The works on this disc date from two distinct periods of Moeran's life.
The overture
In the Mountain Country and the first two Rhapsodies
are among the composer's earliest published works while the other two were
written under wartime conditions almost twenty years later. All however are
pure Moeran.
In the Mountain Country was premiered while Moeran was still a
student at the Royal College of Music but demonstrates a great deal of the
composer's unique style and sense of orchestration. The opening clarinet
theme, combined with other material, is skilfully developed into a winning
if still somewhat derivative work. The Rhapsody No. 1 followed the overture
by only a year, but brings Moeran's personality into sharper focus as well
as demonstrating a wider emotional range and greater control of the work's
basic material.
The Rhapsody No. 2 is, on first hearing, less direct than its two
predecessors, but closer acquaintance shows it to have a greater and more
personal depth of feeling as well as more of an experimental element. Its
central section makes it among the most affecting of Moeran's shorter
orchestral works.
The
Overture to a Masque has little that is Jacobean about it but
definitely fulfils Moeran's brief for a short work to be performed
for the troops in 1944.The piece has a distinct out-of-doors feeling, and
while full of fanfares and striding passages, has a lovely middle section
that is all the more touching for providing contrast.
Moeran's Third Rhapsody was also written for wartime audiences, as a
concertante work for the 1943 Proms. In spite of its title it is one of the
composer's most closely organized works, being based on three
closely-related themes. These are developed and combined with such flair as
to make it one of Moeran's most imaginative pieces.
This is the second disc of Moeran's orchestral music by Jo Ann Falletta
and the Ulster Orchestra (earlier disc reviewed
here,
here and
here) and it is to be hope that they will record the rest
of the composer's orchestral works. Falletta emphasizes the dramatic and
rhythmic aspects of the music as opposed to the meditative but her treatment
of the quieter moments is still quite convincing. The Ulster Orchestra has a
long-standing connection with Moeran's music, having recorded all of these
pieces in the 1980s with Vernon Handley [see
here,
here and
here]. While the sound on this disc is a little
rough and strident the playing of the orchestra, especially the strings and
horns, is excellent. Benjamin Frith is well able to negotiate the virtuosic
aspects of the Third Rhapsody but could differentiate the quieter passages
more distinctly. Given that the Handley discs are the main alternative in
the catalog at the moment we can commend this disc to those who do not have
the Handleys or who are seeking more up-to-date recordings.
William Kreindler
Previous reviews:
John France,
Brian Reinhart and
Rob Barnett
