Printable Version: VERDI - Requiem C Major 714804 & 725408[DBi] - Musicweb International Classical Reviews

Since the DVD from Parma appears to be the better value in terms of time, let me deal with the large, 52 minute, bonus on that disc. It is called 'Verdi's Backyard' and is a bit like one of those guided tours you foolishly commit yourself to as part of your holiday package. The excuse for including it is that Verdi was born in this area. It contains no insights and is altogether rather amateurish in content. Trust me, you do not need to know what it contains but the booklet blurb promises we will 'get to know how Verdi "lives on" in the region and has even formed the area ... ' By contrast the Dudamel disc has as bonus an 18 minute interview with the young maestro and as such it is at least more relevant. Personally I found it too full of phatic language and short on concrete information.

The Parma film looks very grey; the hall, the chorus, the orchestra and the picture quality. I would not put the last down to it being DVD and not Blu-ray, but to a very ordinary master recording. The sound is constrained and at times hints at someone or some computer riding the gain controls. For example the Dies Irae does not expand as it can on competing recordings. The camerawork is unobtrusive. The soloists are all very satisfactory but the performance, whilst precise, is not urgent and indeed seems a bit slow. It comes in at 7 minutes longer than my favoured video Requiem, that by Abbado and the Berlin Philharmonic on EMI DVD (review). In Temirkanov's favour, it does warm up near the end of the Libera Me but by then it is, in several respects, too late. I would class it as a decent run-of-the-mill performance which was probably very satisfying to attend but with insufficient star quality to compete in a crowded market.

The Los Angeles performance has star quality. What could be more starry than the young Dudamel and a great American orchestra playing at the Hollywood Bowl? It is very strange that this crisply filmed performance has sound with ambience. I say strange because it cannot be a natural ambience in the outdoor Hollywood venue. It must derive from their doubtless cunning use of electronics. There seem to be speakers and screens everywhere. Even the four soloists are convincingly spread in front of the orchestra. Everything about this production oozes smoothness and polish. The orchestral bassoons deserve full credit for their wonderful playing. The trombone section included an instrument I assume to be a specially made valved bass trombone but nothing quite like it comes up on Google. Verdi asked for an ophicleide but this instrument does not look like that either. Whilst on presentation I could do without the mezzo beaming out at the world as if from a red carpet elsewhere in LA. Fortunately she sings well as do all the soloists. The chorus of whistles from a wildly enthusiastic audience at the end is also a bit much; Verdi's Requiem is not a circus. So, what about the performance? The killer, for me, is the lack of desperation. This requiem contains much desperate pleading for forgiveness in the face of damnation and the closing pages are amongst the most moving in Verdi's whole output. Here it is overwhelmed by polish and perfection and is maybe too beautiful. Additionally Dudamel is even slower than Temirkanov, running to 98 minutes, a full 10 minutes more than Abbado. One suspects Dudamel has a fine Verdi Requiem in him but this is not it. I continue to view Abbado on EMI as the great video Requiem, despite being only on DVD and thus inferior in sound and picture quality to Dudamel. Will the Abbado ever reach high-definition Blu-ray? I do hope so.

Dave Billinge

Previous reviews: Robert Farr (Temirkanov) ~~ John Quinn (Dudamel/DVD)

Masterwork Index: Verdi requiem

Support us financially by purchasing this disc from

Support us financially by purchasing this disc from