Songs of Innocence and of Experience
Seven Songs of William Blake (Set 1), Op. 33 (1977) [14:45]
Motet: Et omnes eandem escam spiritualem ederunt, Op. 130 (1996) [3:21]
Six Birds, Op. 161 (2009) [4:46]
Two Studies for solo harp, Op. 132 [4:11]
Songs with harp:
Miri it is, Op. 53 no. 2 [1:07]
How beautiful is the rain, Op. 53 no. 3 (1983) [1:42]
Ceres’ Song from The Tempest, Op. 154 no. 8 [2:22]
Fairies’ Song, Op. 154 No. 7 (1999) [2:29]
Over Hill, over dale Op. 154 no. 9 (1999) [1:31]
Lead kindly light (from Requiem), Op. 111 (1991) [4:50]
A song of joy, Op. 165 no. 2 (2011) [8:26]
A last confession, Op. 137 no. 2 [2:16]
Seven Songs of William Blake (Set 2), Op. 55 (1979-1982) [24:42]
Charlotte de Rothschild (soprano) Danielle Perrett (harp)
The Chapel Choir of Selwyn College, Cambridge; Ely Cathedral Girls' Choir/Sarah MacDonald
rec. 12-13 July 2011, St George’s Church, Chesterton, Cambridge. DDD
English texts included
REGENT REGCD381 [76:49]
My colleague, David Jennings, gave a very warm welcome to this disc recently
and in doing so referred to it as the first disc of music by Gary Higginson.
In fact that’s not quite correct; it is, I think, the first release of his
music by a commercial company but a while ago I reviewed
a privately-produced two-disc collection of his pieces. I mention that not
in any way to correct David but simply in order to point out the existence
of other recordings of Gary Higginson’s music. That collection ranges more
widely than this Regent disc and includes examples of Higginson’s chamber
and orchestra music. There is only one piece common to both discs: the motet
Et omnes eandem escam spiritualem ederunt. However, I have no hesitation
in saying that anyone coming new to Higginson’s music should start with
this Regent disc.
Gary Higginson has been at various times a pupil of several highly distinguished
British composers, including John Joubert, Edmund Rubbra and Patric Standford.
It’s as well to state at the outset that he has been a fellow reviewer on
MusicWeb International for a good number of years. However, I’ve never met
him and don’t know him personally so I hope I can be completely objective
in appraising this disc.
In my review of the earlier release devoted to Higginson’s music one reservation
that I expressed was that the programme was weighted towards music that
was serious in tone. That’s not an issue here; though the music on this
disc is most certainly not superficial much of it is fresh and light – though
not necessarily light-hearted – in tone.
The album is book-ended by two sets of seven songs to texts by William Blake.
These are for a cappella voices with the exception that Higginson
includes a drum to accompany the quasi-processional opening song in the
Op. 33 set; it is also deployed briefly in the sixth song. One interesting
feature of the Op. 33 songs is that the first one, which uses a 14th century
Catalan pilgrim melody, furnishes the theme on which the remaining songs
are variations. The third song is a duet for soprano and bass. Unfortunately,
the music requires better soloists than are to be heard here. Neither voice
is sufficiently mature and therefore the singers are unable to characterise
the music properly; they sing the notes but offer not much more than that.
Indeed, I have to say that this lack of vocal maturity is something of a
feature of the Selwyn College choir as heard on this disc. One can’t fault
their commitment and they sing expressively and with what sounds like excellent
attention to dynamics – I haven’t seen any scores. There’s a welcome freshness
to the sound of the sopranos and altos but the tenors and basses lack amplitude
in their tone. One must remember that these singers are probably aged between
18 and 21 but, that said, I’ve heard more polished choirs in the same age
bracket. In truth, I think the choir is a bit underpowered and there were
occasions when the tuning sounded just a fraction imprecise and when the
choral blend was less than ideal. However, there’s also much to admire in
their singing and I congratulate them and their director, Sarah MacDonald,
for their advocacy of this music.
I like Higginson’s Op. 33 set very much. The music is consistently interesting
and the use of variation form is intriguing – there are just sufficient
references to the theme from the first song to make you aware that there
is a thematic relationship running through the set and Higginson’s music
fits the texts very well. I’m not sure if the poems he has chosen are from
Blake’s Songs of Innocence but an air of innocence pervades these
songs.
In Op. 55 he goes a technical step further in that the first song, to another
14th century melody, supplies the material for a double
theme and variations. As he admits, this second set of Blake songs is more
complex than its predecessor. The music is more searching too, though it’s
always accessible. I didn’t find it as easy to discern the theme and variations
structure this time but I’m sure that’s a failure on my part and not the
composer’s. As in the earlier set the third song is a duet, this time for
alto and bass. The singers here sing with sensitivity but, once again, one
feels their voices don’t quite have the necessary maturity to bring out
all the nuances in the music. The set includes the well-known poem, Tyger,
tyger, for which Higginson furnishes some intense music, which the
Selwyn choir delivers with great commitment.
There are only thirteen singers in the Ely Cathedral Girls' Choir
but, my goodness, they make a nice sound! Here, the ensemble is pretty flawless
and the sound these young singers make is keen, fresh and crystal-clear.
Six Birds is scored for SSAA and harp and, sadly, it seems to be
over in a flash. These pithy settings are most engaging and the performance
is a delight. The harp accompaniment works a treat and I don’t believe it’s
just the combination of upper voices and harp that put me in mind of Britten’s
Ceremony of Carols.
It’s not just in Six Birds that Higginson uses the harp effectively.
The Two Studies offer a very pleasing interlude between the vocal items
and then we find the harp as the accompanying instrument to five solo songs.
It seems from the composer’s notes that at least some of these – the Op.
53 songs – were not originally written for harp but they all seem to work
pretty well on this instrument. I found Charlotte de Rothschild’s voice
grew on me – perhaps the lower tessitura of parts of Miri it is
didn’t show her voice to best advantage – but she comes into her own in
How beautiful is the rain, a soft, sensitive setting which she
floats beautifully. Ceres’ Song is a very eloquent, lyrical composition
while in Fairies’ Song two sopranos are required and Charlotte
de Rothschild duets with a member of the Selwyn College choir, Aoife Monaghan.
Their voices are well matched and the song is a delight. So too, in a different
way, is Over Hill, over dale. Some composers have set this text
to quick, light music but Higginson sets off on a different tack. His setting
is moderate in tempo and has perhaps the most engaging melody to be heard
on the disc.
A song of joy sets words from Isaiah. It’s scored for soprano solo,
SSAA choir and harp and was written specifically with the present performers
in mind. Charlotte de Rothschild gives an expressive performance, though
it does sound as if she pushes the tone rather too much on loud high notes,
and the Ely choir is, once again, enchanting. The combination of female
voices and harp is a winner. I thought this melodious, appealing piece –
and the performance it receives – was a highlight of the programme.
Lead kindly light is a movement from a Requiem that Higginson wrote
in 1991 and which still remains unperformed in toto though the
Selwyn College choir has extracted this setting of Newman’s hymn and performed
it as a separate anthem. It’s very expressive and the choir gives a dedicated
performance of it. I wonder what the full work is like.
There is some very well crafted and appealing music on this disc and it’s
good to find Regent giving Gary Higginson’s music this exposure. Collectors
who are interested in English choral music will find much to reward them
here.
John Quinn
See also review
by David Jennings. (A November 2012 Recording of the Month)
Collectors who are interested in English choral music will find much to
reward them here.
Support
us financially by purchasing this disc from |
|
 |
 |
 |
 |