Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Michael
JARRELL (b. 1958) ...prisme/incidences... (1998)a [15:02] Sillages (2005)b [17:06] Trois Etudes de Debussy (1992) [12:49] Abschied (2001)c [19:05]
Hae-Sun
Kang (violin)a; Emmanuel Pahud (flute)b;
Paul Meyer (clarinet)b; François Leleux (oboe)b;
Marino Formenti (piano)c
Orchestre de la Suisse Romande/Pascal Rophé
rec. Victoria Hall, Geneva, July, October, December 2005 AEON AECD0752 [64:39]
Michael
Jarrell’s ...Prisme/incidences... for violin
and orchestra is structured as a large-scale arch. The music
starts hesitantly with the violin playing a repeated note.
The ambit progressively widens while the orchestra joins
in with increasing vehemence. Most of the time the soloist
holds the front rank in turn opposing the massive orchestral
forces and being engulfed by them. The music of the soloist
is often of meditative character although it never shies
away from nervous outbursts either in response to the orchestra’s
angry assaults or in an attempt to assert itself. As is now
often the case in similar concertante works, the orchestra
often functions as a huge resonating box for the soloist’s
part. This is not a proper concerto, but rather a piece in
which the soloist often appears as a primus inter pares;
and, although it is not designed to showcase the soloist’s
virtuosity, the solo part is nonetheless demanding both in
terms of technique and – most importantly – of musicality.
Hae-Sung Kang, whom I heard last year in Pintscher’s en
sourdine - a work similar to Jarrell’s - is a beautifully
equipped musician whose assured technique unquestionably
equals musicality. She is the perfect soloist for such a
demanding work as this, which she plays with confidence and
commitment.
Sillages is scored for three wind soloists (flute, clarinet and oboe) and
orchestra. The title aptly suggests what the music is about: “undulations,
waves, backwash or eddies”. It is also clearly reflected
in the fluid writing for the solo winds. The music appropriately
enough moves in waves, at times mighty or peaceful, in a
succession of strongly contrasting moods. Again not a virtuosic
concerto. Yet another work calling for confident technique
and musicality, which this formidable trio of soloists possesses
in plenty.
“The
initial idea was that of a spiral developing almost infinitely”.
This is how Jarrell originally conceived his work for piano
and orchestra Abschied. Personal events, in
fact his father’s death when he was at work on this piece,
had some impact on the structure, which is roughly laid-out
in two sections played without a break. The opening torrential
section - an unrelenting Toccata - clearly reflects the composer’s
original intent, whereas the second is conceived as a gesture
of farewell (“Abschied” in German), although it too is not
without its angry moments.
Trois
Etudes de Debussy is
the only purely orchestral work and the earliest work
in this release. Debussy’s Preludes and
some other piano pieces been orchestrated before - one
thinks of Colin Matthews’ orchestration; there have been
others - but the Etudes do not seem to
have attracted as much attention. There may be purely
practical or technical reasons that have prevented composers
attempting an orchestration. Jarrell, however, took up
the challenge by scoring three of the Etudes: Pour
les notes répétées, Pour les sonorités opposées and Pour
les accords … and quite successfully. His scoring
for standard orchestra, such as Debussy himself might
have used, sounds perfectly “Debussy-ish” and is nicely
balanced without overdoing Debussy’s music. Jarrell does
not make these short piano works larger than life. In
short, these orchestrations are superbly done and quite
enjoyable.
I have long been ‘hooked’ by
Michael Jarrell’s music which I find gripping, often beautiful
and strongly communicative for all its complexity. There
are no exceptions here and all the pieces are well served
by committed and convincing readings. The recording and the
production are well up to Aeon’s high-quality standards.
A magnificent release.
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.