Founding Editor Rob Barnett Senior Editor
John Quinn Seen & Heard Editor Emeritus Bill Kenny Editor in Chief
Vacant MusicWeb Webmaster
David Barker MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Encuentro Ástor PIAZZOLLA(1921-1992)
Camorra I-II-III (1987-88) [28:13] Gustavo BEYTELMANN(b.1945)
Otras voces [8:51]
El desaparecido [7:46] Ástor PIAZZOLLA
Contrabajissimo (1984) [10:13]
Quatuor Caliente (Gilberto Pereyra (bandoneon), Michel Berrier (violin),
Cédric Lorel (piano), Nicolas Marty (bass)), Laurent Colombani
(guitar), Vincent Maillard (vibraphone, Otras voces)
rec. May/Sep 2010, Studio Sequenza, Montreuil, France. DDD
ÆON AECD1107 [64:21]
This disc is for those who do not need any introduction to Astor
Piazzolla. It contains four pieces by the maestro and three
more by the Argentinean composer Gustavo Beytelmann. All can
be put under the title "AdvancedNuevo Tango".
The three Camorras are dark and dense. They mix two main
types of Piazzolla's tango music: the "wild and crazy", and
the "pure and heartfelt". Many elements sound familiar. The
Quatuor Caliente is rather good in both the aggressive Sturm
und Drang outer parts, as well in the heart-throbbing, supple
and expressive internal episodes - especially when the violin
takes the lead. The first Camorra does not really work
out here, I'm afraid. It comes out quite mechanical. This is
due to the hard sound of the piano and especially of the bandoneon,
and to the unimaginative repetition. Also, if the lyrical episodes
were not so rushed, there would be more breath and more soul
in them. Camorra II is one of Piazzolla's grand tangos,
and the Calientes are very good in conveying its demonic urgency.
Camorra III is the most diverse of the three, and the
most beautiful. Between small thunderstorms of the entire ensemble,
jazzy and agitated, we have expressive cadence-like slow episodes
led by the violin and the piano. This is evening music, improvisatory
and melancholic, and resemblesAdios Nonino.
Contrabajissimo is impressive. Piazzolla's own version
with The New Tango Quintet on Nonesuch is sharper, angrier and,
in my eyes, not yet surpassed. Where Piazzolla is agile and
full of action, the Caliente has more power, but is more predictable.
Still, each has the power to impress.
The Piazzolla star is so bright that nuevotango
is still more a style than a real genre. Many composers that
have followed Piazzolla hook up to the tail of his comet. It
is very difficult to get rid of his influence - some do it with
great effort, some are happy to remain with the comet's tail.
The three works of Gustavo Beytelmann show differing degrees
of detachment from the Piazzolla influence. Encuentro
could have been written by Piazzolla himself. It has episodes
with beautiful cadences for the violin and the guitar. The mood
is nocturnal, chilly, tranquil, concentrated.
Otras voces is much more cerebral. The Piazzolla influence
is less immediate although it can still be seen as a distant
branch of the Tango tree. It is interesting to watch how the
composer takes elements of tango and builds music which is quite
advanced. To really enjoy this work, you must immerse yourself
in it, absorb it, ride with it. Be prepared: this ride will
be bumpy. Some places left me cold - for example, the final
stretch does not seem convincing - some were enthralling. Give
it a few tries, and it will probably get you on the hook.
El desaparecido brings us back, closer to the trunk of
the tree. The mood is cold and foggy. There are tranquil evening
episodes, where the violin and the bandoneon share the singing,
and more urgent ostinato moments with sharp, pointed
rhythms. Nothing radically new is added to the Piazzolla building
blocks. The work has its architecture; you can feel it. It's
like entering different rooms of a house: they are different,
but you feel that they were furnished by the same designer.
The aftertaste is comparable with that of one of Piazzolla's
Seasons of Buenos Aires. An attractive work, though derivative.
As a whole this album is more for those who already know and
love Nuevo Tango, for those who want to dig deeper. Definitely
not for Piazzolla beginners or as an introduction to the genre.
The sound is well recorded - maybe a bit too close. I had the
impression that the sound engineer wanted to reproduce the “sandpaper”
feeling of Piazzolla’s own recordings. The violin playing
of Michel Berrier is absolutely superb. It is completely inside
the idiom, sensitive and beautiful. Unfortunately, the sound
of the bandoneon is hard and mechanical, which is especially
noticeable when compared to Piazzolla's own recording legacy.
Quatuor Caliente had recorded two discs with more standard Piazzolla
repertoire. These have the same violinist, less focus on the
bandoneon and can be really good. I'd especially try the disc
with the singer Debora Russ. Judging by the sound samples on
Amazon, I’d say that one would be the disc to have.
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.