Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Inventio Dietrich Buxtehude (1637-1707)
Toccata in d minor, BuxWV 155 [7.46] Matthias Weckmann (ca
1616-1674)
Gelobest seystu Jesu Christ [10:50] Johann Adam Reincken (1643-1722)
Fugue in g minor [4.23] Dietrich Buxtehude
Two Variations on Von Gott will ich nicht lassen, BuxWV 220, 221[4:31] Georg Böhm (1661-1733)
Vater unser im Himmelreich [5.57] Johann Ludwig Krebs (1713-1780)
Toccata in E [3.49]; Fugue in E [4.00] Johann Sebastian Bach (1685-1750)
Allein Gott in der Höh sei Ehr, BWV 662 (1708-17, with later revisions) [8.51]; Nun
danket alle Gott, BWV 657 (1708-17, revised) [3.57]; Trio Sonata No.3, BWV
527 (c.1727) [16:48]; Prelude in a minor, BWV 543 (?1708-17) [3.27]; Fugue in
a minor, BWV 543 (?1708-17) [6.43]
Eric Quist (Hinsz
organ, a' = 448, equal temperament)
rec. 24 April 2006, Bovenkerk, Kampen, Holland. DDD
Notes in English, German and Dutch DE VERSLUIS dev-eq1016 [80:53]
I hadn’t encountered either
Eric Quist or Versluis before. D E Versluis founded this independent
Dutch label in 2000, primarily to record choral and organ music;
all of his recordings reflect his Christian identity. Information
on the label may be found at the home-page.
Each artist appears to have his/her own subdivision, distinguished
by that artist’s initials, hence the EQ for ‘Eric Quist’ in
the catalogue number above. Nico Blom, who also offers a predominantly
Baroque recital on the same Bovenkerk organ at Kampen, appears
on DEV-NB 1017. Sample MP3 tracks from both recitals are available
online; these offer some idea of the quality of the playing
but, as the site points out, can only hint at the quality of
the recording. The Dutch version of the web-page serves as a
reminder – to my mind, a sad reminder – of the world-wide corruption
of other languages by English on the internet: Een sample van
de muziek is te downloaden en te beluisteren in MP3 formaat
...
The title of the recording
is explained in the excellent booklet: inventio was the
first of the four phases of rhetoric and music, inventio, dispositio, elaboratio and actio.
(Will someone please develop a spell-checker which recognises
Latin and doesn’t convert it to its English equivalent when
I’m not looking). In fact, the booklet sells the process of inventio (literally, ‘finding,
discovery’) a little short: it involves not only the finding
of material but the power to stimulate the listener’s sense
of imaginative discovery, as in the Prologue to Shakespeare’s Henry
V:
O for a Muse of Fire that
would ascend
The brightest Heaven of Invention!
...
And let us, Cyphers to
this great Accompt,
On your imaginarie Forces
worke. (author's italics)
The organ of St Nicholas’ Church,
Kampen, known as the Bovenkerk, presumably because it is at
the upper end of the town, dates back to 1524, with radical
changes in 1626-30, 1676, 1741 and 1788. In 1972-5 a series
of 19th-century alterations was reversed, thus rendering
the instrument ideal for the kind of music recorded here. A
complete specification is given in the booklet, together with
full details of the registration chosen for each work, with
registration of separate sections of the Buxtehude Toccata and
several other pieces specified.
The tuning is stated to
be equal temperament (gelijkswevend) without specifying
whether this is modern equal temperament or one of the many
eighteenth-century systems; otherwise the booklet is a model
of its kind. We are even given the name of the stop assistant.
The English translation in the booklet is a trifle stilted in
places, but much better than is often the case with non-native
translators. “Each singe [sic] line is preceded by anticipations
which are consistently worked into all the accompanying voices” (p.6)
is not exactly what I should call idiomatic.
Eric Quist, born in 1977,
is resident organist of the Reformed Church at Tholen, on which
he has made an earlier recording. He has also recorded two of
Vierne’s organ symphonies for D E Versluis, part of a complete
set with other organists, DEV-VI 1010. No details are given
in the booklet but the Vierne is listed on the Versluis website
and details of the other recordings are available on Quist’s
own website: the Tholen
disc consists of works by Bach, Mendelssohn, Reger and Quist
himself.
There is a danger that
organists and other performers who cast their performance net
as wide as Quist has done end up as Jacks of all trades and
masters of none. I am pleased to report that his performances
on the current CD show him to be no Jack but a master of the
Baroque repertoire. Abetted by an appropriate instrument and
a very good recording, this is a thoroughly recommendable disc.
These are ‘plain’ performances
in the best possible sense of that word, that is to say without
the agogic distortions to which some organists resort in order
to make Baroque music more ‘exciting’. I have in mind particularly
my own reservations about Ton Koopman’s playing on a CD of Baroque
Christmas music, Puer nobis nascitur, (Challenge
Classics CC72234) which I recently reviewed, where I felt
that he pulled some of the music about.
I yield to none in my
admiration for Koopman at his best – which he almost always
is – and I have to admit that I seem to be in a minority of
one in respect of Puer nobis nascitur: I am amazed that
other reviewers have been able to praise both Koopman’s performances
of Daquin on that CD and those of Christopher Herrick on the
Hyperion Helios reissue of all the Daquin Noëls, when
the two approaches are as different as chalk and cheese. Actually,
I am not quite in a minority of one in questioning the way in
which Koopman sometimes pulls the music about: my fellow Musicweb
reviewer Chris Bragg also complained of Koopman’s dissident,
macho eccentricity in his review of Volumes I and II of the
complete organ works of Buxtehude (CC72242
and CC72243). Specifically, CB complained of fast tempi
and violently over-active touch, leading to a lack of Affekt in
the music.
If Koopman and Herrick
represent extremes in their interpretation of the Daquin Noëls,
Quist definitely falls into the Herrick camp, allowing the music
to speak for itself without trying to dress it up, yet never
allowing their playing to seem lacking in expression. Well-chosen
registration is part of the secret, as is arrangement of the
music in such a way as to allow the differences between the
pieces to be apparent. The charm of the quieter music and the
power of the larger-scale works are both made apparent here.
In general the programme
is arranged so that a quieter piece is followed by one in which
all the stops are pulled out. (Pun intended, I’m afraid.) Thus
Böhm’s Vater unser receives an ethereal performance with
effective use of the tremulant, immediately followed by the
Krebs Toccata and Fugue, a larger-scale work which provides
excellent contrast with the Böhm. The Bach setting of Allein
Gott which follows returns to a quieter mood.
The tremulant in the Böhm
is never allowed to sound kitsch and the registration in the
Krebs is never so heavy that the listener loses track of the
underlying melody. The Kampen organ does not possess anything
larger than 16' stops, so there is no temptation to overload
the music with the use of 32' tone – a generally unsuitable
practice in Baroque music which some organists nevertheless
indulge in – but I doubt whether Quist would have been tempted
anyway.
Eighteenth-century Lutherans
would, of course, have recognised the cantus firmus of
the liturgical settings which underlie Vater unser and Allein
Gott in der Höh, the Lord’s Prayer and Gloria in excelsis respectively.
Modern listeners are much less well placed to pick out the underying
tunes, but the fault cannot be laid at Quist’s door: he neither
sinks them under heavy registration nor brings them out artificially.
The excellent, light-fingered
performance of the opening Buxtehude Toccata sets the
tone for the whole recording. In Buxtehude’s anniversary year
it is appropriate that three of the tracks on this CD offer
music by him, but it is for the concluding Bach pieces that
many will want this disc. In a very real sense the music of
the preceding century leads inexorably to Bach and the four
pieces here represent a fair cross-section of his organ music:
two ‘Leipzig’ Chorale Preludes, a Trio Sonata and
a Prelude and Fugue, all probably dating originally from
his time at Weimar, though the Preludes seem to have been revised
several times thereafter.
The fade at the end of
each piece provides an indication of the ambience of the Bovenkerk
but neither the reverberation nor the recording in general ever
intrudes on my enjoyment of the music, allowing me to imagine
that I am in the church listening to the recital. As usual when
I am unaware of the recording for good or ill, I am very pleased
with the result.
All in all, the title
of the recording is very apt: Eric Quist is a real Inventio,
a true find. I look forward to hearing him again soon – I hope
that Herr Versluis will make that possible.
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.