Editorial Board
MusicWeb International
Founding Editor Rob Barnett Editor in Chief
John Quinn Contributing Editor Ralph Moore Webmaster
David Barker Postmaster
Jonathan Woolf MusicWeb Founder Len Mullenger
Francis POULENC (1899-1963) The Carmelites - Opera in three acts(1953-56)
Libretto by the composer after Georges Bernanos' play Dialogue
des Carmélites, revised English version by Joseph Machlis
Ashley Holland
(baritone) - Marquis de la Force
Catrin Wyn-Davies (soprano) - Blanche de la Force
Peter Wedd (tenor) - Chevalier de la Force
Gary Coward (baritone) - Thierry
Natalie Herman (soprano) - Off-stage voice
Felicity Palmer (mezzo) - Madame de Croissy
Josephine Barstow (soprano) - Mother Marie
Orla Boylan (soprano) - Madame Lidoine
Sarah Tynan (soprano) - Sister Constance
Jane Powell (mezzo) - Mother Jeanne
Anne Marie Gibbons (mezzo) - Sister Mathilde
Ryland Davies (tenor) - The Chaplain
William Berger (baritone) - Monsieur Javelinot
James Edwards (tenor) - First Commissioner
Roland Wood (baritone) - Second Commissioner
Toby Stafford-Allen (baritone) - First Officer
David Stephenson (baritone) - Gaoler
English National Opera Orchestra and Chorus/Paul Daniel
rec. Blackheath Halls, London, 20-26 October 2005. DDD. CHANDOS
CHAN 3134(2) [79.50 + 64.25]
It
was my distinct pleasure to review for Seen
and Heard ENO’s production of The Carmelites when
it was last staged in October 2005. What struck me most then
was the power inherent in Phyllida Lloyd’s staging, although
the particularly strong lead quartet of Catrin Wyn-Davies,
Felicity Palmer, Josephine Barstow and Sarah Tynan left their
mark with indelible contributions too.
This
recording, made at much the same time as that run of performances,
highlights several aspects of Poulenc’s musical personality
that are intertwined within the piece. The Carmelites is
Poulenc’s most complex statement on the personal nature of
religious belief and the sacrifice that it can often require
those most devoted to it to make. Being closer in spirit
to the world of the Gloria than the seemingly carefree Parisian
ambiance that imbues the piano concerto, for example, it
is a work that must be performed with reverence but without
becoming over-sanctified in the process. The stories of Blanche
de la Force, Madame de Croissy, Sister Constance and the
other nuns are first and foremost human stories, then religious
ones. Personal terror is played out against state terror,
and as such the consuming mood is one of fear that never
dissipates throughout the entire duration of the piece.
Inevitably
this recording raises the issue of language and performance. I
found Joseph Machlis’ English translation to be sympathetic
to the spirit of Poulenc’s own libretto. If any are troubled
by the idea of hearing The Carmelites in translation,
I would merely point out that the work was commissioned for
La Scala, Milan, and was first given there in Italian during
the 1957 season. A reasonable recording from that production
exists, featuring Romanian soprano Virginia Zeani as a very
fine Blanche de la Force, should anyone wish to seek it out.
A pity that another Romanian, Leontina Vaduva, was not heard
often enough in the role when she took it into her repertoire. Inevitably
though any newcomer has to stand its ground against Dervaux’s
classic account for EMI, recorded under the supervision of
the composer (Great Recordings of the Century 562 751-2).
I
have to say I think Paul Daniel’s recording holds its own
pretty well in terms of the dynamic pacing and sense of energy
he draws from the ENO orchestra. Indeed, hearing playing
of this calibre makes you wonder why the two parted company
as they did. Daniel manages to capture an edge in the distinctly
Poulencian orchestral timbres that stick firmly in the mind
and register over a long period the inevitability of the
drama’s final outcome.
The
cast is understandably dominated by the women in it, though
the male roles play a crucial role also. I still feel that
vocally at least Felicity Palmer steals the show as Madame
de Croissy, such is the power of her characterisation. It
is given with absolute commitment, but no less might be said
of Catrin Wyn-Davies, who sings Blanche de la Force with
unimpeachable musicality and awareness of tone, line and
nuance, but overall Denise Duval for Dervaux has the edge
as Blanche. Sarah Tynan’s Sister Constance continues to be
a considerable highlight in an already distinguished career.
Perhaps one day there may be a Blanche to set amongst the
best to come from her? The other sisters are a well-matched
group vocally, giving their parts with passion and feeling
to reinforce the point that they are no mere extras in this
terrifying drama. Ashley Holland and Ryland Davies stand
out for their contributions amongst the men. David Stephenson’s
gaoler exerts his malevolent authority with ease.
Much
recommended then, whether you’re after a version in English
or an alternative to sit alongside EMI’s recording with Dervaux.
There is much to enjoy and move you in this recording.
Evan Dickerson
Reviews
from previous months Join the mailing list and receive a hyperlinked weekly update on the
discs reviewed. details We welcome feedback on our reviews. Please use the Bulletin
Board
Please paste in the first line of your comments the URL of the review to
which you refer.