52,943 reviews
and more.. and still writing ...

Search MusicWeb Here



International mailing

  Founder: Len Mullenger             Editor in Chief: John Quinn               Contact Seen and Heard here  

Some items
to consider

£11 post-free anywhere
Normal service resumed


100th birthday of Mieczyslaw Weinberg on December 8, 2019.
Renate Eggbrecht has recorded all 3 violin Sonatas

Bruno Monteiro (violin)

More Preludes to Chopin
Kenneth Hamilton (piano)

Gloriæ Dei Cantores


Recordings of the Month


Beethoven Piano Concertos

Stradal Transcriptions

LOSY Note d’oro

Scarlatti Sonatas Vol 2



Feinberg Piano Sonatas

Schoenberg Violin Concerto

Early Keyboard

Nun Danket Alle Gott
Now Everyone Thanks God


REVIEW Plain text for smartphones & printers
Advertising on

Donate and keep us afloat


New Releases

Naxos Classical

Nimbus Podcast

Obtain 10% discount

Special offer 50% off
15CDs £83 incl. postage

Musicweb sells the following labels

Altus 10% off
Atoll 10% off
CRD 10% off
Hallé 10% off
Lyrita 10% off
Nimbus 10% off
Nimbus Alliance
Prima voce 10% off
Red Priest 10% off
Retrospective 10% off
Saydisc 10% off
Sterling 10% off

Follow us on Twitter

Subscribe to our free weekly review listing

Sample: See what you will get

Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor
Rob Barnett
Editor in Chief
John Quinn
Seen & Heard
Editor Emeritus
   Bill Kenny
MusicWeb Webmaster
   David Barker
Jonathan Woolf
MusicWeb Founder
   Len Mullenger

Support us financially by purchasing this from
John McCABE (b.1939)
Symphony No.1 Elegy (1965) [19:35]
Fantasy on a Theme of Liszt (1967) [11:36]
Capriccio (Study No.1) (1969) [6:39]
Sostenuto (Study No.2) (1969) [6:58]
Tuning (1985) [17:33]
London Philharmonic Orchestra/John Snashall (Symphony)
National Youth Orchestra of Scotland/John McCabe (Tuning)
John McCabe (piano)
rec. Barking Assembly Hall, Essex, 1967 (Symphony); 1977 (piano works); City Hall, Glasgow, 1986
NAXOS 8.571370 [62:21]

John McCabe’s Symphony No.1 Elegy was first performed on 4 July 1966 at the Cheltenham Festival by the HallÚ Orchestra with their conductor John Barbirolli. It is a work that I can hardly believe is not fairly and squarely in the concert and recorded music repertoire. Yet it would appear to have been largely forgotten over the succeeding years. The present recording was originally released in 1967 on a Pye Virtuoso LP (TPLS 13005) coupled with Kenneth Leighton’s fine Concerto for String Orchestra and Adrian Cruft’s superb (but forgotten) Divertimento for string orchestra op.43. John Snashall (1930-1994) conducted the London Philharmonic Orchestra in all three works. McCabe’s Symphony has never appeared on CD until the present release.

The contemporary reviewer in The Gramophone noted wryly that if the Symphony’s title suggested ‘mourning’ it was ‘certainly not for the passing of the orchestral symphony, the British symphony, or the Cheltenham symphony.’ He insisted that this work ‘declares … in every bar … a continuing life for these things.’ Paul Conway has noted that this work is not a traditional four movement symphony but suggests it is ‘avowedly symphonic in language’. It is in three unequal, but ultimately well balanced movements.

A number of reviewers seemed to have some problems with the symphony’s title – Elegy. None of the three movements present a particularly tragic mood although it is not in any way ‘light’ music. One critic at The Times newspaper suggested that it was ‘contemporary music without tears’ and was ‘immediately comprehensible in argument and full of arresting sonorities to beguile the ear’. Another reviewer of the work’s premiere considered that it was ‘all development: no themes’. He felt that it was discouraging for a young composer to allow ‘procedures [to] take priority over ideas’.

The first movement is almost like a slow march. It is entitled ‘Prelude’ which gives the clue to its part in the symphony’s structure: it serves as an introduction to what follows. However two subjects are formally declared and are duly developed. I do not agree with Paul Conway’s assessment that this movement is ‘tragic, death-haunted (like George Lloyd’s Seventh Symphony)’. There is certainly a dramatic climax, but the general tone is reflective and possibly even cool rather than heart-rending.

The second movement is entitled ‘Dance’ and exploits a number of interesting musical devices including boogie-woogie, jazz and even some contemporary ‘pop’ sounds. Does some of this music nod towards Malcolm Arnold – Heaven forfend. There is some ferocity about this music, yet it is full of positive energy and life. It appears to be almost kaleidoscopic in its structure. Listeners may feel that this movement could have been extended a little beyond its brief four minutes.

The third movement ‘Elegy’ is certainly much more profound and antagonistic than the preceding two. It opens quietly but with double-forte chordal interruptions. There are beautiful moments including some fine writing for strings in this movement that are often interrupted by something a little more sinister. There is a reprise of the ‘dance music’. The movement ends quietly and appears to have resolved any residual conflict. This symphony is, I believe, typically reflective rather than disturbing or crisis-laden.

Listening to this work after half a century seems to blow away the contemporary reviewer’s criticisms. Unless I am totally na´ve, this symphony has stood up well over the years. It has the wonderful ability to sound ‘modern’ whilst at the same time nodding to a greater musical tradition that includes Sibelius. It is a work that impresses and moves the listener and holds their attention. It is not a ‘dance of death’ but something more affirmative.

The Symphony No.1 ‘Elegy’ (the first of seven) was written during 1965 and had been commissioned by the HallÚ Society.

The three piano works are totally new to me. The Fantasy on a Theme of Liszt (1967) is based on a passage drawn from the Hungarian composer’s Faust Symphony. Interestingly, this theme uses all twelve notes of the chromatic scale. McCabe has cast his Fantasy in sonata form in spite of the title. Harold Truscott noted that this work comes as close to being in traditional ‘sonata form’ as McCabe had come at that time. It is a complex piece that demands a hugely virtuosic technique. Tamami Honma has written that this work remains a ‘favourite among pianists and audiences’: I have to admit that I have not heard it played in the recital room or on radio. The present recording of this work was issued on the RCA Red Label in 1977 (RL 25076) deleted these many years. The liner-notes for the current re-release suggest that it is often Beethoven rather than Liszt who inspired its pianism. I was captivated by the sheet explosive energy of this music. McCabe quite naturally gives an inspiring and dramatic performance.

Equally interesting are the two piano studies dating from 1969. They are from a set of four that were designed to explore various aspects of keyboard writing and performance techniques. The first study, a Capriccio, is effectively a toccata predicated on rapid repeated notes, an exploration of staccato chords, a wide range of dynamics with moments of complete repose and even silence. The second study Sostenuto has ‘vigorous’ music in the middle section, framed by sustained and reflective sonorities for the opening and closing material. Honma has noted Debussy as an inspiration behind this music. In both cases McCabe gives an impressive and rewarding account of these two studies. It is just a pity that the other two in the series Gaudi and Aubade could not somehow have been squeezed into the programme: there is only 62 minutes of music on this disc. Those two works can be heard on a BMS CD.

The final work is Tuning for orchestra which was composed in 1985. It was a commission by the Carnegie United Kingdom Trust for the National Youth Orchestra of Scotland to celebrate the 150th Anniversary of the birth of Andrew Carnegie. It also marked European Music Year 1985. Written for a large orchestra it sports a battery of percussion. The British premiere was given at the Albert Hall in Stirling on 6 August 1985.

McCabe has written that the work was inspired by hearing a chamber orchestra tuning up for a performance of Mozart’s Serenade for 13 wind instruments. He noted that by ‘sheer chance they alighted a couple of times on rich and sonorous chords’. It was this that provided the initial impetus for this work. In some ways Tuning appears like a ‘concerto for orchestra’. The composer creates blocks of sound for woodwind, then percussion and brass. The piece naturally divides into two sections: a slow-moving opening followed by a rapid toccata making use of fanfares, repeated notes and patterns. It is only at the end that the entire orchestra comes together for the concluding chords.

I found this work immediately approachable in spite of the possible objection that much modern music has been described as sounding like ‘an orchestra tuning up’.

The liner-notes have been written by Robert Matthew-Walker and the composer (Tuning). They give a comprehensive account of all the works. For further information, I encourage the listener to explore Landscapes of the Mind: The Music of John McCabe, ed. George Odam (2007). The insert also includes brief notices of the orchestras, the conductor John Snashall and the composer.

One point of confusion. The rear cover of the CD suggests that all these pieces are ‘World Premiere Recordings’. This is confusing as all the recordings except for Tuning were released on Pye and RCA Red Label LPs. The piano works have also been recorded in recent years by Tamami Honma (Studies, Metier MSVCD92071) and Graham Caskie (Fantasy, Metier MSVCD92004). I concede that the ‘original’ releases of these works were then (1967 & 1977 respectively) ‘premiere recordings’. Tuning was acquired from the original master made at the City Hall, Glasgow concert on 4 January 1986.

This is an excellent new release from Naxos that should command the attention of all enthusiasts of British music. It presents two important works by John McCabe that have so far eluded release on CD. It is also a pleasure to hear the composer’s own performance of his piano pieces, his conducting of Tuning and the excellent Symphony No. 1 Elegy.

John France