The Great Russian Pianists - The Original Piano Roll Recordings
see end of review for track listing
Recorded on piano rolls made between 1908 and 1933 and transferred
to CD in 1992.
DAL SEGNO DSPRCD038 [72:27]
This CD is a bit of a dog’s breakfast. The title is The
Great Russian Pianists though the pianists are not all Russian
and neither are the composers, though most are. The scant booklet
notes also don’t include all the pianists and there is
no mention of the composer where the composer is not also the
performer. That said the disc as a piece of pianistic history
is quite incredible. It’s not the first such disc I’ve
come across or reviewed but they never fail to stupefy me. Interestingly
enough this month’s BBC Music Magazine has an interesting
article on wax cylinders and it points out how difficult they
were to make and to keep over the years as they were very delicate.
When you hear discs like this that are recordings made from
piano rolls that sound as fresh as if they’d been made
yesterday you have to ask why anyone bothered to do anything
else prior to the invention of the gramophone and the shellac
disc when it came to recording the piano. I suppose it was because
with piano rolls you needed a reproducing piano and they presumably
were expensive compared to what reproduced the sound from a
wax cylinder.
The sheer quality of sound that comes with this disc means you
keep having to remind yourself what and who you are listening
to. This includes Liapunov playing his own Elegy on the death
of Liszt Op.11which he made in 1910, four years before the
beginning of the first world war or Scriabin playing his own
works, a composer who died in 1915. The fact that the earliest
recording here dates from 1908 and the most recent is from 1933
is irrelevant as the quality is almost identical with some exceptions
in some treble passages which sound rather tinny though that
might be my equipment rather than the disc.
Usually a review either concerns itself with the music where
that is less well known or the interpretation where it’s
better known, sometimes with both where neither is well known,
whereas here the main thing is the sheer fact that we can hear
giants of the past as if they were around today. I find this
particularly amazing when it comes to hearing Prokofiev playing
his own music or Horowitz’s masterly interpretations of
Rachmaninov preludes, fingers flying up and down the keyboard
like a man possessed. As mentioned above it is also salutary
to hear Scriabin playing his own preludes - not that he ever
bothered with anyone else’s music. It was also breathtaking
to contemplate that Cherkassky made the piano roll of Rachmaninov’s
Polka de W.R. in 1924 at the age of 12 in 1924 - though
some sources give his year of birth as 1909 not 1911 - and staggering
to think that I saw him play in the 1970s in his favoured way
without shoes. Incidentally I found it interesting to discover
that the W.R. in the title of that piece refers to Rachmaninov’s
father’s name: the W for Wasili being the Germanic form.
It appears that Rachmaninov may have believed it was originally
a tune his father had composed and which he arranged; he did
not know that in fact it was by Franz Behr (1837-1896) a prolific
but now forgotten composer.
I particularly enjoyed the Liapunov work Elegy on the death
of Liszt Op.11 which is the longest piece on the disc giving
the listener a better chance of assessing his playing which
is quite exceptional. Again it is incredible to think that he
died in 1924. That particular piano roll is also apparently
extremely rare, as the notes explain he only made four rolls
for the Welte Mignon Company which was one of the most famous
of the reproducing piano manufacturers. However, for me a disc
such as this is the star itself irrespective of what’s
on it so it is difficult to choose favourites though the Prokofiev,
Horowitz, Cherkassky and Liapunov are outstanding. I’ve
said before that future generations will have an amazing archive
of music preserved in so many forms from wax cylinders to mp3
and no doubt other methods will be invented in time. In our
own time we are already supremely fortunate to have these fascinating
documents to marvel at. I’m writing this passage whilst
listening to Godowsky playing Moszkowsky’s Polonaise
in D Op.17. I have to agree with the notes which say that
the performance “can be compared with any before or since
and still be called outstanding by any criterion”. They
go on to say that that goes for any of the 170 piano rolls he
made between 1907 and 1930 - extraordinary!
If you like being ‘gobsmacked’ by music and performances
then this is the disc to do it.
Steve Arloff
If you like being ‘gobsmacked’ by music and performances
then this is the disc to do it.
Track listing
Theodore LESCHETITZKY (1830-1915)
Two Skylarks Op.2 No.1 [2:34]
Performed by the composer
Vasili SAPELLNIKOV (1867-1941)
Dance of the Elves Op.3 [4:09]
Performed by Ossip Gabrilowitsch
Pyotr Ilyich TCHAIKOVSKY (1840-1893)
Nutcracker Suite Op.71a - Dance of the Reed Flutes
[2:10]
Performed by Percy Grainger
Sergei PROKOFIEV (1891-1953)
Prelude in C Op.12 No.7 [2:07]
Performed by the composer
Sergei RACHMANINOV (1873-1943)
Prelude in A minor Op.32 No.8 [1:06]; Prelude in B
minor Op.32 No.10 [3:24]; Prelude in G minor Op.23
No.5 [3:18]
Performed by Vladimir Horowitz
Sergei PROKOFIEV
Rigadon Op.12 No.3 [1:18]; Scherzo Op.12 No.10
[2:21]; March from The Love for Three Oranges
[1:31]; Intermezzo from The Love for Three Oranges
[1:14]
Performed by the composer
Alexander GLAZUNOV (1865-1936)
Gavotte Op.49 No.3 [2:26]
Performed by Sergei Prokofiev
Sergei PROKOFIEV
Tales of the Old Grandmother Op.31 [3:12]
Performed by the composer
Alexander SCRIABIN (1872-1915)
Prelude in C Op.11 No.1 [0:45]; Prelude in A minor
Op.11 No.13 [1:36]; Prelude in G flat minor Op.11 No.13
[1:28]
Performed by the composer
Sergei LIAPUNOV (1859-1924)
Elegy on the death of Liszt Op.11 [10:51]
Performed by the composer
Sergei RACHMANINOV
Polka De W.R. [4:26]
Performed by Shura Cherkassky
Peter Ilyich TCHAIKOVSKY
Song without words No.2 [3:10]
Performed by Shura Cherkassky
Moritz MOSZKOWSKI (1854-1925)
Polonaise in D Op.17 [7:09]
Performed by Leopold Godowsky
Malagueña Op.49 No.1 [4:47]
Performed by Rudolph Ganz
Theodore LESCHETITZKY
Mazurka Op.24 [3:44]
Performed by the composer
Moritz MOSZKOWSKI
Serenade Op.15 [2:12]
Performed by Ignaz Friedman