Pyotr Ilyich TCHAIKOVSKY (1840-1893)
Serenade for Strings in C, Op.48 [30:05]
Antonín DVOŘÁK (1841-1904)
Symphony No. 9, ‘From the New World’ [44:44]
Philharmonia Hungarica; Royal Philharmonic Orchestra/Antal Doráti
rec. 4-5 June 1958 Konzerthaus, Vienna; 31 January 1977, Kingsway Hall,
THE DORÁTI EDITION ADE048 [74:49]
Among the many fine recordings which he made, first
for Mercury and later for Decca, Antal Doráti’s way with Tchaikovsky
was always well worth hearing but his recordings of the symphonies,
on two 2-CD Mercury reissues, or one 5-CD set, with fillers, now seem
to be obtainable as downloads only. This 1958 recording of the Serenade
for Strings is otherwise available only on an inexpensive Presto
2-CD set, licensed from Universal, with Doráti’s classic LSO recording
of the complete Nutcracker (4327502)1 or as part of
a monster 51-CD box set (Mercury Living Presence Collector’s Edition:
4783566). The same LSO Nutcracker is also available on a Decca
Duo, with highlights from Sleeping Beauty and his later Concertgebouw
recording, with Suites 3-4, also remains available (Philips 50). So
the Doráti Edition reissue is particularly welcome, joining earlier
releases of the Minneapolis (mono) Sleeping Beauty and Nutcracker
recordings from the same source – review.
The Serenade receives a loving performance and I enjoyed hearing
it. It’s not the only way to perform this work and I thought it just
a little light-weight in places. I remember hesitating between this
recording and one recorded for HMV by Sir John Barbirolli a few years
later (ASD646) and, like the Doráti, originally coupled with Arensky’s
Variations on a Theme of Tchaikovsky, a most appropriate coupling,
though far less generous than we now have on ADE048. Barbirolli was
never one to downplay the emotion, as demonstrated by the fact that
his recording of Elgar’s Introduction and Allegro is still the
one to go for.
Of course, Barbirolli could sometimes overdo the emotion – I’m not allowed
to play his recording with Jacqueline du Pré of the Elgar Cello Concerto
at home for that reason – but he wrung just enough and not too much
out of the Serenade for Strings and the Arensky to make me prefer
him to all then-current competitors. Alas, I can’t point you to anywhere
to make a comparison: even the EMI Forte twofer on which the Arensky
was reissued has been deleted, but I suspect that if it were available
once more, that would still be my preference. It’s not a matter of
tempo – neither Doráti nor, from recollection, Barbirolli rushed matters
– but I do wish that Warner would make that HMV recording available
again. Memory sometimes plays us false, but not, I think, in this case
– that LP is still there as the benchmark in my subconscious.
The new transfer of the Doráti offers sound to match the performance
– less flamboyant and with somewhat less pin-point placing of the instruments
and a slightly narrower sound-stage than we usually expect from Mercury
Having already recorded the New World Symphony for Mercury, with
the Concertgebouw Orchestra, c.1960, not wholly successfully – now reissued
on Australian Philips Eloquence – Doráti recorded it again with the
RPO. I don’t recall there being a UK release of this – presumably it
was issued on the budget Vox Turnabout label to avoid competition with
the Decca Phase 4 recording which he made with the Philharmonia about
the same time (now in a 6-CD Phase 4 collection, Decca 4787662 and in
a 40-CD monster box).
I had not thought of Doráti as a Dvořák specialist, though his
recording of the Cello Concerto with Janos Starker is something
of a classic, albeit in a strongly competitive field, and the budget
Double Decca twofer with his complete Slavonic Dances, etc.,
is well worth hearing.
With such strong competition, this RPO New World would not be
my first choice – of many that I could name, Kubelík (DG2)
would be my Desert Island selection – but the aim of the Antal Doráti
Centenary society is to preserve his recordings and, taken as such rather
than searching for a top recommendation, I very much enjoyed it. In
fact there’s nothing at all that tempted me to get out my red pen.
If I say that there’s nothing that particularly made me sit up and take
notice, either, that’s not meant as a criticism: it’s equally true of
Kubelík, one of whose strengths is that he characteristically gives
us Dvořák fairly straight. It’s clear that both the Berlin Philharmonic
for Kubelík and the RPO for Doráti are enjoying the music as much as
their respective conductors, even though I don’t think that Doráti made
too many recordings with this orchestra.
I presume that the Dvořák recording was made by Decca engineers
– the Kingsway Hall was their stamping ground and the Turnabout label
was licensed to Decca at the time. Whether that is the case or not,
the recorded sound is fuller than in the Tchaikovsky.
Presentation is fairly minimal, without even the diacresis and accent
for Dvořák, though Doráti is printed with the ‘á’ throughout.3
The simple booklet merely lists movements and timings – no overall timing
for each work – the orchestras involved, the date and place of recording
and, for the Tchaikovsky, the catalogue numbers (mono and stereo) of
the first US release4. My review copy came in a paper sleeve,
with a simple pair of inserts for use with one’s own CD case – these
are post-free at a very reasonable Ł8/€10/$10 each. That’s a very sensible
arrangement: it allowed me to place just the CD and ‘booklet’ in a slim-line
case to save space. Only for CDs in jewel cases is there postage to
This well-filled and enjoyable CD marked my first encounter with The
Doráti Edition and I hope that it won’t be my last – there seem to be
some tempting releases in their collection with higher catalogue numbers
in the offing.
1 CD or download from prestoclassical.co.uk.
Also sample/stream/download with pdf booklet from Qobuz.
Please see Göran Forsling’s review
of the SACD reissue. I listened to the Qobuz as I was completing this
review and enjoyed hearing the Nutcracker again, but I’d still
choose Ansermet for my Desert Island (Australian Decca Eloquence 4800557,
with Suites 3-4 or Brilliant Classics 94031, with Sleeping Beauty,
Swan Lake, etc.).
2 Symphonies 8 and 9 on DG Originals 4474122, or Nos. 6-9
on DG Duo 4779764, or Nos. 1-9 on DG Collector’s Edition 4631582.
3 Incidentally, a cause of confusion: Doráti eventually gave
up reminding people that the accent was a mark of a long vowel – as
in father – rather than of stress, which should fall on the first
4 MMA11091 and AMS16040 in the UK.