rec. live, Théâtre du Châtelet, Paris, 3 November 2005
(concerto); Auditorium Olivier Messiaen (Radio France), Paris, 2 December
2000. Radio France. DDD
William Hedley reviewed
Thierry
Lancino's Requiem a couple of years ago. You can hear
Lancino talking about
this ambitious piece on
YouTube.
The site review was certainly not an encomium. Even so I was interested
to hear what this French-born and US-resident composer sounded like in these
two works. They are heard here in healthy, open, good quality sound courtesy
of Radio France and the performances seem exemplary. The Concerto is from
a concert with audience applause but no other distracting 'participation'
that I noticed.
The
Violin Concerto enjoyed a celebrity outing here. It's
no mean feat to have attracted Isabelle Faust to champion this challenging
work. As for the orchestra and conductor, we know them for their excellent
work on Timpani - often in avant-garde music including
Xenakis
and
Ohana.
This concerto is not in an ultra-modern style. There are three successively
shorter movements. The first spins a sultry web redolent of Szymanowski
and Berg. The violin has a commanding muscularity and singing flight and
these aspects are highlighted by an imperious positioning in what we hear.
The slow moving, surreal and faintly melancholy
Lent is atmospheric
and is more diaphanously scored. The final Fugato treats the listener to
a panoply of modern and occasionally explosive sounds but is not dissonant;
more like later Bartók. There's even a twittering and buzzing
section for the orchestra which recalls a similar effect at the start of
Nielsen's Fifth Symphony. The smoothly plunging and at times aggressive
solo 'flight' carries the impress of the rapid eldritch passages
in Prokofiev’s Violin Concerto No. 1. The writing for solo and orchestra
has a physical impact.
The
Prelude and Death of Virgil is sung in French
and the text is given as sung and with side by side English translation.
In fact the singing is confined to one of the four separately tracked sections
- the longest one. In the
Prelude the brass groan quietly and there
are shimmering, shivering cymbals. A nocturnal ambience is established atmosphere.
It's quite eerie, alive with detail and rising to brassy rasping
expostulation. The
Interlude again wanders the same dark groves:
tense and dense. The weave of violins predominates. ‘The Death of
Virgil’ is the longest section and is sung by the mature-voiced Matteo
de Monti. He is not called on to do anything outlandish but sings in an
often stern and declamatory manner. The music becomes increasingly wild
in the manner of some nightmare pursuit. There's a touch of Peter
Pears about this singer; in fact I was reminded, more than once, of the
sound of Pears in the classic Decca recording of
Les Illuminations.
Mercifully, de Monti lacks the other singer's braying vibrato. The
final section has a hooded tone. This is music of a steadily upward boiling
restlessness and although tenderness does put in appearance it is threaded
with a surge doom-laden.
The booklet notes are in English and French as is the French sung text for
the Virgil work. English translations can be found inside the booklet and
also
here.
Interesting music rather than instantly compelling. It is good that it has
been recorded commercially.
Rob Barnett