaps compromised by the constraints of a live performance – it ensures the apocalyptic noise of the Tuba mirum just doesn’t move and shake as it should. Not only do Davis’s orchestra, augmented brass and the LSO and Wandsworth choirs all respond with a fervour and focus that surely emanates from the podium, they’re also ideally spread across a broad and spacious soundstage. A reminder, if it were needed, that the Philips set, nearly fifty years old, is as much a technical marvel as it is a musical milestone.

The hushed playing and singing in Gardner’s Quid sum miser is more appealing, yet even here I yearned for the luminous, long-breathed phrases that Davis made his own. And if you’re expecting a blaze of sound in Rex tremendae, you’ll be sorely disappointed. No sign, either, of the intuitive tempi and felicitous rhythms, especially in the surging Lacrymosa, that make Sir Colin’s performance so vital and interesting. Here, more than anywhere else, I was acutely aware of Gardner’s curiously stop-start approach to this music, which effectively destroys all sense of line or narrative. Contrast that with Davis’s magisterial control of the work’s long spans, not to mention his awareness of its inner dialogues and striking sonorities. A good example of the latter are the rich, dark trombone pedals in Davis’s Hostias, which launch themselves into the void like departing souls; alas, they count for very little in this new recording.

Frankly, I find this Bergen performance rather bland. Indeed, there’s barely any contrast here, those huge dynamic swings strangely curtailed. Unfortunately, the somewhat distant sound and less-than-ideal perspectives don’t help. For instance, the tenor soloist, Bror Magnus Tødenes, sounds like he’s singing from the car park. (Then again, there’s none of the crude focus pulling that marred Gardner’s Gurre-Lieder.) Davis crowns his glorious performance with a deeply moving Agnus Dei, its lovely ‘Amens’ – Berlioz was rather good at those – bringing with them a wonderful sense of release. Although Gardner’s refined Norwegian choirs are suitably hushed at this point, they lack the sheer frisson of their British counterparts.

Yes, there are moments of real poise and beauty in this performance; however, Gardner’s cultivated reticence never really conveys the complexities of this great score. It’s not just the notes, of course, it’s about the very theatrical way Berlioz uses the performing space. To be fair, that’s more of a challenge in the relative confines of the Grieghallen. Which begs the question: why wasn’t it performed in Bergen’s cathedral, where some of that marvellous Janáček album was recorded? Venue considerations aside, we need to remember that this isn’t just a ceremonial piece, it’s a French ceremonial piece, so it demands a sense of spectacle. For all sorts of reasons, technical as well as musical, that doesn’t come across here.

Davis certainly fits the bill, although I concede some may feel he’s too flamboyant at times, not to say old-fashioned, in his desire for a big sound. (Trouble is, his approach simply underlines the comparative smallness of Gardner’s reading.) In the end, what Sir Colin brings to the piece, that few rivals do, is immense drive and unrivalled insight, and that makes his classic set so special. He may have lost some of that fire in his later years, but I have very fond memories of his Prom performances of the Grande Messe and its ‘little brother’, the Te Deum. In death, as in life, he’s a very hard act to follow.

Gardner’s Requiem lacks scale, character or ambition; disappointing sound, too.

Dan Morgan

We are currently offering in excess of 51,000 reviews

Advertising on

Donate and keep us afloat


New Releases

Naxos Classical

Nimbus Podcast

Obtain 10% discount

Special offer 50% off
15CDs £83 incl. postage

Musicweb sells the following labels
Acte Préalable
(THE Polish label)
Altus 10% off
Atoll 10% off
CRD 10% off
Hallé 10% off
Lyrita 10% off
Nimbus 10% off
Nimbus Alliance
Prima voce 10% off
Red Priest 10% off
Retrospective 10% off
Saydisc 10% off
Sterling 10% off

Follow us on Twitter

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing

Sample: See what you will get

Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor
Rob Barnett
Editor in Chief
John Quinn
Seen & Heard
Editor Emeritus
   Bill Kenny
MusicWeb Webmaster
   David Barker
Jonathan Woolf
MusicWeb Founder
   Len Mullenger