Ludwig van BEETHOVEN (1770-1827)
String Trios, op.9:-
No. 1 in G major (1796-98) [25:10]
No. 2 in D major (1796-98) [22:16]
No. 3 in C minor (1796-98) [23:37]
Erick Friedman (violin), Emanuel Vardi (viola), Jascha Silberstein
(cello)
rec. 1977
CEMBAL D’AMOUR CD165 [71:06]
Three tonally and expressively compatible musicians are needed to
elicit the most from Beethoven’s early string trios. That is certainly
the case here, with the collaboration of three elite string
players. Erick Friedman, whose youthful training with Heifetz was
confirmed on disc and video, is joined by Emanuel Vardi, one of the most
eminent violists of the second half of the twentieth century, and by Jascha
Silberstein (1934-2008), less well known than his confreres, but who acquits
himself with distinction here.
These 1977 recordings capture a wide sound spectrum, neither
abrasively close - though the playing can be assertive and trenchant when
necessary - nor too billowing such as to diffuse unisons. It allows one to
concentrate on the core of things. Ensemble is tight, vibrato usage well
calibrated, the emotional temperature remaining quite appropriately,
reserved in the first two and more engaged in the case of the most
sophisticated trio, the C minor. They bring out the strongly lyrical core of
the G major, with virtuosity subjugated in the interests of a more malleable
communicative spirit. Pathos is mined in the slow movement, and a brisk,
bright and engaging spirit develops in the Presto finale. The three players
colour vividly and well.
What is refreshing about these performances is the sense of lively
interplay, something very audible in the D major where the slow movement, an
Andante quasi Allegretto is well judged. There’s nothing clammy
here, the phrasing remaining clean-limbed but not cool. It’s the C
minor that draws out the most ardent phrasing and tonal breadth from the
trio, especially Friedman. A tautly expressive ethos floods the Adagio, but
the sureness of the rhythm precludes any wallowing. The three string players
bring considerable clarity to their playing, thus revealing many
contrapuntal subtleties, and never allow things to obscure harmonic shifts.
They also ensure that these details are not unduly attention-grabbing, not
an easy balancing act to accomplish. At points the playing may strike one as
too spruce, but I think as a whole it remains finely moderated.
Jonathan Woolf
Three tonally and expressively compatible musicians elicit the most from Beethoven’s early string trios.