George Frideric HANDEL (1685–1759)
Saul (1738) [149:39]
Rosemary Joshua (soprano) – Michal; Emma Bell (soprano) – Merab; Lawrence Zazzo (counter-tenor) – David; Jeremy Ovenden (tenor) – Jonathan; Michael Slattery (tenor) – High Priest, Witch of Endor; Finnur Bjarnason (tenor) – Amalekite, Abner; Henry Waddington (baritone) – Doeg, Samuel; Gidon Saks (bass-baritone) – Saul
RIAS Kammerchor, Concerto Köln/René Jacobs
rec. 2004, Teldex Studio, Berlin
Liner notes and short synopsis in French, English and German.
HARMONIA MUNDI HMY2921877-78 [74:33 + 75:06]
Saul, with a libretto by Charles Jennens, based on
The First Book of Samuel, is one of Handel´s most dramatic oratorios. It was
regularly revived during the composer’s lifetime and also survived the
nineteenth century neglect of Handel’s great choral compositions. Messiah
and a few others also did. It is still popular and has been successfully staged
on several occasions. Winton Dean called it "one of the supreme masterpieces
of dramatic art, comparable with The Oresteia and King Lear”. It has
been recorded a number of times and I still treasure an Archiv recording (4476962)
from 1973 under Charles Mackerras with the English Chamber Orchestra, Leeds
Festival Chorus and a starry line-up of soloists with Donald McIntyre (Saul),
Margaret Price, Sheila Armstrong, Ryland Davies, James Bowman, Stafford Dean
and John Winfield. That recording has stood the test of time admirably, sonically
as well as musically and I see no reason to scrap it after hearing René Jacobs'
version, extremely good though it is. Concerto Köln, with which he also recorded
Giulio Cesare, has long been one of the leading period instrument
orchestras and they play with vitality and rhythmic swagger. You only need
to listen to the overture to realise that this is the real thing. The 36-strong
RIAS Kammerchor is another important building block in this production, powerful
and fine-tuned and they really make the most of the choruses, so central to
this drama.
Add to this the soloists, not all of them as well-known as their counterparts
on the Mackerras recording (still available as a download) but each just as
good. Rosemary Joshua’s light and silvery voice is ideal for Michal
and Emma Bell, slightly fluttery as she sometimes is, has the technical capacity
for the florid writing in her first aria. Lawrence Zazzo is one of the most
outstanding counter-tenors of today and as David he out-sings James Bowman
on the Mackerras set. Jeremy Ovenden is a truly excellent Jonathan. Birth
and fortune, one of the great Handel arias, has rarely sounded so good.
Michael Slattery, who is both the High Priest and the Witch of Endor, is also
splendid and his reading of the remarkable aria Infernal spirits
almost worth the price of this set alone. Gidon Saks is a monumental Saul
and his arias are magnificently sung.
The recording is excellent and the notes informative and well written. I only
wish the full texts had been available. I still like the Mackerras recording,
having played it regularly for almost forty years, and will continue to play
it, but this historically informed version will probably be my choice just
as often in the future.
Göran Forsling
|
Support us financially by purchasing
this from
|
|
 |
 |
 |
|