This is a most attractive collection and is much more than a merely worthy
successor to the first two volumes. It's the first without a
symphony. The first two are
8.572985 and
8.573157. My fingers are crossed for a stunning next
volume, presumably to include the Third Symphony.
What is it about Fibich that captivates? I can tell you which recordings
did it for me. Let's take two. The first is his Third Symphony which,
rather like Louis Glass's miraculous Fifth Symphony and
Madetoja's Second, needs to be heard in the right hands. For me those
hands were at work in a
Supraphon mono from the 1950s: Karel Sejna conducting. The
performance is lithe, pointedly delineated and flashes and flickers with
energy. I have heard some less prepossessing versions including that by
Järvi and the Detroit Symphony which takes the way of the limp lettuce. Get
the Sejna - ancient though it is. Next there is the gaunt bitterness and
tragedy of the epic
Hippodamia trilogy for narrator and orchestra - tragedy writ large and
craggy.
The works on this third disc in the series are an extension of the Dvořák
tone poems. Fibich even wrote an
Othello which comes first here.
This one is more about romance (14:48) than about tragedy although that
darker streak is present though deeply subdued. The style is something
between Dvořák and Schumann - more Dvořák in its span of moods. The premiere
in 1873 was conducted by Smetana whose own tone poems are also echoed. It
ends in a gentle self-effacing gesture rather than with a dark
crowd-pleasing grimace.
Two years later came
Zaboj, Slavoj and Ludek. This was well
thought of by Smetana whose own
Richard III is brought to mind by
the brass fanfares. It ends most effectively in contrasting textures of harp
and full orchestra.
All the works here are the products of a composer in his 20s or early 30s;
Toman and the Wood Nymph likewise. This work is taut and has more
engaging mystery about it than the others. The supernatural subject matter
must have caught and held his attention with more force. It's also
about five minutes shorter than its predecessor. Allowing for a few moments
of Smetana-like bombast this can be explored with confidence by those who
are already keen on the Dvořák Erben tone poems. It too is strong on the
grim and the supernatural. There are also some proto-Rimskian moments where
delicacy and steely determination meet as in the episodes between 6:30 and
8:12. The work ends once again with gentle episodes contrasted with loud
drama. Here he again shows the same mettle demonstrated at the close of
Othello.
The
Tempest takes us back to Shakespeare. Fibich was clearly
fascinated as he also wrote an opera on
The Tempest in 1893-94;
well worth hearing, I would guess. The tone poem is concise. The invention
is strong - almost Tchaikovskian - a composer who wrote his own tone poem on
The Tempest. The invention in the Fibich work is tense and very
satisfying. Melodic ideas are memorable and are handled with evident relish
by Stilec. This is a work you will want to return to. It ends with seething
and storm-tossed conviction.
Vesna -
Spring - stands to one side from the other four
pictures. This has more in common with the rural contemplative bucolic
idylls of
Impressions from the Countryside and the shorter works
that are coupled with the Second Symphony on 8.573157. It stands in the
branches of the same family tree as Suk's
Ripening and
Glazunov's idyllic Seventh Symphony and his own
Vesna.
Fibich shows himself sympathetic to Smetana's and Dvorak's
folk dances (7.31 and 7:58).
The recordings are agreeably detailed and with plenty of dynamic
contrast.
The notes are by Richard Whitehouse and are in English only. Pity we are
not told what the title of the
Zaboj work refers to.
A separate note on the performing materials assures listeners as to the
authenticity of the sources and the application of all repeats. This has
also apparently resulted in the removal of distortions that have become part
of the Fibich performing tradition such as it is.
All the works here have been recorded before and can be tracked down on
Alto (Douglas Bostock) and Supraphon but no one else offers this combination
of music. Add to this those assurances about authenticity of materials and
execution. By the way, there is a
Zdenék Fibich website.
All who are already friends of
Ma Vlast and the Dvorak late
tone-poems will want to hear this and can expect to find new friends.
Rob Barnett
