I am delighted to see that BIS are continuing to promote the music of John
Pickard. Last year I gave a warm welcome to a CD including his
Tenebrae (
review review), which I also nominated as one of my CDs of the year. I
was also delighted to meet the composer for a conversation the year before
following the UK première of
Tenebrae in Cardiff; Pickard has a
long connection with Wales which goes back to his study with William Mathias
at Bangor, although he now lives across the water in Bristol. The composer
contributes an intelligent and discursive seven-page booklet note which is
lucid — not always a
forte with composers — and provoking by turns,
and to which I shall turn at several points in the course of this
review.
This disc contains his two major works written for brass band. The
Gaia Symphony was indeed composed for the Cory Band from the
Rhondda Valley in South Wales during the period when Pickard was their
composer-in-residence. The four movements which comprise the symphony were
originally written and performed separately. However, the composer at an
early stage recognised that there were kinships between the various sections
which justified the title of symphony although he had “fairly strong views
about what a symphony should be.” These reservations are unnecessary. The
whole work centres around the ‘Gaia’ theory of British scientist James
Lovelock “which proposes the earth itself to be a living self-regulating
organism”. Pickard goes on to describe the theory “if I understand it
correctly” and it is clear that it has inspired him profoundly, even though
he draws a pessimistic conclusion from it: “From an artistic point of view,
I find the cyclic nature of this idea to be strongly compelling – even if it
does imply a limited future for my own and any other artist’s conclusions.”
As a composer myself as well as a writer on music, I hope he is wrong – for
his own sake as well as my own. Those looking for a more optimistic view
should read Isaac Asimov’s treatment of the theory in his sequel novels to
his
Foundation trilogy, which most unfortunately was left
incomplete at the author’s death.
Pickard, wishing to write the symphony as a continuous linked work, was
concerned that the “continuous unrelieved sound of the brass band might well
become tedious over the course of an hour” and also that “no band in the
world could possibly have the stamina to sustain a continuous piece of such
unparalleled length.” Accordingly he has furnished three ‘windows’ for an
expanded percussion section (six players) which act as links between the
four main movements. They do indeed serve the two purposes for which they
were designed, and blend well into the structure of the work as a whole.
The opening
Tsunami begins slowly but rapidly develops into a
whirlwind of a piece depicting the destructive power of nature.
Wildfire is a similarly fast and furious scherzo. After this
Aurora is a particularly beautiful slow movement, an intensely
atmospheric piece. Oddly enough Asimov employs the name
'Aurora' for one of his other planets in
his
exploration of the Gaia theory. The same sense of landscape impressions
extends into the lengthy finale
Men of stone, a suite of four
connected movements each depicting a Neolithic monument at a different
season and time of day. The depiction of morning at Avebury, serene and
calm, seems to quote from Britten’s
Dawn interlude in
Peter Grimes with its little arpeggiated flecks from the cornets. I
am not sure if this is deliberate, but it is certainly effective. Otherwise
the music, with its parallels with Mahler’s
Third Symphony in its
description of a whole universe of nature and mankind, is in the mainstream
of the European classical tradition. There are none of the superficial and
artificial ‘effects’ that afflict so much music which is being produced
nowadays. The
Gaia Symphony is an attempt to engage with modern
environmental concerns without falling into the trap of ‘new age’
simplicity. It succeeds triumphantly.
Eden was written a couple of years after the symphony, and was
designed as a test piece for the National Brass Band Championships in
London’s Royal Albert Hall. It is also a programmatic work, taking its
inspiration from Milton’s tale of the expulsion of Adam and Eve from the
Garden of Eden in
Paradise Lost as well as the Eden Project in
Cornwall which Pickard regards as “a small ray of hope for the future.” He
also voices complaints about “some contemporary composers (especially those
who work exclusively in the brass band world) … producing music that is more
concerned with producing superficial effects than with pursuing the core
values of intelligent construction and musical integrity.” I can only agree,
with the additional comment that Pickard can most certainly not be accused
of making such sacrifices here. The tripartite structure of the piece is
clearly demonstrated, and the music – which begins the disc – immediately
draws the listener in with its clearly delineated tonal basis. The central
section is furious scherzo-like music depicting industrial despoliation of
the landscape. The finale is an “intense lament” which only gradually
achieves a hard-won sense of optimism at the end.
Since the
Gaia Symphony was written with the Cory Band in mind, I
might shed a tear that they do not perform the work on this CD - although
they have recorded
Wildfire and
Men of stone separately. No one could complain about the
performance of the Norwegian players here, who produce a stunningly
virtuosic and heartfelt vision of the work. There has been a previous
recording by a local South Wales group, which was issued on Doyen in 2005
and was enthusiastically
reviewed for this site by Christopher Thomas (which I have not
heard). That disc contained only the symphony. BIS have put us in their debt
by the production of a CD which is so well filled – I think it is the
longest use of the medium I have ever encountered – and so superbly
engineered and presented.
This will certainly be another nomination for my ‘disc of the year’ come
December. In the meantime anybody who is interested in the development of
music in the twenty-first century should rush out and buy this CD at once.
It is to be hoped that this will encourage BIS to explore the music of
Pickard further, with recordings of his other four symphonies.
Paul Corfield Godfrey
Previous review:
Dan Morgan
