another entertaining volume
a strong cast
the air from
NOT a budget
Support us financially by purchasing this from
Alexandre GUILMANT (1837-1911) Sonata No.7 in F, Op.89 [30:03]
Louis VIERNE (1870-1937) Pièces de fantaisie:
Toccata [3:43]; Clair de lune [8:45]; Impromptu [2:59]; Etoile du Soir [6:47]
Alexandre GUILMANT Sonata No.4 in d minor, Op.61 [18:56]
Eugène GIGOUT (1844-1925) Dix Pièces pour orgue: Toccata [2:53]
David M Patrick (Van den Heuvel organ, Katarina Kyrka, Stockholm)
rec. 10-12 July 2002, and 20 July 2001, Katarina Kyrka, Stockholm. DDD.
Organ specification included.
The only mystery about this CD is why we have had to wait so long for it:
the recording was made in 2001 and 2002 and it hasn’t been around before in
another guise, to the best of my knowledge. John France
David Patrick’s programme of French and Belgian organ music for Guild very
favourably (GMCD7801). Reviewed as recently as February 2018, that release
followed fairly hard on the heels of the recordings including on it,
whereas the music on the new release has been in the ‘can’ for 16 or 17
Did Guild think that the programme wouldn’t be popular enough? Alexandre
Guilmant is not exactly as well known as Vierne and Widor, but there are
complete 3-CD recordings of his organ sonatas from Brilliant Classics
(Adriano Falcioni 94227, super-budget-price) and on MDG (Ben van Oosten
MDG3160340), while Sonata No.7 with a selection of shorter pieces features
on Ricercar (Joris Verdin RIC267). And that seems to be the sum total of
I see that, in reviewing a Talent recording of French organ music
containing Guilmant’s Sonata No.1 (DOM 2910 108), I managed to say
about the music or the composer – I was too busy pondering why a brass
quintet had been brought in to accompany the organ! Not surprisingly, that
recording seems to have disappeared without trace, even as a download or
streamed version. No such problem with the new Guild recording, which I was
able to enjoy without feeling perpexed.
Guilmant’s Sonata No.7 is a lengthy work containing very varied movements: some of
these could easily have featured on one of Christopher Herrick’s Organ Fireworks Hyperion CDs – his Symphony No.1 is on CDA67758 –
CD or download – and the second movement of Sonata No.7 (appropriately
entitled Rêve on Hyperion) features on his Ripon Cathedral album of Organ Dreams Volume 2 (Hyperion CDA67146 – from
CD or download).
Herrick gives that movement more time to breathe than Patrick and the
result is even more magical; I marginally prefer it, but in a sense that’s irrelevant
to an overview of the complete sonata and Patrick’s reading as a whole is
about as good as it gets. Actually, I have some reservations about
Herrick’s recording in that a whole 73 minutes of dream-like music, however
beautifully played, however well suited to the Ripon organ, and however
much variation there is within the format, does lack variety. I haven’t
actually done it, but downloaders could mix and match the tracks of this
album with one of Herrick’s Organ Fireworks CDs for variety.
(If you do it, be very careful about re-numbering the tracks and back
everything up first.) On the
other hand, Organ Dreams 2 is very valuable for containing Elgar’s complete
set of Vesper Voluntaries.
If you are not looking for one of the complete recordings of Vierne’s Pièces de fantaisie, 24 in all, the four recorded here will do
nicely; you may already have the most famous of the set, the Carillon de Westminster, so its omission here is no great matter. If
not, Simon Preston on DG Originals 4791926 (with Widor Organ Symphony No.5
and Reubke Sonata on Psalm 94) would be a good place to go. Alternatively,
there’s Christopher Herrick, again on an Organ Fireworks album
(Volume XII, CDA67612 –
review). Apart from the Toccata, the pieces chosen on Guild are
reflective, Étoile du soir almost mystic in quality, a feature well brought
out in Patrick’s idiomatic performance.
Guilmant’s Sonata No.4 is shorter and less varied than No.7 but it’s an
enjoyable work which deserves to be played and recorded more often, and it,
too, receives a fine and idiomatic performance. The only other recording
seems to be on the 3-CD Brilliant Classics set and on a couple of
The short Gigout Toccata rounds off an attractive, well played and
well recorded recital. Gigout is another composer whose work I know only en passant,
so the Priory series of his complete organ works looks like
a good place to investigate further.
An important point in favour of the Guild recording is the inclusion not only of
the organ specification but also some detailed and informative notes about
the music. All that’s missing is the chosen registration for each piece.
One might expect that a Swedish organ would be inappropriate for this
French music, but the manuals and stops all have French names and, indeed,
it transpires that this instrument, built in 2000, owes much to the Cavaillé-Coll style,
albeit housed in a copy of the baroque case illustrated in the booklet, a
fact oddly not mentioned in the notes.
Even if the competition were thicker on the ground, this Guild recording
would be well worth considering. It certainly helped convince me that
Guilmant’s music doesn’t deserve its comparative neglect. As I conclude this
review, I’m listening to and enjoying Christopher Herrick’s recording of his Grand chœur triumphal, Op.47/2, and Marche sur un theme de Hændel, Op.15/2, on
Organ Fireworks I (CDA66121 – from
CD from Archive Service or download, with pdf booklet, for £6.99).
The Choral et fugue finale of Guilmant's Symphony No.5 and Gigout’s Grand chœur dialogué are included on Organ Fireworks XI (CDA67577 – from
CD or download with pdf booklet). Either, or both, of those could be your
next stop after the new Guild release has convinced you of the value of
Guilmant and Gigout; if you like French
organ music, I’m sure that it will. Did I mention how much more
wonderful and varied music is also included on those Herrick recordings?
We are currently
offering in excess of 50,400 reviews
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Senior Editor
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny Editor in Chief
Vacant MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger