Vladimir Ashkenazy made some excellent recordings during the 1990s.
Many slipped into the deletion lists as his record label, Decca,
began to suffer in the well-documented recording crises that
beset the "major" labels. Arkiv has given some of
these recordings a new lease of life through its "on demand"
high quality CD-R initiative. Among them is this disc of Borodin,
which Ashkenazy recorded towards the end of his time as Music
Director of the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra.
Borodin's symphonies had a long gestation, a result of Borodin's hectic
work as a trail-blazing scientist and, in his spare time, a
campaigner for women's rights. He lived to complete two symphonies;
the third was completed and orchestrated by Glazunov after Borodin's
death. We must be grateful for what we have, though, as of
all of the Mighty Handful, Borodin had an ear for melody that
not even Rimsky-Korsakov could match.
Ashkenazy's accounts of Borodin's two completed symphonies are not
high octane, blood and thunder accounts. For that approach,
look to Svetlanov
or Tjeknavorian.
Ashkenazy's approach is gentler, though still idiomatic, and
offers an alternative interpretative point of view that is well
worth hearing.
The first symphony is characterised by an almost Mendelssohnian lightness
under Ashkenazy's baton. Tempi are danceable. Ashkenazy caresses
the flowing melodies of the first movement and the third movement
andante, but allows his orchestra to hit accents with impact.
The chattering winds and strings in the scherzo are lovely -
I was reminded here of the scherzo from Tchaikovsky's third
suite for orchestra. The final allegro molto vivo is smiling
and sprightly, shooting out sparks rather than blazing like
a bonfire.
The second symphony opens with dark colours but does not explode as
it does in some accounts. The brighter major key passages jostle
with darker minor interjections from snarling strings and brass.
The scherzo, once past its eye-widening opening chord, is light
and airy but not without impact. The opening of the andante
is gorgeous, with the principle French horn intoning the long
solo that opens the movement with great sensitivity. Colours
darken as the music builds, though. The finale has an exciting
almost wild west cut and thrust. The voltage could be higher,
but this rendition remains charming, highlighting the tuneful
inventiveness of Borodin's writing. Not exhilarating, then,
but delightful.
In an intelligent stroke of programming, the two symphonies are introduced,
and not followed, by Borodin's gorgeous tone poem, In the
Steppes of Central Asia. Ashkenazy's account is gently
evocative, but he maintains a flowing tempo and resists the
temptation to wallow.
I have not heard much from the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra in recent
years, but certainly in the early to mid 1990s they remained
an excellent ensemble. Under Ashkenazy's baton, they approach
this music with a full romantic sweep, clear textures and excellent
ensemble. There is some charming solo work from the woodwinds,
in the finale of the second symphony for example or the chattering
scherzos of both, and crisp articulation from all concerned.
The strings, though not opulent, have warmth and bloom and the
brass are imposing without being brash.
Sonically, this disc offers a very satisfying experience, with the
warm, clear and well balanced sound.
If you appreciate the picturesque and lyrical qualities of Borodin's
music, then this disc is for you.
Tim Perry
[69:35]
