Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
John Solum: Live in Concert Johann Nepomuk HUMMEL(1778-1837)
Flute sonata in D major op.50 [15:16] Joseph RHEINBERGER (1839-1901)
Rhapsodie
(1856) [6:49] Paul TAFFANEL (1844-1908)
Allegretto Grazioso (1877)
[1:53] André CAPLET(1878-1925)
Reverie and Petite Valse
(1897) [7:44] Georges ENESCO (1881-1955)
Cantabile et Presto (1904)
[6:04] Darius MILHAUD (1892-1974)
Sonatine (1922) [8:58] Richard WILSON (b. 1941)
Music for Solo Flute (1972)
[11:20] Ernesto KOHLER (1849-1907)
Flight of the Swallows
Op 72 [3:47]
John Solum
(flute); Irma Vallecillo (piano)
rec. 19 September 1985, Skinner Recital Hall, Vassar College,
Poughkeepsie, New York, 29 October 1978, London,
England (Kohler). DDD/ADD MSR CLASSICS
MS1126 [61:50]
The opening movement of Hummel’s D major
Sonata is bright and lightly played on this live recording
by American flute player, John Solum. The slow movement
demonstrates his warm and colourful tone, while the finale
once again gives an opportunity for fast-paced energy.
Solum is a distinguished flutist with
an impressive pedigree. Born in 1935, he studied with Kincaid
and went to Princeton University. Currently professor of
flute at Vassar College, he has been associated with the
Flute Club of New York, National Flute Association and
the Connecticut Early Music Festival. Over twenty composers
have written music for him, perhaps most notably Copland,
who composed his Duo in memory of William Kincaid
at Solum’s request. Respected as an editor and recording
artist, his professional career has spanned over fifty
years.
In the modern recording age, there can
often be a disparity between quality in a live performance
and a recording. In a recording studio, the only constraints
on technical perfection are the amount of time the performer
has to make re-takes to cover any mistakes. The spontaneity
of the live performance can be lost and the art of being
a recording artist can be far removed from that of a concert
artist. All the more impressive, then, that this live concert
recording lives up to the high standards we have become
accustomed to on disc.
Solum performs a wide range of repertoire
here, from the sparkling Hummel to a three movement work
by contemporary composer Richard Wilson, heard in chronological
order. Rheinberger’s Rhapsodie is a beautiful work,
in which Solum displays his excellent control of tone colours
and expressive range. He is accompanied in this recital
by Irma Vallecillo, whose playing is both sensitive and
expressive, allowing the flute and the music space to breathe
where required. The combination of these two players is
a winning formula. Taffanel’s Allegretto Grazioso is
a lilting miniature, performed with poise and grace. I
have heard a number of recordings of Caplet’s Reverie
and Petite Valse, my favourite being Paul Edmund Davies’ recording
for EMI, but this comes a close second. Solum takes the Reverie slowly,
giving a real sense of its dreamlike mood. The Valse has
fluidity and direction, with a wonderful sense of ebb and
flow. Listening to Solum it is clear that he is not bound
up in the diva mentality of some flute players. His technical
security is merely a tool of his work as a musician – this
programme does not ‘show off’ or ever once lose its musical
focus. This is essentially simple repertoire, played with
polish and artistry with expression and musicality at its
essence.
Enesco’s Cantabile et Presto was
composed as a test piece for the Paris Conservatoire in
1904, and is now frequently played by flute students everywhere.
Solum’s Cantabile is well paced, with a lovely sense
of flow. The Presto is taken at an impressive speed,
and the dramatic impact is further enhanced by a couple
of ‘live performance moments’; somehow very occasional
slips add to the performance rather than detract from it.
Milhaud’s Sonatine has a hypnotic
musical language which fuses the French romantic tradition
with jazz and modernism. The music twists and turns, sometimes
turbulent, sometimes languishing in the harmony and the
textural piano writing. The recital ends with Richard Wilson’s
three movement Music for Solo Flute, written for
Harvey Sollberger in 1972. This is a well written work
which shows an understanding for the capabilities of the
flute. The music features bird-like motives, which reminded
me of Messiaen. This is a highly enjoyable work, lyrical
at times and technically challenging at others, and always
full of character and personality.
As an encore, Solum adds a previously
unreleased studio recording of Kohler’s Flight of the
Swallows for flute and orchestra. This is a short work
in the form of a charming and virtuoso waltz. Although
the recital would have been complete without this, Kohler’s
music provides an entertaining ‘lollipop’ at the end of
an excellent disc.
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.