Johann Sebastian BACH (1865-1750)
Partita No. 1 in B-Flat Major, BWV 825
Partita No. 2 in C minor, BWV 826
English Suite No. 3 in G minor, BWV 808
Rudolf Buchbinder (piano)
rec. Lukaskirche, Dresden, Germany, 2014
SONY CLASSICAL 88875053302 [56:57]
I have long admired the playing of Rudolf Buchbinder. His recordings of
Haydn (2564637872) and Beethoven (886978751027), whilst not my overall
favourites have always figured high. His interpretations have a lot to
offer, especially in his less Romantic approach to tempi which in some cases
can be quite exhilarating.
This is the first time I have heard Buchbinder play Bach and I must admit
that my feelings are somewhat mixed. Things start well enough; he gives a
spirited performance of the B flat Major Partita, slightly slower overall
than Schiff's original Decca recording (4117322), but with good
articulation. It is however, in the C minor Partita where the interpretation
goes a bit wayward. Here he is quicker overall than Schiff, with the
Rondeaux being less than half as long as Schiff's. It sounds just
too quick which is odd as it very nearly corresponds with the recording by
David Korevaar (MS 1461), a performance I really enjoy, yet Korevaar manages
to make the movement sound unhurried. There is also a lack of definition in
tempo in some movements, especially the
Courant and
Sarabande which sound too similar. This all leads to an uninspiring
performance of the Partita, which is a shame as I really enjoyed his
performance of the First.
The disc concludes with what for me is the highlight: a first rate
interpretation of the
English Suite No. 3. Here Buchbinder seems to
be fully at home in the music -a truly wonderful performance. I must admit
to being a bit of an authenticity bore when it comes to Bach's
keyboard music. I much prefer it played on the instrument for which it was
composed. However I have recently been listening to a lot of Baroque
harpsichord music in transcriptions for piano. If more performances followed
Buchbinder's spirited example I could well find myself leaning more towards
the modern concert grand.
Stuart Sillitoe
Track Details
Partita No. 1 in B-Flat Major, BWV 825
I. Praeludium [1:47]
II. Allemande [3:28]
III. Corrente [2:49]
IV. Sarabande [5:36]
V. Menuet I & II [3:00]
VI. Gigue [2:15]
Partita No. 2 in C minor, BWV 826
I. Sinfonia [4:19]
II. Allemande [4:22]
III. Courante [2:27]
IV. Sarabande [2:42]
V. Rondeaux [1:32]
VI. Capriccio [3:35]
English Suite No. 3 in G minor, BWV 808
I. Prelude [3:11]
II. Allemande [3:20]
III. Courante [1:59]
IV. Sarabande [3:41]
V. Gavotte I & II [3:56]
VI. Gigue [2:38]
