Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
David
Ashley WHITE (b. 1944) Praise The Spirit
see end of review for track listing
Alan Austin (violin), Martha Chapman (violin),
Brady Knapp (baritone),
Garrett Martin (trumpet),
Patty Moeling (flute),
Sarah Oldrin (soprano),
Johanna Peske (oboe),
Celeste Proffitt (percussion),
Laurie Robertson (soprano),
Mitzi Sotrey (recorder),
Brian Vogel (percussion),
David Ashley White (keyboard),
Laura Witt (harp),
Ann Frohbieter (organ)
Choir of Palmer Memorial Church/Brady Knapp and Courtney Daniell-Knapp
(directors)
rec. 9-10 January 2004; 26 October 2004; 24th-25
February 2005; 17 June 2006; 7 July 2006, Palmer Memorial
Episcopal Church, Houston Texas. GOTHIC RECORDS
G49254 [74.25]
David
Ashley White is the director of the University of Houston’s
Moores School Music where he holds the Chair in music. He has
taught at the university since 1977. White has produced a considerable
body of work, some of which has found its way onto CD. This
new disc focuses on White’s pieces written for liturgical use
at the church. The choir of Palmer Church has a long association
with White: they have sung his music for thirty years and he
has composed a number of pieces especially for them.
Palmer
Church choir numbers around fifty adults - the booklet refers
to the adult choir so I assume there is a children’s choir as
well - and is directed by husband and wife team Brady and Courtney
Knapp. They have quite a high profile and have toured the UK
where they have had residencies at Trinity College and Clare
College, Cambridge.
The
CD booklet describes Palmer Church as being Anglo-Catholic.
But the selection of music on this disc would firmly fit into
the mould of mainstream Anglican Hymnody, Anglican Psalmody
and Worship song; there are no mass settings or Marian hymns.
White
obviously has a great gift for melody and an interesting ear
for timbre. All the pieces here are well crafted and sound rewarding
and uplifting to sing. They must make a very strongly positive
contribution to worship. The textures of the pieces is amazingly
varied and White manages to avoid the standard choir and organ
hymnody by using accompaniment in a spare fashion, including
an imaginative use of bells and other instruments.
White’s
selection of texts is catholic, ranging from a hymn by Clement
of Alexandria, through the Psalms to contemporary writers.
Only
in a couple of places does White let rip with the organ, so
we do not get the chance to appreciate the full capacity of
the 1991 Fisk organ in the church. Organist Anne Frohbieter
confidently accompanies the choir.
My
main complaint about the disc is that the selection of pieces
does not include any substantial ones. There are a total of
27 items, ranging in duration from 1:22 to 5:55. By the end
of the disc I felt that I had been exposed to too many attractive,
short pieces, that the programme was a little insubstantial.
This is not to decry White’s talent; all of the music on the
disc sounds attractive and useful.
It
is this word ‘useful’ that is the key. With an average duration
of between 2 and 3 minutes these works are ideally constructed
to fit into a service. The disc displays White’s ability to
produce short, melodic pieces as a useful and important part
of worship. A complete sequence of these does not necessarily
make a satisfactory programme, nor does it give a complete picture
of White’s talent.
The
CD booklet includes all the words for the pieces and a short
introduction by the composer. I would have liked, however, a
little more detail about the origin and usage of each item on
the disc.
The
music on this disc is very well sung by the choir and it makes
a brilliant showcase for them. But I am not sure that the disc
as a whole makes a satisfying recital. For those interested
in contemporary sacred music then this disc would be excellent
to dip into.
Robert Hugill
Track listing
Spirit, moving over chaos [3.50]
Comfort, comfort, ye my people [2.31]
The Apple Tree [3.09]
Adam lay y’bounden [1.37]
Conceived in the autumn [1.48]
The Kingdom of Love [2.42]
Come all my partners in distress [2.06]
Are you weary of your burden [3.12]
God is One [1.22]
Love came down at Christmas [1.40]
Sweet was the song [1.51]
Alleluia, song of gladness [2.14]
True Anointed One [3.16]
No More a Stranger or a Guest [4.44]
Memento, Domine [5.55]
As the Father Has Loved Me [2.33]
O hilarious light [3.12]
So the day dawn [2.37]
Our holy tribute, this [3.25]
A fanfare for St. Antony [2.22]
Bread of heaven [2.40]
O taste and see [1.43]
Come, pure hearts [2.17]
O Love divine [3.28]
God so loved the world [2.26]
Into the woods my Master went [2.55]
King of glory, King of Peace [2.31]
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.