MusicWeb International One of the most grown-up review sites around 2024
60,000 reviews
... and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here Acte Prealable Polish CDs

Presto Music CD retailer
Founder: Len Mullenger                                    Editor in Chief:John Quinn             

Some items
to consider

new MWI
Current reviews

old MWI
pre-2023 reviews

paid for

Acte Prealable Polish recordings

Forgotten Recordings
Forgotten Recordings
All Forgotten Records Reviews

Troubadisc Weinberg- TROCD01450

All Troubadisc reviews

FOGHORN Classics

Brahms String Quartets

All Foghorn Reviews

All HDTT reviews

Songs to Harp from
the Old and New World

all Nimbus reviews

all tudor reviews

Follow us on Twitter

Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor
Rob Barnett
Editor in Chief
John Quinn
Contributing Editor
Ralph Moore
   David Barker
Jonathan Woolf
MusicWeb Founder
   Len Mullenger

REVIEW Plain text for smartphones & printers

Support us financially by purchasing this from

Sir George Dyson - His Life and Music
by Paul Spicer
450 pages, including appendices & index
ISBN: 978-1-84383-903-3
First published 2014
Retail price 45.00
The Boydell Press

Sir George Dyson (1883-1964) might be said to epitomise the self-made man. He died a Knight of the realm and a respected former Director of his alma mater, the Royal College of Music yet his origins were decidedly humble. He was born into an artisan family – his father was a foreman blacksmith in an engineering works and his mother was a weaver in a textile mill. Nor was he born into scenic surroundings: he hailed from Halifax, then a grimy industrial town, west of Leeds and Bradford in what was at that time the West Riding of Yorkshire. He was educated at local schools but got his big ‘break’ in life with the award of a scholarship to the RCM in 1900, just before his seventeenth birthday.

I confess that sometimes when I’m reading biographies I tend to skim through the chapters that deal with the subject’s childhood, impatient to get to the “meat” of the life that is to be described. On this occasion, however, I read this section in detail. That’s partly because Paul Spicer writes so well and because he provides sufficient detail without writing reams. The main reason for my interest is that I was born and bred in Halifax, though the town in which I grew up in the 1950s and 1960s had changed a lot – for the better – from Dyson’s day, not least through the provisions of the Clean Air Acts. However, mention in Spicer’s narrative of many familiar street names and buildings was very evocative.

In writing this biographical study Paul Spicer faced something of a problem in that Dyson was a private and unsentimental man who kept neither a diary nor any personal papers or letters. Fortunately, Spicer has been able to access Dyson material in many archives and he has benefited from detailed recollections and other assistance from Dyson’s daughter, Alice, who died in 2013, and his son, Freeman, who pursued a distinguished scientific career in the USA.

Dyson studied at Royal College of Music and was also sufficiently precocious that he obtained, very speedily, degrees at Oxford University. Most of his early works were destroyed but Spicer conjectures what they might have been like and discusses the few survivors. Dyson’s early career either side of World War I was spent teaching in a succession of English public schools. He was an early volunteer to serve in the wartime army. One of his accomplishments during active service at the front-line was to write a pioneering handbook on grenade warfare. This filled a void in military literature and is still referenced today on account of its author’s thoroughness. Dyson was wounded and sent home after which he was seconded to the Royal Air Force where he succeeded Walford Davies in charge of the nascent service’s music. He deserves much of the credit for the establishment of the RAF Central Band. However, Spicer makes an observation of his RAF work which is relevant for the remainder of his working life: he could be “fairly formidable when it suited him …”

On leaving the armed services in 1920 Dyson went back to teaching in public schools. His two children, Alice and Freeman were born and it seems that Dyson was very contented in his life and also in his marriage to Mildred Dyson. Spicer makes a very interesting point about the music that Dyson wrote during these years, contrasting it with the often-anguished music produced in the aftermath of the Great War by composers such as Vaughan Williams and Bridge. These and others, says Spicer, were “producing music which touched the soul through its introspection and pathos. Dyson was writing as if he had not a care in the world which, in many ways he hadn’t.” Yet Dyson hadn’t had an easy war; but he had been able to pick up the threads of his life more easily than some, it seems, after his war-time service was done. Furthermore, he was, throughout his life, a well-grounded, pragmatic man whose “way of celebrating was to drink a cup of hot chocolate. He was a home man, and whenever possible would always return home to his wife after a day spent elsewhere.” This is worth dwelling on, not because it suggests that Dyson was a dull dog - Spicer makes clear that he wasn’t – but because it indicates that Dyson’s feet remained firmly planted on the ground throughout his life.

In 1924 he was head-hunted to become Master of Music at one of England’s premier public schools, Winchester College where the musical tradition was already strong. This began a connection with the city of Winchester that was to last the rest of Dyson’s life. He stayed at Winchester College until 1937. He greatly expanded musical participation in the school – a good example of his life-long wish for people of all levels of musical accomplishment to become involved. He also inherited the Nightjars Madrigal Society, a ‘Town & Gown’ body. Renaming it the Winchester Music Club, Dyson expanded it into a full choral society with an orchestral section. This society inspired him to take up serious composition again and he wrote both In Honour of the City and The Canterbury Pilgrims for it.

The pinnacle of Dyson’s public service in music was his spell as Director of the Royal College of Music, which began in January 1938. To this post, as Spicer comments, Dyson brought “his vision and his determination to modernise”. He was also a very practical, hands-on Director, often involving himself in the minutiae of college life. As Spicer points out, the College when he arrived was rather cosy and amateur in nature and Dyson’s work to professionalise it, often in the face of financial stringency, was not universally appreciated. Most of the changes that Dyson made – and quickly – seem now, with the benefit of seven decades hindsight and as explained by Spicer, utterly sensible and very much geared toward improving what we would call nowadays the “student experience”. The changes concerned not only matters related to the curriculum or fabric of the college; other things received his attention. For example, previous Directors had been asked repeatedly, but unsuccessfully, to sanction the foundation of a college sports club. Not only did Dyson agree to the formation of a club; he became its President.

Dyson’s determined leadership was a major factor in the RCM continuing to operate in London throughout the Second World War. In October 1939 Herbert Howells described the decision to carry on thus: “I think Dr. Dyson has shewn a very real courage – some have called it sheer stubbornness.” Dyson recognised that the exigencies of war might place limitations on the college’s work but he was determined that insofar as it was possible cultural life should continue – for the benefit of the public as well as musicians and artists. This was not the stance of a blinkered man, living and working in a bubble; rather it was the strong conviction of a man who had seen front-line service in the Great War. In this connection it’s moving to read Dyson’s Director’s address to the students at the start of term in September 1939. Spicer says of it: “This penetrating analysis and ‘call to arms’ shows Dyson’s deep sense of history, place, duty, leadership, and unswerving rightness of mind.” Spicer uses Dyson’s start-of-term addresses to the College as the framework on which to hang his narrative of his time as Director; this is a perceptive approach which provides many useful insights into Dyson’s approach to the Directorship, to music and to life in general. Not everything that Dyson did at the College was good, however. Spicer records that a considerable amount of the College’s important collection of old music books, instruments and artefacts was destroyed or dispersed during Dyson’s tenure. To be fair, though, money raised from sales of such assets was ploughed back into the College for the benefit of students: there was pragmatism behind the ‘cull’.

Dyson’s devotion to ‘business as usual’ during the war years led to him sleeping at the college during the Blitz, despite the dangers, and taking his turn as a night-time firewatcher. The College suffered a direct hit by an incendiary bomb one night in February 1941 and Dyson was personally involved in the dangerous work of extinguishing the flames and limiting the damage. The College was hit again in February 1944.

At the end of 1952 Dyson retired from the RCM Directorship and he and his wife moved back to Winchester. However, he continued many of his public appointments, which entailed frequent trips up to London for meetings. In passing, it’s interesting to note that when Dyson became associated with a musical organisation, such as the Royal College of Organists, more often than not he was invited to become President and never did he take on such a role as a mere figurehead. In retirement he also continued to compose and he did so energetically; indeed, Spicer quotes the late Christopher Palmer’s observation that “Old age rejuvenated him”. It was only in the last three or four years of his life that old age really started to catch up with him, including an increasing deafness, a particular scourge for a musician. Dyson died at home in Winchester in September 1964.

One trait that comes through strongly in Spicer’s narrative is that Dyson had a strong sense of public service through music, a characteristic he shared with Parry, who was an important influence on Dyson’s life and music in many ways. This shows through in his leadership of the Royal College of Music, which is expertly chronicled by Spicer. It’s also evident in the work he did for the Carnegie Trust and as the founder President of the National Federation of Music Societies which, now re-named Making Music, flourishes to this day. During the 1930s, when he first became involved with those two organisations, he also took a prominent role in the Rural Music Schools Association, becoming founder President in 1937. The founder and moving spirit behind the RMSA Mary Ibberson (1892-1979), looking back many years later, had this to say of Dyson:

“The unusual combination of an acute and logical mind and a warm-hearted interest in amateur music-making made him a valuable friend and adviser to the growing Federation and his influence increased when he followed Sir Hugh Allen at the Royal College of Music. I had feared that he would leave us when he took on his new responsibilities; on the contrary, he became even more involved in our affairs.”

That’s a fine summation of a man who, distinguished though he had become, never lost sight of music’s roots with the amateur and, indeed, sought actively to nurture those roots. Writing of Dyson’s work in general and his involvement with the Carnegie Trust in particular, Spicer comments that: “The UK owes much of its present organisation of amateur music making to Dyson’s efforts in those years [the 1930s and 1940s]. It is a remarkable legacy.”

Spicer comments that one of Dyson’s “most basic and deeply felt philosophies [was] that music, specialised art as it is, must be within the grasp and understanding of the ordinary person.” This was emphatically not a question of ‘dumbing down’: as Paul Spicer reminds his readers Dyson had “the mental apparatus of the most ivory-tower academic at Oxbridge and … an encyclopaedic knowledge of repertoire old and new.”

His own music is conservative in style and he was not attracted to the advanced music of the likes of Schoenberg. However, his was by no means an unreasoned dismissal. On the contrary, in the years immediately following World War I he made a careful study of what he termed ‘the more extreme revolutions in contemporary music’ and these studies led him to produce a significant book, The New Music, in 1923-24. As Spicer puts it, this book and various lectures and talks confirm that Dyson “understands the music of Schoenberg intellectually and can analyse it in depth. But his ultimate conclusion is that this new experiment in music is a cul-de-sac.” So Dyson may have been a conservative but he was a very thoughtful conservative.

Dyson had a complex character. To some he could appear stern, disinterested and remote. Others, perhaps those who got to know him better, appreciated his sense of humour and that he could be capable of warmth once one had penetrated the surface veneer. A former pupil, Leonard Blake, wrote a lengthy letter to The Times in response to what he clearly thought was a less-than-complete picture of Dyson in the paper’s obituary. One sentence seems to sum up very perceptively so much about Dyson’s interwoven career as a composer and man of cultural public life:

“Chaucer’s Prologue drew the best from him [in The Canterbury Pilgrims] because it is a vivid picture of people – just those ‘sundry folk’ in whom he so much believed and whom he so much wanted to gather into music-making which they could enjoy…”

Paul Spicer is sympathetic to Dyson but not uncritically so and I feel that this book contains a balanced portrait of the man and an equally fair assessment of his music. He writes very well. He has a clear style and his enthusiasm for Dyson’s music comes through strongly. He also demonstrates a nice turn of phrase; for example, writing of the orchestral opening to In Honour of the City he says: “The whole opening is set up to sparkle like the sun on rain-washed roofs.”

Reading this book I got a real sense of the man. Spicer doesn’t overlook his faults and shortcomings but he paints a sympathetic portrait and I think he’s right to do so. I learned a great deal about Dyson as well as about his music from this study and came away from it with my admiration for both significantly increased. The book includes succinct but thorough discussions of each significant Dyson piece – and some more modest ones - and copious musical examples are provided.

The design of the book is good, though in order to accommodate the substantial text plus the appendices within 450 pages the print font is on the small side, though perfectly clear. The 17 chapters are all quite lengthy but I like very much the way Spicer has broken each chapter into logical segments, which is handy if you don’t have time to read a full chapter at one go. The appendices, compiled by Ray Siese, are an invaluable mine of information. There’s a list of Dyson’s works; a list of the texts that he set; details of 35 performances of The Canterbury Pilgrims that Dyson conducted between 1935 and 1960; a select bibliography; and a discography.

Sir George Dyson was an important figure in twentieth-century British musical life. As a composer he didn’t match the stature of the likes of Elgar, Vaughan Williams or Britten but he was still a fine composer whose works deserve better than the neglect into which they have fallen. As an administrator and educator he was insightful and had much foresight, not least in his tireless work to involve in the love and practice of music as many people as possible and from all walks of life. Sadly, his music is not widely heard in our concert halls these days but at least, as I pointed out in my recent survey of Dyson recordings, all of his important works are now represented on CD and in good performances.

Paul Spicer has produced an excellent, comprehensive and very readable study of Sir George Dyson and his music. I learned a great deal from it and enjoyed it very much. I believe that Spicer is now working on a similar project devoted to Sir Arthur Bliss. When it appears that, surely, will be as welcome as his championship of Dyson in this important book.

John Quinn



Advertising on

Donate and keep us afloat


New Releases

Naxos Classical
All Naxos reviews

Hyperion recordings
All Hyperion reviews

Foghorn recordings
All Foghorn reviews

Troubadisc recordings
All Troubadisc reviews

all Bridge reviews

all cpo reviews

Divine Art recordings
Click to see New Releases
Get 10% off using code musicweb10
All Divine Art reviews

All Eloquence reviews

Lyrita recordings
All Lyrita Reviews


Wyastone New Releases
Obtain 10% discount

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing