This download
(from iTunes) was obtained too late for inclusion in my
April
2009 Download Roundup and I thought it too good to wait for the
May
edition;
it will appear there, almost certainly as
Download of
the Month, unless something even better comes along.
If Jacobus Vaet
is anything more than a name to you, it’s probably because
you own or have heard his music on an earlier Cinquecento
CD,
Music for the Court of Maximilian II (CDA67579 – see
the strong recommendation in Johan van Veen’s
review),
which included his music alongside that of Lassus and several
contemporaries. I was recently very surprised to discover
that, despite the welcome given here and by other reviewers,
this featured as one of Hyperion’s ‘please buy me’ recordings,
offered on a first-come basis for £5.60. I’m happy to report
that I snapped it up at that price and am thoroughly delighted
with the purchase.
More recently,
Cinquecento recorded Jacob Regnart’s
Missa super Œniades
Nymphę, also for Hyperion (CDA67640). Again, despite
very enthusiastic reviews here and elsewhere, I’ve just purchased
that recording for £5.60, too. Not only did Dominy Clements
give it a strong recommendation in his
review, he also made it one of his
Recordings of the Year for 2007: “Richness
of sonority and expressive musicality characterise Cinquecento’s
performance, and their few voices always sound like many
more in this recording of some rare and special vocal repertoire.
Jacob Regnart’s music is as intoxicating as are these recordings.”
A third colleague,
Gary Higginson, was also impressed by their next recording,
of music by Philippe de Monte (CDA67658 – see
review)
and I was equally impressed by the download of that recording
in 256k aac sound from iTunes, as I wrote in my
March,
2009, Download Roundup:
Some time ago
I recommended a Claves recording of music by the 16
th-century
composer Philippe or Philippus de Monte
(50-2712,
Ensemble Orlando Fribourg/Laurent Gendre); in fact, I made
it Recording of the Month – see
review. If
you followed my recommendation and are looking for downloads
of more music by de Monte with very little duplication, Cinquecento
have recorded his
Missa Ultimi miei sospiri, together
with the Verdelot piece which serves as its
cantus firmus ...
in fully acceptable 256kbps AAC sound from iTunes. I
can the more wholeheartedly recommend this download since
I paid for it myself. Like Gary Higginson ... I am
disappointed only by the short playing time of this recording
and the less-than-appropriate cover painting, an unusual
lapse for Hyperion whose presentation is usually spot on.
I truly hope that
sales of the first two Cinquecento recordings never again
appear on Hyperion’s list of waifs and strays and that neither
the de Monte nor the present recording ever joins them there. Music
of this quality in such excellent performances, lovingly
recorded by a company which cares about these things, deserves
to sell like hot cakes.
Apart from odd
items on Etcetera KTC1287, music by Clemens Non Papa and
his contemporaries, Eufoda EUF1164, music by de Monte and
contemporaries, and a 10-CD Etcetera set,
Masters of Flanders (KTC1380),
the earlier Cinquecento CD of music for Maximilian and the
new recording are the only representatives of Vaet’s music
in the catalogue. Clemens, whose music is better known,
and who forms the anchor on KTC1287, here adopts the much
lesser role of having contributed the tune for
Ego flos
campi which forms the
cantus firmus of Vaet’s
Mass. Clemens must have been something of a joker, since
he gave himself the nickname
non Papa – Clement, but
not the Pope of that name.
Are Cinquecento
justified in giving Vaet a CD of his own, with the better-known
Clemens as second fiddle? Emphatically, yes. You may be
tired of reading reviewers like myself claiming that a particular
recording enshrines the music of a neglected genius, but
such is the case with Vaet, whose music is not put to shame
on the earlier recording by juxtaposition there with Lassus’s
Pacis
amans, and who certainly deserves the new CD virtually
to himself. If anything, the music here is more worthy of
acclaim than the five works on that earlier recording. Indeed,
it seems likely that his colleague Lassus valued Vaet’s music
highly.
The opening work
Antevenis
virides, is one of those works in praise of princes
which renaissance artists had to create to please their
lords and masters, though sometimes, like Erasmus, they
disguised their toadying as ‘advice to princes’. In this
setting of an acrostic poem
in laudem illustrissimi
Principis Albertis Bavarię Ducis, Vaet salutes his
master, Albrecht of Bavaria, his patron and Lassus’s. It’s
a workaday piece, but it’s also workmanlike, and it makes
a good introduction to the recording since it’s written
for six voices. Like everything here and on the other
programmes, it’s flawlessly sung, all six members of Cinquecento
taking part – two countertenors, two tenors, baritone and
bass.
The major work
follows on tracks 2 to 6. This 6-part
Missa Ego flos
campi is based on a 7-part motet by Clemens, included
as the final track on the CD. As with the Mass on the de
Monte recording, I wonder why this piece was not placed first,
so that we might have the basis of the
cantus firmus of
the Mass in our heads before the work begins. It is, of
course, possible to programme it to precede the Mass, but
that seems an unnecessary nuisance.
Clemens’ motet
Ego
flos campi is a beautiful work of Marian devotion. We
ought not to be surprised that a composer with a reputation
for dissolution and drunken behaviour could write such
beautiful music; after all, Thomas Weelkes was dismissed
from Chichester Cathedral in 1617 for drunken behaviour
and other composers have led less than blameless lives.
Vaet takes a very
effective piece of music and turns it, with art which conceals
art, into a minor masterpiece, the first four sections being
written for six voices, but the final part,
Agnus Dei,
is in eight parts. I don’t recommend that you become too
involved in the means by which this metamorphosis of Clemens’ music
is achieved, but they are outlined in the excellent notes – otherwise,
just sit back and enjoy the music. Everything is again excellently
performed and, in the
Agnus, the two extra voices
of the outsiders fit into Cinquecento’s sound-pattern flawlessly,
as, indeed, one of them also does in the Clemens motet.
Yet Cinquecento
aim not just for beauty in their singing; they are aware
of the affective power of the music and bring it out effectively. Vaet’s
Miserere (track
9) may not have the sheer beauty of Allegri’s famous setting,
but it does have the power to express contrition without
lugubriousness and these characteristics are well realised – fully
realised, indeed – in the performance without in any way
compromising the beauty of their singing.
The other major
work, the 4/5-part
Magnificat octavi toni (tr.8) and,
indeed, the shorter pieces, all receive excellent performances
which can only enhance the reputation of the performers and
the composer. Plainchant and polyphony alternate beautifully
in the
Magnificat. I’ve already reviewed more than
enough excellent recordings this year to have filled my complement
of Recordings of the Year, but this new recording must surely
be a strong contender for inclusion.
The recording,
made like the Regnart in the sympathetic acoustic of Kloster
Pernegg, is excellent. The other two recordings were made
in other Austrian churches with suitable acoustics.
The booklet is,
as usual with Hyperion, exemplary, with detailed and informative
notes on the music and all the texts and translations. For
once, the use of one of those renaissance flower-and-veg
face paintings, by the master of the genre, Arcimboldo, is
appropriate for music which sets the words
Ego flos campi, ‘I
am the flower of the field’. Whereas the paintings employed
for the Regnart and de Monte recordings were frankly grotesque – just
the opposite of the performances – this flower concoction
is rather attractive. To find anything at all to criticise,
I’m reducing to saying that I’d prefer the
ę ligature
to be employed instead of
ae in words such as
Filię (track
10, title).
You may recall
that Mrs Organ Morgan in
Under Milk Wood had trouble
deciding which of the twins who lived in the village she
liked better – Mr Organ Morgan, not listening, said that
he preferred Bach, closely followed by Palestrina. I find
myself in the same quandary as Mrs Organ Morgan; though I
share her husband’s predilection for Bach and Palestrina,
there is such a plethora of excellent recordings of renaissance
music available now that I find it hard to give them a pecking
order. All four Cinquecento recordings for Hyperion are
certainly among the best that I’ve ever heard, including
The Tallis Scholars and The Sixteen; I just can’t decide
which of them to recommend that you buy first, so why not
go for this new one?
If you already
have one or more of the other recordings, you’ll need no
urging from me to buy this latest offering on CD or as a
download. Don’t put off buying it, as I did with the two
recordings which ended up among the ‘please buy me’ offers;
support Hyperion’s enterprise in bringing us such wonderful
recordings. As with the de Monte, I can recommend this new
recording all the more convincingly, since I paid to buy
it, instead of receiving a review copy.
The download from
iTunes costs £7.99 and the 256k sound in this and the de
Monte download is hardly inferior to that on the two Cinquecento
recordings which I own in CD format. There are no notes
or texts, but Hyperion offer the substantial and valuable
booklet and the artwork as pdf downloads on their website – make
sure that you access these before burning to CDR or syncing
to your player, otherwise you may find that iTunes has placed
the tracks in the wrong order. If you have any doubts about
your technical ability to rearrange them, buy the physical
disc – available at less than £10 from some online dealers.
Brian Wilson