John IRELAND(1879-1962) Piano Music - Volume 4 The Towing Path (1918) [3:58] Three Pastels: A Grecian Lad, The Boy Bishop, Puck’s
Birthday (1941) [10:08] Summer Evening (1919) [4:13] Soliloquy (1922) [3:30] Spring Will Not Wait (1926-7) [5:02] In Those Days: Daydream, Meridian (1895) [9:36] Merry Andrew (1918) [3:24] Leaves from a Child’s Sketchbook: By the Mere, In the
Meadow, The Hunt’s Up (1918) [3:57] Meine Seele (1931) [2:02] Epic March (1942) [9:02] Pastoral (1896) [4:18] Month’s Mind (1933) [5:38] On a Birthday Morning (1922) [3:25] Columbine (1949/51) [3:57] Equinox (1922) [2:40]
Mark Bebbington (piano)
rec. Symphony Hall, Birmingham, 3-4 January 2011
SOMM SOMMCD 0115 [74:54]
I have said this before - but it bears repeating. In the early nineteen-seventies,
I got hold of three Lyrita LPs of piano music by John Ireland
played by Alan Rowlands. I treasured these, as it was unlikely
that it would ever be recorded again. It is hard to believe
that forty years later, there are some five complete or near
complete cycles of this music available in the CD catalogues.
Out of interest, these are by Alan
Rowlands, Eric Parkin (two separate recordings - one on
and the other on Chandos: CHAN9056, CHAN9140, CHAN9250) John
and finally by Mark Bebbington (vol.1,
One of the desiderata of reviewing is to compare versions. Yet
in this case, it is a matter beyond my capability or desire.
I admit to a preference for the Lyrita versions by Alan Rowlands
and Eric Parkin. However this is probably predicated on the
fact that it was with these recordings that I first seriously
explored this repertoire. Both of these pianists worked with
the composer - so there is a certain authority to their interpretation
that may be lacking from Lenehan and Bebbington. However, I
have never been disappointed with any of these recordings:
all these performers give valid and sympathetic accounts
of Ireland’s music. They are all in my collection.
There are three facets to Mark Bebbington’s fourth and
final disc in this present cycle. Firstly, there are the ‘standard’
pieces from Ireland’s repertoire - such as Merry Andrew,
Equinox and The Towing Path. Secondly there are
the delightful ‘children’s’ pieces Leaves
from a Child’s Sketchbook. Finally there are a number
of extremely rare or première recordings. It is the last
two aspects on which I wish to concentrate.
Firstly, a few words about the potboilers. The CD gets off to
a great start with the barcarolle-like The Towing Path.
It is one of the earliest Ireland pieces I heard ‘live’
and it is still a favourite. The deeply expressive Three
Pastels date from 1941 and are revisions of earlier works:
they are sensitively played here. Summer Evening is a
delightful example of ‘South Downs’ pastoral music.
Its 1919 date suggests that the composer was harking back to
the Edwardian pre-Great War era. The Soliloquy is one
of Ireland’s easier pieces to play. However, this technical
facility does not hide the deeply-introverted mood of the music:
it is heartbreakingly beautiful in its exploration of love and
loss. Spring will not wait is the last ‘movement’
or ‘epilogue’ to the song-cycle ‘We’ll
to the Woods no more’ (1928). I am never convinced that
this piece should be excerpted from the vocal work, although
Stainer & Bell have issued it as a stand-alone.
Daydream and Meridian are from In those Days.
These were composed when Ireland was still a student at the
Royal College of Music. He did not agree to publish them until
1961 after some gentle revision in 1941.
The final four pieces present the reflective Month’s
Mind with it 'longing desire’, the ebullient On
a Birthday Morning dedicated to close friend Arthur George
Miller, the Ravelian waltz Columbine and lastly the toccata-like
Equinox portraying a summer storm in both the landscape
and in the heart.
In 1918 Winthrop Rogers issued Ireland’s offering to a
younger, less technically competent audience - probably at about
today’s Grade 4 level. One of the reasons I like Leaves
from a Child’s Sketchbook is because I can play them
- whereas the majority of the composer’s grown-up music
is beyond my gift. As the Musical Times reviewer noted, these
numbers ‘show the not too frequent combination of simplicity
and significance’. I am pleased that Bebbington has chosen
to play these wistful works with seriousness and without condescension.
I have never had the opportunity of hearing Meine Seele,
although it has been recorded before by Jonathan Plowright.
This was part of the well-known, but now rarely-heard A Bach
Book for Harriet Cohen assembled in 1931. This volume contained
a number of miniatures by Granville Bantock, Arnold Bax, Lord
Berners, Arthur Bliss, Frank Bridge, Eugene Goossens, Herbert
Howells, Constant Lambert, Ralph Vaughan Williams, William Walton
and W. Gillies Whittaker. All were direct transcriptions of
Bach’s music arranged for the piano. Ireland’s contribution
was Meine seele erhebt der herren (My soul doth magnify
the lord) which was derived from the fourth (BWV 648) of the
Six Schübler Chorale Preludes for organ. The cycle
was first performed at the Queen’s Hall on 17 October
1932 by the dedicatee. The piece does not really appeal to me
- it lacks interest. However, it is good to have this piece
for the sake of ‘completeness’.
In 1941, John Ireland was approached by the Ministry of Information
and invited to compose a patriotic march. The Epic March
was duly first performed at a Promenade Concert on 27 June 1942.
The piano transcription of the Epic March does not work
- but then neither does that of Walton’s Crown Imperial
or even Elgar’s Pomp & Circumstance No.1. They
seem to lack any sense of pianism. I also believe that Epic
March is a little too long. However, that does not belittle
the piece - the middle section is truly lovely and presents
a deeply felt tune that deserves to be part of the ‘ceremonial
music' repertoire. There is nothing particularly epic about
the march except for the wartime circumstances in which it was
composed. It is well played by Mark Bebbington, and once again
deserves its place in this ‘complete’ survey of
The third ‘novelty’ is the Pastoral. If this
piece were played to the ‘innocent ear’ listener
he would not guess that it was written by John Ireland. This
splendid work was written in 1896 by the student composer whilst
he was staying at the village of Pontwgan in the Conwy Valley.
It portrays the landscape in a near perfect way. I noted in
a previous review of this piece that the music ‘contrasts
the darker, introverted mood of the hills with smiling fields
in the valley on a hot summer’s day.’ I do wonder
if Wales was the actual inspiration for this piece or whether
its true genesis is to be found in events or locations nearer
London. It was previously included in John Lenehan’s survey
of Ireland’s piano music.
The CD is attractively presented with a fine ‘sepia’
photo of The Towing Path at Pangbourne. The liner notes
by Bruce Phillips (President of The John Ireland Charitable
Trust) are well-written and extremely helpful. Finally, the
sound quality is all that I have come to expect from SOMM.
This present recording concludes Mark Bebbington’s exploration
of the ‘complete’ piano music of John Ireland. Each
CD has presented a well-balanced programme that examines different
aspects of the composer’s remarkable achievement. I have
enjoyed Bebbington’s performances on this disc and throughout
the series. His playing is excellent, is sympathetic and reveals
a deep scholarly and emotional engagement with this important
and beautiful music.
I stick by my assertion that all lovers of John Ireland’s
music will insist on owning all the currently available editions
of the piano works - including the excellent EMI discs by Daniel
Adni and Desmond Wright. However for completeness, the Bebbington
cycle cannot be beaten. It is an excellent place for a detailed
exploration of some of the finest piano music in the repertoire
of British music. Finally, if SOMM and Mark Bebbington are looking
for other composers’ music to explore - how about Harry
Farjeon, Leo Livens or Alec Rowley (and also Greville Cooke
and Norman Peterkin. Ed.)?
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.