Mieczyslaw WEINBERG (1919-1996)
Piano Trio, Op.24 (1945) [32:03]
Dmitri SHOSTAKOVICH (1906-1975) Piano Trio No.1 Op.8
(1923) [13:17]; Piano Trio No.2, Op.67 (1944) [28:17]
Trio Voce (Jasmine Lin (violin); Marina Hoover (cello); Patricia Tao (piano))
rec. 12-14 May 2010, WFMT Studios, Chicago, USA. DDD
CON BRIO RECORDINGS CBR21045 [73:43] 
Titled Inscapes this release contains both of Shostakovich’s piano
trios plus the piano trio by his friend Mieczyslaw Weinberg. Making a sensible
coupling Shostakovich’s trios are quite common on disc with Weinberg’s score
considerably less so.
Weinberg is sometimes known as Moishe Vainberg or Moisey Vaynberg. As Polish-born
Jews Weinberg’s immediate family perished in the Nazi Holocaust. Precariously
having to keep one step ahead of his oppressors Weinberg always had to uproot.
In 1943 at the behest of Shostakovich he ended up in Moscow. The Piano
Trio, Op.24 is a product of his early years in Moscow and is regard by
music writer David Berg in the booklet notes as a, “wartime masterpiece”.
An emotional roller-coaster of a score Weinberg’s Piano Trio, Op.24
is cast in four movements. It opens with a Präludium and Arie restless
and disturbing movement of significant acidity. By 1:42 the mood has eased
down to writing of an aching almost languid quality underpinned by an intermittent
and uneasy mournful march for piano. The Toccata has a curt and detached
quality with relentless, savage thrusts. Commencing with cold, remote and
wary music the Poem movement alters at 1:03 to find a rhapsodic and
predominantly relaxed vein. Around 4:44 the writing develops into a disagreeable
and unsettling state of near frenzy. From 6:55 the storm clouds are blown
away with a more relaxed mood. The Finale commences with a swirling
world of bewilderment and anxiety. The underlying mood is like an impression
of rootlessness; always on the move; always feeling fearful. Suddenly at 6:23
Weinberg alters the disposition but it is rather an indeterminate one. A clearer
picture becomes more evident at 6:45 being reflective and appealing if remaining
a touch vulnerable and lacking in assurance. At 9:59 the piano plays a chorale-like
melody to provide a pseudo-religious conclusion.
Shostakovich was a favourite son of the Soviet regime before being heavily
condemned in Pravda the newspaper that served as the official voice of the
Soviet government. His first censure was in 1936 for his opera Lady Macbeth
of Mtsensk.
The second rebuke was in 1948 when Shostakovich, together with a number of
other composers were denounced for ‘formalism’; for writing music regarded
as lacking in appeal for the masses.
Cast in a single movement Shostakovich’s Piano Trio No.1, Op.8 was
originally entitled ‘Poem’. A student work for the Leningrad Conservatoire
from 1923 it was composed whilst Shostakovich was on vacation in the Crimea
for a health cure. There the seventeen year old Shostakovich met and became
infatuated with Tatyana Glivenko who was to be a feature of his life for almost
a decade. The opening of the score feels like indoor music in an urban setting;
certainly not evocative of the countryside. From 2:46 the general atmosphere
becomes one of anxiety and then frenetic intensity. There are two passages
(3:52-6:60 and 8:26-11:30) that interrupt the prevailing mood with music of
gentle appeal though carrying a sorrowful undercurrent.
Shostakovich’s Piano Trio No. 2, Op.67 composed in 1944 followed on from the
composition of his Symphony No. 8. The horrifying siege of Leningrad
had ended but Shostakovich hadn’t returned from Moscow. It seems that the
four movement score had been written in memory of a number of close friends
that had died in the war; victims of the Holocaust and specifically the death
of his friend the musicologist Ivan Sollertinsky. Shostakovich himself played
the piano part at the score’s première in November 1944 at Leningrad. Eerie
and bleak writing of an almost disembodied landscape launches the score. A
sense of disconsolate brooding predominates perhaps reflecting the torments
of the time. Sardonic in character, the short Scherzo is wild and relentless.
Cast as a Passacaglia the Largo conveys a chill of heartfelt
sadness. With strong elements of Jewish folk music the Finale is one
of the most curious movements that the composer wrote. The music could almost
feel genuinely humorous at times if the sarcasm wasn’t so heavy. Lying heavy
on the listener is an underlying sense of contempt and disturbing bitterness.
The music floats down gently to its close.
These are compelling and characterful performances evincing immense concentration
by Trio Voce. A slightly rough edge suits these scores far better than smooth
refinement. The playing has the spontaneity of live music-making. Recorded
at the WFMT Studios in Chicago the sound is vividly clear and extremely well
balanced. This excellent disc would prove an important addition to any serious
collection of twentieth-century chamber music.
Michael Cookson
An important addition to any serious collection of twentieth-century chamber
music.