Carl Philipp Emanuel BACH (1714-1786)
Symphony in E minor, WQ 178
Oboe Concerto in E flat, WQ 165 [21:37]
Harpsichord Concerto in D minor, WQ 17 [24:34]
Symphony in D, WQ 183 No. 1 [10:57]
Alfredo Bernardini (oboe); Christian Kjos (harpsichord)
rec. 19-22 April 2012, Østre Fredrikstad Church, Fredrikstad,
LAWO CLASSICS LWC 1038
Here’s another wonderful addition to the CPE Bach revival
trend. A Norwegian period-instrument ensemble called Barokkanerne puts its
best foot forward in a collection of two concertos and two symphonies. As
with all the CPE Bach concertos and symphonies I’ve heard so far,
there’s always something to intrigue and fascinate.
Oboist Alfredo Bernardini is a period-instrument luminary
who’s worked with Jordi Savall’s orchestras, the Freiburg
Baroque, La Petite Bande, and the English Concert. His solo reading is
magisterial, especially in the moving minor-key adagio
, and his
instrument appealingly dusky compared to today’s squeakier versions.
It’s really an oboe d’amore, I think. Christian Kjos,
Barokkanerne’s in-house harpsichordist, is an able soloist too.
For me the scene is stolen by the two compact, muscular symphonies,
especially the opener in E minor. It’s like Haydn’s evil twin,
with a first movement that seems by harmonic sleight of hand to lead
directly into the second - like the second and third movements of
Beethoven’s Eighth. There are innumerable rhythmic tricks, gnarly
instrumental flourishes and other ear-catching details. The other plus
enjoyed by CPE Bach’s symphonies is their brevity, at eleven minutes
each. The concertos are short, too (21 and 24 minutes), but the harpsichord
work especially brings to mind Stravinsky’s comment about music
that’s over before the band stops playing.
Barokkanerne plays very well throughout, and has an appealing sound;
they are warm, rather than dry or dusty, in slow movements, and attack CPE
Bach’s darker hues with vigour. The concert-like program and digipak
presentation are pluses in my book.
As for competition: the harpsichord is available in a
modern-instruments version with even a new piano, on Hänssler.
It’s also on Volume 4 of the complete BIS concerto series with Miklos
Spányi. Heinz Holliger recorded the oboe concerto, though again
period-instrument performances are far less common. The E-minor symphony is
available on a similar Harmonia Mundi symphonies-and-concertos collection,
and on a Freiburg Baroque album. For the symphony in D, though, this is the
only game in town.
If you have the Harmonia Mundi album, grab this too. If you
don’t, grab both. After two centuries of unjustified neglect, one can
never have too much CPE.