Wolfgang Amadeus MOZART (1756-1791)
Die Zauberflöte K620 (1791)
Performance details below review
OPUS ARTE DVD OA1122D [163:00 + bonus: 20:00]
With the death of the relatively enlightened Emperor Joseph
II, who had commissioned Cosi fan tutte and may perhaps have
suggested its plot to Mozart, the composer’s source of operatic
patronage appeared to have dried up. Given his parlous financial state
he welcomed the impresario Emanuel Schikaneder’s suggestion that
he compose a magic opera for his Theater auf der Wieden. The two had
resumed friendship when Schikaneder returned to Vienna in 1789 and they
shared the fellowship of the same Masonic lodge. Theater auf der Wieden
was a popular theatre holding around one thousand. It mounted productions
featuring elaborate machinery, live animals, spectacular lighting and
scenic effects. In the singspiel tradition the musical items and songs
to suit an unsophisticated audience were interspersed with topical jokes
in the local patois.
Various sources have been suggested for the basis of Schikaneder’s
libretto. There has been much discussion as to the relationship of the
trials undergone by Tamino and Pamina and the triumph of good over evil;
not to mention the Masonic background of composer and librettist. The
Masonic influence is also claimed on the basis of the frequency that
the number three occurs. It is said that this number is significant
in Freemasonry. Certainly the number occurs with the Three Ladies, and
Boys as well as in the musical structure. What really undermines the
argument for the work being a Masonic allegory is that there are only
two trials: of fire and of water. If there were any Masonic allusions
it would surely be to the three steps and trials that an initiate has
to undergo.
As I noted in my review
of this opera from the Bregenz Festival, Die Zauberflöte was
not only in the tradition of the Theater auf der Wieden as a popular
entertainment but was to include as much spectacle as possible. In the
operatic world of today, magnificent Roman amphitheatres not excepted,
there are few if any other venues for spectacle that matches that offered
by the Bregenz Festival. Every standard theatre and the big boys of
La Scala, New York’s Met and Covent Garden, all try to meet that
specification in their productions. In this second collaboration with
English National Opera, De Nederlandse Opera tried again. The previous
collaboration, in this same opera produced by Nicholas Hytner, had many
years of success in London but went down like a lead balloon in Amsterdam
having only one run. Such are the differences of taste, it would appear,
between Europe and Britain in respect of opera productions.
Well, for this second collaboration on Die Zauberflöte between
the two theatres, the well-known theatre Director, unknown in the opera
world, Simon McBurney and his designer Michael Levine were allocated
the task. Watching the bonus, featuring the former running around, his
hair all over the place, I better understood why his ideas were similarly
blessed. Occasionally he put a cap on and organised the mess, so it
is with the production. Ideas and gimmicks abound, some amusing, some
quite banal. The usable stage is quite small, square and hung by steel
hawsers at each corner. Sometimes it is in a flat plane at different
heights; at others it is tilted. This allows for the different heights
to represent the different worlds of the characters. These are quite
strange too. The three ladies first appear in casual army fatigues.
The Queen of the Night is an old bent crippled crone, either in a wheelchair
or assisted in her bent crippled walking by a sturdy stick. The three
boys are portrayed as old men-cum-cadavers with wispy hair and their
ribs evident. Monostatos is gross of belly and certainly all white.
As to the rest, modern dress is de rigueur for Sarastro and
his colleagues of the temple. He, bespectacled, looks more like a school
headmaster than anything else. Inspiration and spectacle come in the
grand manner with the trials of fire and water. If we should miss the
venue, words - in German - scrawled on a board are projected on the
back of the stage. I will not spoil it too much, but it is the best
trials spectacle I have ever seen on a stage in this opera and I have
seen a fair few live and an even greater number on video recordings.
The orchestra, on a level with the stage allowed for what I believe
happened in Vienna at the Theater auf der Wieden. Papageno passing his
flute, as and when required, to the leader of the woodwind section and
easy for either to pass from stage to pit or vice versa. The
conducting of Marc Albrecht did Mozart’s elegant music few favours.
A lot can be forgiven in idiosyncratic productions if the solo singing
is good or better. Regrettably, this is not the case here. Perhaps the
biggest disappointment is that by the scruffily attired Papageno of
Thomas Oliemans. He is accompanied by a mass of people fluttering pieces
of paper to represent birds. It works after a fashion, but his characterless
singing and bodily portrayal did nothing for me. As Sarastro, Brindley
Sherratt lacked vocal depth and sonority. I have heard him live
with much more to add than good pitch and legato. As singers, the two
lovers, Christina Landshamer as Pamina and Maximilian Schmitt as Tamino,
carried the day with elegant nuanced Mozart singing that is ideal for
the roles. She looked the part; he didn’t look the romantic hero
at all. Good costuming rather than wardrobe left-overs might have helped
them and others in the cast. Somehow or other, Íride Martínez got through
her role as Queen of the Night whilst Nina Lejderman was an appealing
Papagena.
When the production reached London, sung in English at English National
Opera, reports were luke-warm. I am certain it will not last as long
as its predecessor. A short life is likely to be true for many recent
productions at that address directed, as many have been, by the Kings
of European egoism or no operatic experience. Seemingly this has contributed
to acres of empty seats ensuring an increasing fiscal deficit to add
to the loss of Arts Council grant support.
Robert J Farr
Performance details
Pamina - Christina Landshamer (soprano); Tamino - Maximilian Schmitt
(tenor); Papageno - Thomas Oliemans (baritone); Sarastro - Brindley
Sherratt (bass); Queen of the Night - Íride Martínez (soprano); Papagena
- Nina Lejderman (soprano); Speaker - Maarten Koningsberger (bass);
Monostatos - Wolfgang Ablinger-Sperrhacke (tenor); Three ladies - Anna
Maria Labin, Silvia De La Muela, Julia Faylenbogen
Chorus of Dutch National Opera; Netherlands Chamber Orchestra/Marc Albrecht
Stage Director: Simon McBurney; Set Designer: Michael Levine; Costumes
Designer: Nikki Gillibrand; Lighting Director: Jean Kalman; Video Director:
Finn Ross
rec. live, December 2012
Filmed in High Definition 1080p. Format: 16:9; Sound formats: PCM Stereo,
DTSHD-HD 5.0
Subtitles: German (original language), English, French, Dutch, Korean,
Chinese.
